Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [STDS-802-11-TGAX] [STDS-802-11-TGAX PHY adhoc] Adjourn for this week

Hello, TGax colleagues,

I hope you all have a good rest after Jul meeting.

Though we will not have PHY adhoc meeting in this week, our target is still to finish all the PHY comments in next week's IEEE meeting. We still have around 162 comments to be resolved. After some offline discussion and re-assignment, the updated PHY comments assignment is as below.

I wish all the assignees (including some MAC experts) will attend next week's IEEE meeting and have the comment resolution ready. If there's problem with any comment resolution, please let me know asap. I'll try leaving some time in next week's PHY adhoc for those PHY CIDs without resolution.

Assignee Unresolved CIDs after Jul Clause Target Time
Bo Sun 81 28.2.2 (TXVECTOR/RXVECTOR) (11-17/1001r2) Sep
Xiaogang Chen 13 8172 (17.5.2.3), 9793, 9148, 7238, 4970, 8604, 7239, 9149, 9150, 7240 (28.3.3.2), 5292 (28.3.6.6), 9084 (transmitter block), 7855 (CSD) Sep
Sigurd 1 4917 Sep
Lochan 3 6433, 8348, 7894 (9.4.2.218.3, 26.1.1) Sep
Ron 1 8093 (28.3.10.7.2); (Solution: rejected. Confirmed by the commenter) Sep
Hongyuan 38 37 for midamble PHY  (including 5246, 5753, 5090)+ 9082; CID 3403 is duplicated and rejected by Editor Sep
Yongho 1 9735 Sep
Sung Eun Lee 9 9765, 8806, 7237, 8808, 7827, 10382 (28.3.3.5, 28.3.3.6 , 20 MHz only);
9153, 8811, 8810 (28.3.3.6). 		Sep
Liwen 2 3124 (8.4.2.218.1), 7376 (9.4.2.218.3) Sep
Abhishek Patil 1 8172 (17.5.2.3) Sep
Editor 1 8055 (28) Sep
Jian Yu 1 6120 (28.3.11.3) (Withdrawn by the commenter) Sep
Junghoon Suh 1 10374 (28.3.3.4) Sep
Osama 1 1703 (Annex G) Sep
Sean Coffey 1 10411 (9.4.2.218.3) Sep
Yusuke Asai 1 10182 (3.2) Sep
Yujin 1 8576 (Target RSSI) Sep
Transferred to MAC 1 7778 (9.7.3) (Liwen will take it)
Returned 5 8869, 6116, 5263, 10228, 9042 Sep
Total 162 Sep



Best Regards,

Sun, Bo




发件人:         Bo Sun <sun.bo1@xxxxxxxxxx>
收件人:         STDS-802-11-TGAX@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx,
日期:         2017/07/13 07:39
主题:        [STDS-802-11-TGAX] [STDS-802-11-TGAX PHY adhoc] Adjourn for this week
发件人:        "*** 802.11 TGax - HEW - High Efficiency WLAN ***" <STDS-802-11-TGAX@xxxxxxxx>



Hello, all,

PHY adhoc has completed all its sessions in this week. We proceeded almost all the submission except 11-17/1001. Please check 11-17/1099r4 for latest progress update.

Assuming all of the PHY CR motions pass in this meeting, PHY adhoc still has 168 un-resolved CIDs to handle. I listed all the un-resolved CIDs as below. Among all these un-resolved CIDs,
  -  125 CIDs are regarding to txvector/rxvector, midamble or 20MHz only;
  -  there're 5 CIDs resolved in past meeting but returned by TG editor which I listed in another table as below;
  -  there're 5 CIDs transferred into PHY adhoc but not assigned. We need volunteer to handle these 5 CIDs.
  -  there're some CIDs assigned to people who are typically working in MAC adhoc and may have no time to handle these PHY CIDs. We may need volunteer to handle these CIDs for them. If any assignee needs extra help to finish the CR, you may find a volunteer to help you or please let me and PHY adhoc know.  

The target for PHY adhoc in Sep meeting is to complete all the PHY adhoc CIDs. And PHY adhoc decided not to have adhoc meeting before IEEE meeting. To accomplish that target without adhoc meeting, it's better for us to reach consensus before Sep meeting on 3 major topics: Midamble, TXVECTOR/RXVETOR and 20 MHz only. I will send out an independent email to trigger TXVECTOR/RXVECTOR cr email review. Please Hongyuan and Sung Eun help to coordinate the midamble and 20 MHz only cr email review respectively.  

Thank you very much for your collaboration!
Assignee Unresolved CIDs after Jul Clause Target Time
Bo Sun 81 28.2.2 (TXVECTOR/RXVECTOR) Sep
Shahrnaz Azizi 9 8172 (17.5.2.3), 9793, 9148, 7238, 4970, 8604, 7239, 9149, 9150, 7240 (28.3.3.2) Sep
Sigurd 1 4917 Sep
Lochan 3 6433, 8348, 7894 (9.4.2.218.3, 26.1.1) Sep
Ron 1 8093 (28.3.10.7.2) Sep
Hongyuan 37 36 for midamble PHY  (including 5246, 5753)+ 9082 Sep
Yongho 7 4719, 4718, 6938, 7296, 7297, 6939, 9735 Sep
Sung Eun Lee 6 9765, 8806, 7237, 8808, 7827, 10382 (28.3.3.5, 28.3.3.6 , 20 MHz only) Sep
Guoqing 3 9153, 8811, 8810 (28.3.3.6) Sep
Liwen 2 3124 (8.4.2.218.1), 7376 (9.4.2.218.3) Sep
Abhishek Patil 1 8172 (17.5.2.3) Sep
Editor 1 8055 (28) Sep
Jian Yu 1 6120 (28.3.11.3) Sep
Junghoon Suh 1 10374 (28.3.3.4) Sep
Osama 1 1703 (Annex G) Sep
Sean Coffey 1 10411 (9.4.2.218.3) Sep
Xiaogang 1 5292 (28.3.6.6) Sep
Yusuke Asai 1 10182 (3.2) Sep
Returned 5 8869, 6116, 5263, 10228, 9042 Sep
Un-assigned 5 5090 (Doppler),  8576 (Target RSSI), 7778 (9.7.3),  9084 (transmitter block), 7855 (CSD) Sep
Total 168 Sep


CID Past CR Assignee Reason of return Latest Status
8869 11-17/0316r4 Bin Tian Tech argument from Editor
5255 11-17/0305r2 Hongyuan Tech argument from Editor Resolved in 11-17/0993r2
6116 11-17/0398r1 Hongyuan Editor requests Visio diagram
5263 11-17/0398r1 Hongyuan Editor requests Visio diagram
10228 11-17/0234r3 Xiaogang No Reason
9042 11-17/0234r3 Xiaogang Editing instruction for subclause that does not exist.





Best Regards,

孙 波   Sun, Bo

  _______________________________________________________________________________

If you wish to be removed from this reflector, do not send your request to this reflector - it will have no effect.

Instead, go to http://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGAX and then press the LEAVE button.

Further information can be found at: http://www.ieee802.org/11/Email_Subscribe.html _______________________________________________________________________________

_______________________________________________________________________________

If you wish to be removed from this reflector, do not send your request to this reflector - it will have no effect.

Instead, go to http://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGAX and then press the LEAVE button.

Further information can be found at: http://www.ieee802.org/11/Email_Subscribe.html _______________________________________________________________________________