|
Hello Mark H.,
I have the following proposed resolutions for the identified CIDs:
|
CID |
Name |
Category |
Page |
Subclause |
Line |
Comment |
Must be Satisfied |
Proposed Change |
Assignee |
Submission |
Resolution Type |
Resolution Text |
|
4032
|
RISON, Mark |
Technical
|
|
9 |
|
The IRM Active field in the RSNXE seems to have been renamed to IRM Support, but there are still references to an
IRM Active field. Or are there two fields now, one to indicate support and one to indicate activation? I note the MIB attribute is still called dot11IRMActivated, not dot11IRMSupport |
Yes |
As it says in the comment |
Robert Stacey |
|
REVISED |
The IRM Active field was renamed and is now called the IRM Support field. There are still instances of the old name
present in the draft. At 59.04, 59.05, 60.09, 60.12, 61.13, 61.15, 63.04, and 63.06 change "IRM Active field" to "IRM Support field" |
|
4033
|
RISON, Mark |
Technical
|
|
AG |
|
"Device ID Active field" -- no such field |
Yes |
As it says in the comment |
Robert Stacey |
|
REVISED |
The Device ID Active field was renamed and is now called the Device ID Support field. There are still instances
of the old name present in the draft. At 54.37, 54.39, 55.53, 55.54, 57.08, 57.11, and 63.04 change "Device ID Active field" to "Device ID Support field" |
|
4052
|
RISON, Mark |
Technical
|
|
9.4.2.240 |
|
It's not clear why IRM/Device ID Support are about whether something is "active", while KEK In PASN is about whether
it's "support"ed. Can the latter be supported but not active? |
Yes |
Probably best to talk about active everywhere, since this is less ambiguous |
Robert Stacey |
|
REVISED |
Since the behavioral descriptions of the device ID and the IRM mechanisms in 12.2.13.1 and 12.2.13.2, respectively,
use the term "support", it would be better to use the same term in the field description. This would also better align with the description of the KEK In PASN field.
In the "Notes" column at 28.62 and 29.06, change "active" to "supported". |
Regards,
-Robert
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBH list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBH&A=1
|