Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

[STDS-802-11-TGAX] Comment status

Hello All,

 

A new revision of the comment spreadsheet is available: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.11/dcn/19/11-19-0292-22-00ax-comments-on-tgax-d4-0.xlsx

 

This revision has the proposed resolutions that were strawpolled on the telecons. You can find these by filtering: Resn Status=<non blank> Motion Number = <blank>. I was working from the minutes and may not have captured everything.

 

I have also moved the approved resolutions into comment groups in the form <assignee><dcn><topic>. This is mainly for the summary below.

 

Here is a list of assignees with the number of comments assigned to them that have not been motioned or strawpolled:

Assignee

Comments without resolution

Matt Fischer

25

Alfred Asterjadhi

23

Srini Kandala

19

Yongho Seok

15

Menzo Wentink

11

Edward Au

9

Abhishek Patil

8

Zhou Lan

7

Liwen Chu

7

Laurent Cariou

6

David Kloper

6

Mark Rison

6

Ming Gan

5

Osama Aboul-Magd

5

Sameer Vermani

4

Tianyu Wu

4

Huizhao Wang

4

Lochan Verma

4

Kaiying Lv

3

David Yang

3

Jarkko Kneckt

3

Ron Porat

2

Youhan Kim

2

Po-Kai Huang

2

Chitto Ghosh

1

Hongyuan Zhang

1

Xiaogang Chen

1

Grand Total

186

 

 

And here is a more detailed summary:

Assignee

Count of CID

Resolution Drafted

Resolution Approved

Abhishek Patil

139

131

131

(blank)

4

 

 

6GHz out of band discovery

1

 

 

6 GHz inband discovery

1

 

 

PPDU format selection

1

 

 

Scanning

1

 

 

Abhi 19/0394 9.3.1.22

30

30

30

Abhi 19/436 11.1.4

8

8

8

Abhi 19/0395 BSS color

9

9

9

Abhi 19/479

1

1

1

Abhi 19/508r4 UORA

22

22

22

Abhi 19/548r1 TF format

4

4

4

Abhi 19/510r3 MU Operation

26

26

26

Abhi 19/506r3 Multi-BSSID

14

14

14

Abhi 19/505r2 BSS color

6

6

6

Abhi 19/1217r1 #21110

1

1

1

Abhi 19/1218r0 UORA Pt 2

3

3

3

Abhi 19/1148r2 Multi-BSS

6

6

6

Abhi 19/1147r1

1

1

1

Alfred Asterjadhi

219

196

192

(blank)

1

 

 

TWT

15

 

 

6GHz out of band discovery

2

 

 

6 GHz inband discovery

3

 

 

PPDU format selection

6

4

4

BSS operation

8

8

8

Alfred 19/305 TPC

2

2

2

Alfred 19/315 TWT PS

5

5

5

Alfred 19/301 HE beacon in 6 GHz

11

11

11

Alfred 19/316 BSR operation

5

5

5

Alfred 19/302 HE BSS

6

6

6

Alfred 19/593r0 Frame Control

2

2

2

Alfred 19/725r1 Individual TWT

18

18

18

Alfred 19/304r2 HE BSS in 6 GHz

14

14

14

Alfred 19/910r1 Fast Passive Scanning

15

15

15

Alfred 19/652r2 TWT Info frames

24

24

24

Alfred 19/303r4 QoS Control

18

18

18

Alfred 19/724r3 Broadcast TWT

13

13

13

Alfred 19/561r2 miscellaneous TWT

8

8

8

Alfred 19/0967r1 Fast Passive Scan Pt 2

4

4

 

Alfred 19/0965r16 GHz inband discovery

6

6

6

Alfred 19/1017r4 6 GHz channelization

4

4

4

Alfred 19/0962r4 Non-AP STA Scanning

17

17

17

Alfred 19/0909r3 6 GHz Scanning

3

3

3

Alfred 19/1061r0 HE FTM in 6 GHz

2

2

2

Alfred 19/0961r3 Group addressed MPDUs

3

3

3

Alfred 19/0309r1 Frame Control

4

4

4

Bo Sun

20

20

20

Bo 19/407 xVECTORS

17

17

17

Bo 19/0572r1

3

3

3

Brian Hart

48

48

47

Brian 18/1774r18 HE-SIG-B

46

46

46

Brian 19/1386r2 HE-SIG-B

1

1

 

