stds-802-16: Sessions #5 and #6: Independent MAC and PHY scoring results (summary)

[Brian_Petry@3com.com]

Hello,

At session #6, the 802.16 group informally asked me to publish additional
results of MAC and PHY proposal scoring.  (I was the "ad hoc score compilation
committee").  Specifically, people wanted to see the results of "independent"
voters.  Independent voters are those who are not authors of a proposal, or not
affiliated with an author's organization.  So, I compiled some results, from
both session #5 and #6.

Please note that these are unofficial, non-binding results that I volunteered to
compile and provide to you.  I am also willing to compile other statistical
groupings of scores, within reason.  The complete results (including
individuals' score cards) will be posted to the web site as soon as the chair
and secretary are able.

Please refer to the 802.16 web site (http://ieee802.org/16) for the text of the
proposals and a description of the evaluation criteria.

Note: The scores are best viewed in a fixed-width font (e.g., courier)---the
tables will then line up.

***Session #5:***

MAC (10 independent ballots):
Average Scores
                 1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9   10   11   12   13
   Avg
01: Sater     : 6.4  6.4  6.1  6.2  6.1  5.7  6.1  6.5  6.2  6.3  6.5  6.1  5.9
  6.2
07: Mollenauer: 7.8  7.4  8.0  7.4  7.2  7.8  7.3  6.9  6.5  6.7  7.1  7.4  8.0
  7.3
Average of the "overall" category:
01: Sater     :  6.2
07: Mollenauer:  7.6

PHY (11 independent ballots):
Average Scores
                 1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9   10   11   Avg
05: Williams  : 4.1  3.6  4.4  4.6  4.6  4.8  3.9  4.4  4.5  5.3  5.6  4.5
02: Foerster  : 6.7  6.4  6.5  6.2  5.4  5.5  5.8  6.1  6.9  6.4  6.9  6.2
09: Klein     : 8.0  7.9  7.4  7.6  8.0  8.2  7.2  7.5  7.2  7.7  7.3  7.6
Average of the "overall" category:
05: Williams  :  4.2
02: Foerster  :  6.3
09: Klein     :  7.9

***Session #6:***

6 independent ballots:

MAC:
Average Scores
                 1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9   10   11   12   13
   Avg
09: Sater     : 8.6  8.0  7.1  8.4  7.7  7.9  7.4  8.0  7.5  8.0  8.0  8.2  7.3
  7.8
10: Mollenauer: 7.5  7.0  7.3  5.7  6.5  7.0  6.2  6.5  6.0  6.7  6.8  6.8  7.2
  6.7
Average of the "overall" category:
09: Sater     :  7.9
10: Mollenauer:  6.8

PHY:
Average Scores
                 1    2    3    4    5    6    7    8    9   10   11   Avg
13: Foerster  : 7.8  7.3  8.6  7.5  6.9  7.1  8.2  8.0  8.0  7.5  7.2  7.7
14: Klein     : 7.8  7.5  6.0  7.2  7.5  6.8  7.3  7.8  7.0  7.5  7.3  7.3
Average of the "overall" category:
13: Foerster  :  7.6
14: Klein     :  7.2