Nov ‘96 MAC group Report
Misc Subjects
•	Previous MAC minutes approved.
Status for week
•	We got close but there are some comments we did not have time to process.
•	The rest of the report represents how far we got during this week. 
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 1
–	No comments made in LB
–	all comments processed.
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 2
–	no additional comments processed for R4.
–	all comments processed.
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 3
–	no additional comments processed for R4.
–	all comments processed.
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 4
–	no additional comments processed for R4.
–	all comments processed.
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clauses 0-4
–	R2 Mac Vote: 10, 0, 2
–	Plenary Vote: 25, 0, 2
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 5
–	A few additional comments processed for R4, all minor or with reviewer consent.
–	All No technical comments processed.
–	Comments not processed yet:
»	24,26,32,41,47,48,49
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 5
–	R2 Mac Vote: 9, 0, 3
–	R3 MAC Vote: 7, 0, 1
–	R4 Mac Vote: 14, 0, 2
–	Plenary Vote: 26, 1, 2
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 6
–	Comments not processed:
»	2, 6, 7
–	c6, #1 - encryption vs bcast and mcast frames resolved
»	ok with commentor
»	Text not complete to reflect this - will complete if adopted by end of day.
»	this would impact several open coments in other clauses - they are left open in R4, we will update comment tables when text delivered by Mike F..
»	MAC vote: 15, 0, 2
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 6
–	R2 Mac Vote: 9, 0, 4
–	Plenary Vote: 25, 0, 1
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 7
–	no additional comments processed for R4.
–	all comments processed.
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 7
–	R2 Mac Vote: 10, 0, 3
–	Plenary Vote: 26, 0, 2
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 8
–	A few additional comments processed for R4, all minor.
–	All No technical comments processed.
–	Comments not processed:
»	1,4,7,10,11,13,23,31-35
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 8
–	R3 Mac Vote: 6, 0, 3
–	Plenary Vote: 26, 0, 2
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 9 
–	unprocessed tech no vote: C#12 (state machines)
–	No additional decsions made for R4
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 9
–	R2 Mac Vote: 17, 0, 3
–	Plenary Vote: 27, 0, 0
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 10
–	Comments accepted for R4
»	4,5,6,7,9 
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 10
–	R2 Mac Vote: 13, 0, 6
–	R4 Mac Vote: 13, 0, 3
–	Plenary Vote: 22, 0, 5
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause 11
–	all comments now done.
–	On Wed eve accepted for R4:
»	55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 64, 76, 84
–	Comments accepted Thurs morn:
»	63, 88, 96, 106
»	88,  118
–	117 not accepted - author withdrew
–	Text work needed in C11 due to C10 changes - this may take a lot of time.
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause 11
–	R2 Mac Vote: 14, 0, 3
–	R3 Mac Vote: 8, 0, 1
–	R4 Mac Vote: 13, 0, 4
–	Plenary Vote: 27, 0, 3
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause A
–	no new R4 decisons.
–	Clause 9 #120 impacts A4.5 - referred to PHY group
»	appears that PHY has already handled the comment, hence the C9 file should have this # updated to match PHY resolution.
–	there is some text editing to do to make annex A match clause 11 sec reorg.
–	Pics needs to be updated to match this weeks work.
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause A
–	R2 Mac Vote: 11, 0, 5
–	Plenary Vote: 26, 0, 2
R3->R4 summary
•	Clause G
–	2 comments
»	#1 handled in plenary,
»	#2 re # of “shalls” vs PICs
•	Moved: that we resp decline and comment author be asked to identify which shalls he thinks are supurflous.
MAC resolution adoption vote
•	Clause G
–	R4 Mac Vote: 15, 0, 1
–	Plenary Vote: 25, 0, 2
MAC group report 
•	That’s all for now...