Brian 19/1302r0

1

1

1

Chitto Ghosh

1

 

 

UORA

1

 

 

David Kloper

6

 

 

(blank)

5

 

 

TWT

1

 

 

David Yang

3

 

 

MU operation

3

 

 

Editor

377

377

368

Editorials Rejected

51

51

51

Withdrawn

9

9

 

Invalid Comment

3

3

3

Editorials in D4.1

112

112

112

Editorials in D4.2

154

154

154

Editorials updated 2019-06-27

7

7

7

Remaining Editorials

41

41

41

Edward Au

15

6

 

MIB

7

 

 

PICS

2

 

 

Edward 19/1235r1 MIB

5

5

 

Edward 19/1243r1 PICS

1

1

 

George Cherian

33

33

33

George 19/756r1 26.4 Ack procedure

27

27

27

George 19/1211r1 Ack

3

3

3

George 19/1306r1 Ack

3

3

3

Guoqing Li

6

6

 

Guoqing 19/1237r5 4.3.15a

6

6

 

Hongyuan Zhang

1

 

 

(blank)

1

 

 

Huizhao Wang

4

 

 

Duration-based RTS/CTS

4

 

 

Jarkko Kneckt

13

10

10

OM Control

3

 

 

Jarkko 19/1222r4

5

5

5

Jarkko 19/0696r11 OM Control

3

3

3

Jarkko 19/0447r1

2

2

2

Jianhan Liu

14

14

14

Jianhan 19/1127r4 HE-SIG-A

14

14

14

Kaiying Lv

30

27

27

QTP

3

 

 

Kaiying 19/1163r1 QTP

23

23

23

Kaiying 19/0494r3 BSS color

1

1

1

Kaiying 19/0835r3 PPDU classification

3

3

3

Kome Oteri

3

3

3

Kome 19/553r0 Beamforming feedback

3

3

3

Laurent Cariou

110

104

104

Spatial Reuse

1

 

 

NDP feedback

1

1

1

MU EDCA

3

 

 

6GHz out of band discovery

2

 

 

Laurent 19/416 SR

11

11

11

Laurent 19/413r2 MU EDCA Parameters

1

1

1

Laurent 19/415r2 OPS

5

5

5

Laurent 19/413r4 MU EDCA Parameters

18

18

18

Laurent 19/1161r4

13

13

13

Laurent 19/0414r3 NFRP

10

10

10

Laurent 19/1281r2 Last CIDs

5

5

5

Laurent 19/0416r4 SR

3

3

3

Laurent 19/0417r8 6 GHz out-of-band discovery

37

37

37

Liwen Chu

74

67

50

(blank)

2

 

 

A-MPDU operation

3

 

 

6 GHz multi-frame

2

 

 

Liwen 19/1035r4 26.6.4.2/4 (remaining)

5

5

 

Liwen 19/0748r2 26.2.8

2

2

 

Liwen 19/1387r4 Misc

5

5

 

Liwen 19/1417r1 26.6.3.1

5

5

 

Liwen 19/0750r4 9.7.3

11

11

11

Liwen 19/1023r4

11

11

11

Liwen 19/0734r3 9.7.3

15

15

15

Liwen 19/1035r1

4

4

4

Liwen 19/1336r3

4

4

4

Liwen 19/0737r2

2

2

2

Liwen 19/0735r7

3

3

3

Lochan Verma

11

7

7

(blank)

4

4

4

Trigger frame format

3

3

3

MU operation

4

 

 

Mark Rison

6

 

 

Editorials

1

 

 

(blank)

1

 

 

2019-03-28 telecon

4

 

 

Matt Fischer

25

 

 

(blank)

3

 

 

Spatial Reuse

15

 

 

UORA

4

 

 

Submission Required

1

 

 

Disallowed subchannels

2

 

 

Menzo Wentink

66

55

55

Sounding protocol

11

 

 

Menzo 19/863r2 Sounding protocol

44

44

44

Menzo 19/1137r1 Sounding protocol

11

11

11

Ming Gan

40

35

35

Fragmentation

5

 

 

