IEEE P802.3aq 10GBASE-LRM Task Force
Comments against draft documents

D3.2 comments following May 06 meeting 31 May 2006
D3.2 comments with alternative responses 19 May 2006
Possible changes to Clause 51 19 May 2006
D3.2 comments with responses 4 May 2006

D3.1 comments following March 06 meeting 23 March 2006
D3.1 comments as at 2pm 8 March 2006
D3.1 comments as received
Figure to support comment 35 Tom Lindsay

D3.0 ER, GR and TR comments following January 06 meeting 7 February 2006
D3.0 comments following January 06 meeting 6 February 2006
D3.0 comments following January 06 meeting - preliminary 18 January 2006
D3.0 comments as received
PRBS9 MDIO control comment Tom Lindsay (for comment 3)
PRBS9 MDIO control comment (revised) Tom Lindsay

Editor's report revised 24 November 2005
D2.4 all comments following November 05 meeting 23 November 2005
D2.4 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 16 November 2005
D2.4 comments as received

D2.3 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 24 November 2005
D2.3 all comments following October 05 meeting 16 October 2005
D2.3 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 15 October 2005
D2.3 comments as received

D2.2 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 24 November 2005
D2.2 all comments following September 05 meeting 22 September 2005
D2.2 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 22 September 2005, with selected D2.0 comments as agreed
D2.2 comments as received

D2.1 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 24 November 2005
D2.1 all comments following July 05 meeting 8 August 2005
D2.1 unsatisfied TR and ER negative comments as at 8 August 2005
D2.1 comments plus D2.0 comments from recirculation pack 18 July 2005: comments 1062 and 1076 corrected, some proposed responses
D2.1 comments as received plus D2.0 comments from recirculation pack (comment 1023 corrected 15 July 2005)
Re Placement of Noise Source after Filtering, Ernie Bergmann (for comment 1142)
Proposed replacement Fig 68-10 Mike Dudek (for comment 1050)

D2.0 unsatisfied TR negative comments as at 24 November 2005
D2.0 unsatisfied TR and ER negative comments as at 8 August 2005
D2.0 comments following June 05 meeting Revised 25 June 2005
D2.0 unsatisfied unresolved TR and ER negative comments
D2.0 other ("lack of consensus") unresolved negative comments Revised 25 June 2005
D2.0 comments following May 05 meeting
List of D2.0 comments asking for further study
D2.0 editorial comments with proposed responses 18 May 2005
D2.0 comments with some proposed responses 13 May 2005
D2.0 comments as received
Figure for jitter measurement, Tom Lindsay
Proposed changes for TWDP code, Tom Lindsay

D1.1 comments from precirculation to 802.3 as resolved in Atlanta
D1.1 comments from task force as resolved in Atlanta
D1.1 comments from precirculation to 802.3
D1.1 comments with proposed responses
D1.1 comments 1 March
Supporting document for comment 96, TWDP code, Tom Lindsay

D1.0 comments as resolved at Vancouver meeting
For comment 70 (revised)
For comment 103 (revised)
For comment 106 (revised)
D1.0 comments as received
Test figure (for subclauses 68.6.5.3 & 68.6.5.4) for comment 93 and 103 Tom Lindsay
Proposals for 68.6.4, OMA:rms noise ratio for comment 99 Nick Weiner
Figure for TP2 jitter for comment 115 Tom Lindsay File renamed 11 Jan 04
Informative description of TWDP algorithm for comment 110 Norm Swenson, Paul Voois, Tom Lindsay, Steve Zeng
Text for receiver sensitivity clauses for comment 118 Lew Aronson

D0.2 comments following San Antonio meeting
Supporting document for comment 109, for D0.2 as resolved
D0.2 comments as received
Supporting document for comment 109, for D0.2 as received

Return to IEEE P802.3aq public page
Last Update: 1 June 2006