Thanks Liwen, please see my responses inline.
For the sentence The Broadcast TWT Recommendation is set to 0, 4 or 5 if transmitted by a restricted TWT scheduled STA, and otherwise is reserved if transmitted by a TWT scheduled STA. I have the following comment: It is not clear why 0 is allowed for Broadcast TWT Recommendation for r-TWT.
r-TWT scheduled STAs may also establish membership in bTWT schedules (which are not rTWT schedules). So in these cases r-TWT scheduled STAs need to specify the value 0.
My understanding (checked with Alfred) is that TWT scheduled STAs set this subfield to 0 for bTWT schedules because this subfield is reserved as per baseline. So we keep the same for r-TWT scheduled STAs (which are also TWT scheduled STAs) signaling for bTWT schedules, whereas they may set it to 4/5 for rTWT schedules. If you have suggestions for improvement please let me know.
For the last paragraph in the document, I have the following comment: An AP announces the r-TWT with Broadcast TWT Recommendation 5 in Beacon frame needs to have Triggered TXOP Sharing Mode 2 Support equal to 1. The if condition in the last paragraph for AP is not needed.
Thanks for pointing out, I will revise the draft based on your suggestion.
Best Regards, Liwen Caution: EXT Email
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBE list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBE&A=1
|