Ming 19/745r1 9.4.2

6

6

6

Ming 19/785r1 Fragmentation

24

24

24

Ming 19/1185r3 HE-SIG-B

3

3

3

Ming 19/1184r1 MAC Misc

2

2

2

Osama Aboul-Magd

16

11

 

Editorials

1

 

 

(blank)

3

 

 

Annex G

1

1

 

Osama 19/1155r1 Misc

3

3

 

Osama 19/1259r1 Annex G

8

7

 

Po-Kai Huang

61

59

59

Multi-BSS

1

 

 

SM power save

1

 

 

Po-Kai 19/0288 HE Beacon

6

6

6

Po-Kai 19/0325 SMPS

4

4

4

Po-Kai 19/289 Multi-BSS Bug

13

13

13

Po-Kai 19/492 MU-RTS

14

14

14

Po-Kai 19/0604r5 NAV

12

12

12

Po-Kai 19/1014r2 NAV

6

6

6

Po-Kai 19/1009r1

2

2

2

Po-Kai 19/605r0 MU-RTS Pt 2

2

2

2

Ron Porat

8

6

6

Ron 19/386 Disallowed Subchannels

3

3

3

PHY Midambles

2

 

 

Ron 19/1188r0 PHY Misc

3

3

3

Ross Yu Jian

14

14

14

Ross 19/0971r0

2

2

2

Dandan 19/1125r2 HE-SIG-B

5

5

5

Ross 19/0972r1 HE-SIG-B

7

7

7

Sameer Vermani

15

11

11

PHY Intro

4

 

 

Sameer 19/385 27.1.1

8

8

8

Sameer 19/1271r0 PHY Misc

3

3

3

Srini Kandala

20

1

 

Editorials

2

 

 

PHY SAP

1

 

 

(blank)

16

 

 

Srini 19/0619r4 Select Comments

1

1

 

Tianyu Wu

16

12

12

(blank)

4

 

 

Tianyu 19/0703r0

12

12

12

Tomoko Adachi

13

13

13

Tomo 19/816r2 9.3.1.8

9

9

9

Tomo 19/1200r1 Block Ack

4

4

4

Xiaogang Chen

15

14

14

(blank)

1

 

 

Xiaogang 19/422

1

1

1

Xiaogang 19/0866r3 Misc

11

11

11

Xiaogang 19/0422r7

2

2

2

Yan Zhang

30

30

30

Yan 19/793r1 PHY Math

30

30

30

Yong Gang Fang

5

5

 

Fang 19/1458r2 26.17.6

5

5

 

Yongho Seok

55

40

40

TWT

1

 

 

Duration-based RTS/CTS

1

 

 

UL MU Power Capabilities

3

 

 

PPDU format selection

10

 

 

Yongho 19/770r2 PPDU format, BW, etc.

8

8

8

Yongho 19/0771r1 HE SST

10

10

10

Yongho 19/1141r2 Misc

8

8

8

Yongho 19/1139r1 26.17.4

3

3

3

Yongho 19/1140r1 UL MU Power Capabilities

8

8

8

Yongho 19/1138r1 HLA Control

3

3

3

Youhan Kim

77

75

75

(blank)

2

 

 

Youhan 19/379 Part 1

15

15

15

Youhan 19/378 Unused Tone EVM

1

1

1

Youhan 19/831r1 Part 2

15

15

15

Youhan 19/827r3 Punctured Non-HT

3

3

3

Youhan 19/826r1 DCM and STBC Combinations

3

3

3

Youhan 19/830r1 Clause 17

5

5

5

Youhan 19/836r0 Part 3

1

1

1

Youhan 19/837r1 HE Capabilities

10

10

10

Youhan 19/858r0 Clause 10

3

3

3

Youhan 19/1225r2

14

14

14

Youhan 19/1226r1

4

4

4

Youhan 19/1225r3

1

1

1

Yujin Noh

1

1

1

Yujin 19/0973r2

1

1

1

Yunbo Li

2

2

2

Yunbo 19/1130r1 RD

2

2

2

Zhou Lan

7

 

 

(blank)

2

 

 

A-MPDU operation

2

 

 

TWT

1

 

 

MU operation

1

 

 

Submission Required

1

 

 

Grand Total

1619

1433

1373

 

-Robert

 

 

 

To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGAX list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGAX&A=1