[STDS-802-11-TGM] Comment resolution status

Thread Links	Date Links
Thread Prev	Thread Next	Thread Index	Date Prev	Date Next	Date Index

Dear TGm members,

This email contains statistics for comment resolution status.

The big picture:

Ballot/Draft	Unassigned	Needs submission	Assigned	Discuss	Defer	Review	Resolution Drafted	Ready for Motion	Approved	Grand Total
199	106	5	41	21	1	25	1	1	296	497
EDITOR					1			1	296	298
GEN	54	1	14	20		25	1			115
MAC	52	4	27	1						84
Grand Total	106	5	41	21	1	25	1	1	296	497

With some detail:

Ballot/Draft	Unassigned	Needs submission	Assigned	Discuss	Defer	Review	Resolution Drafted	Ready for Motion	Approved	Grand Total
199	106	5	41	21	1	25	1	1	296	497
EDITOR					1			1	296	298
201311 approved									189	189
(blank)					1					1
Gen Motion Dallas C									5	5
Motion MAC-R									43	43
Editor motion								1		1
Motion MAC-S									25	25
Gen Motion LA 1									13	13
Motion MAC-T									5	5
Gen Motion Telecon 1									16	16
GEN	54	1	14	20		25	1			115
11ad related	1		1							2
Gen Review						14	1			15
Personal vs Directional	1		1	1		1				4
Submission requested		1	6							7
(blank)	31		2	12		1				46
May with Might	21			7		9				37
Deprecation			4							4
MAC	52	4	27	1						84
(blank)	52	4	27	1						84
Grand Total	106	5	41	21	1	25	1	1	296	497

The assignees:

Assignee	GEN	MAC	Grand Total
Adrian Stephens	1	1	2
Brian Hart	1	8	9
Dan Harkins	1	1	2
Dorothy Stanley	4	1	5
Graham Smith	1	1	2
Jon Rosdahl	1		1
Mark Hamilton	2	8	10
Mark RISON	1		1
Matthew Fischer		4	4
Qi Wang		1	1
Mark RISON, Guido HIERTZ, Adrian STEPHENS	1		1
Carlos Cordiero	1	2	3
Grand Total	14	27	41

The unassigned comments are from these commenters:

Count of CID	Part of No Vote?
	N		N Total	Y		Y Total	Grand Total
Row Labels	G	T		G	T
Adrian Stephens	12	5	17	23	27	50	67
David Hunter					36	36	36
Mark Hamilton					3	3	3
Grand Total	12	5	17	23	66	89	106

Having (almost) completed the .11ac roll-in, I am now going to give priority to resolving

or finding assignees for my comments, as requested at a TGmc telecon. Many of my

comments relate to .11ad material (which is not surprising, because that was the bulk

of new or changed material in D2). FYI - I have asked Carlos Cordeiro to resolve a number of

these comments where expert knowledge of .11ad was required.

For those that like pretty pictures, one more: This shows the comment resolution history for LB199 only

To put some analysis into this, In November we approved 115 comments quickly (editorials) and a further ~75 at the session.

Between the end of the November session and the end of the Jan session, we approved about 110 comments.

We have roughly 200 comments not yet approved. Based on the previous rate of approval, this would indicate completion

of the comment resolution in May.

Best Regards,

Adrian P STEPHENS

Tel: +44 (1793) 404825 (office)
Tel: +44 (7920) 084 900 (mobile, UK)

Tel: +1 (408) 2397485 (mobile, USA)

----------------------------------------------
Intel Corporation (UK) Limited
Registered No. 1134945 (England)
Registered Office: Pipers Way, Swindon SN3 1RJ
VAT No: 860 2173 47

IF YOU WISH to be Removed from this reflector, PLEASE DO NOT send your request to this CLOSED reflector. We use this valuable tool to communicate on the issues at hand.