[STDS-802-11-TGM] Request for discussion: CID 140 : "At the Antenna Conn

Thread Links	Date Links
Thread Prev	Thread Next	Thread Index	Date Prev	Date Next	Date Index

I would like to provide the following information to aid in resolving CID 140. I plan to provide a potential resolution to Revise make the changes as noted below.

Feedback is requested.

Jon

--------------------------------------

CID 140:
Comment:

"There are about 30 each of "at the antenna" and "at the antenna connector"

Proposed Change:

"Add "connector" after "at the antenna" where not already present"

Discussion:

Jon to ask for a review of the ~ 14 locations without "connector" for correctness to add "connector"

Update January 15th: Counter proposal to change "at the antenna" or "at the antenna connector" with "at the base of the antenna".

In hallway discussions, I have found more support for just Accepting the proposed change, but was given a warning that adding "at the connector" is not always correct, for example:

P1130,L8. Shouldn't add "connector" since the text is about EIRP. See below.

"The STA Tx Power field indicates the target transmit power at the antenna (i.e., EIRP) in dBm with atolerance of ± 5 dB of the lowest basic rate of the reporting STA. "

Locations (D0.5) that should not be changed:

P1130,L8 (EIRP)

P1141 L53 (EIRP)

P1149 L17 (antenna gain)

Potential locations (D0.5) for the change:

P984 L17 (in Table 9-119)

P2138 L26 (11.11.12)

P2677 L4 (15.2.3.3)

P2696 L60 (15.4.6.3)

P2727 L5 (16.3.8.2)

P2727 L45 (16.3.8.5)

P2733 L34 (17.2.3.3)

P2765 L26 (17.3.10.5)

P2781 L24 (18.3.4)

P2791 L58 (Table 19-1)

P2965 L49 (Table 21-1)

P3098 L13 (Table 22-1)

   P3157 L12 (Table 23-1)
   P3157 L20 (Table 23-1)
   P3157 L26 (Table 23-1)

P3614 L3 (dot11WirelessMGTEventPeerSTATxPower MIB)

P3750 L8 (dot11WNMEventPeerRprtStaTxPower MIB)

Other potential change:

P4027L17 change "at the antenna input" to "at the antenna connector" (Table D-3)

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
Jon Rosdahl             Engineer, Senior Staff
office: 801-492-4023      Qualcomm Technologies, Inc.
cell:   801-376-6435      10871 North 5750 West
       Highland, UT 84003

A Job is only necessary to eat!
A Family is necessary to be happy!!

IF YOU WISH to be Removed from this reflector, PLEASE DO NOT send your request to this CLOSED reflector. We use this valuable tool to communicate on the issues at hand.

[STDS-802-11-TGM] Request for discussion: CID 140 : "At the Antenna Connector"