Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

stds-802-16: editorial comment approval motion



Brian,

I'm requesting to add to the TGa agenda the following motion, at any time before commencing comment resolution:

Motion: To dispose the following comments as indicated:

comment	Decision of group	Resolution of group (implementation)	Notes (not to be recorded in database)
0772		Accepted		Remedy	
0774		Accepted		Comment	
0778		Accepted		Remedy	
0782		Accepted		Remedy	
0788		Accepted		Remedy	
0789		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0788	
0790		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0788	
0791		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0788	
0792		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0788	
0793		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0788	
0799		Accepted		Remedy	
0801		Accepted		Remedy	
0803		Accepted		Remedy	
0804		Accepted		Remedy	
0805		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Roger & Nico		BTC is already used and defined in IEEE Std 802.16.
0806		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Roger			IEEE style requires lower case. We need to reserve uppercase for specific named entities.
0807		Accepted		Remedy	
0808		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico			changed to IEEE P802.16a/D3-2002.
0809		Accepted-duplicate	see 808	
0811		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Roger			IEEE style requires use of abbreviations, once defined.
0813		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Roger			More mathematical and easier to read.
0823		Accepted		Comment	
0824		Accepted-modified	see 823	
0827		Accepted		Remedy				May effectively be superceeded by 0826.
0829		Accepted		Remedy				May effectively be superceeded by 0826.
0831		Accepted		Remedy	
0837		Accepted		Remedy	
0838		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0837	
0840		Accepted		Remedy	
0841		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico			consistency with the base standard.
0842		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0841	
0843		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0841	
0845		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
0847		Accepted		Remedy	
0851		Accepted		Remedy	
0852		Accepted		Remedy	
0858		Accepted		Comment	
0859		Accepted		Remedy	
0863		Accepted		Remedy	
0868		Accepted		Remedy	
0871		Accepted		Remedy	
0872		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0872	
0877		Accepted		Remedy	
0880		Accepted		Remedy	
0881		Accepted-Duplicate	see 0880	
0883		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
0888		Accepted		Remedy	
0891		Accepted		Remedy	
0901		Accepted		Remedy	
0905		Accepted		Remedy	
0911		Accepted		Remedy	
0917		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
0922		Accepted		Remedy	
0923		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
0925		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico			Consistency with previous comment changing sub-channel to subchannel
0926		Accepted		Remedy	
0927		Accepted		Remedy	
0929		Accepted		Remedy	
0930		Accepted		Comment	
0931		Accepted		Remedy	
0937		Accepted		Remedy	
0943		Accepted-modified	Remedy & Recommendation Roger	
0945		Accepted		Remedy	
0946		Accepted-duplicate	see 0945	
0954		Accepted		Remedy	
0955		Accepted		Remedy	
0956		Accepted		Remedy	
0957		Accepted		Remedy	
0959		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Roger			Editor only spotted LSB and MSB in Alamouti parameters in chapter 11, rest should be lsb and msb.
0960		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Sean	
0961		Accepted		Remedy	
0962		Accepted-duplicate	see 0961	
0964		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
0975		Accepted		Remedy	
0999		Accepted		Remedy	
1024		Accepted		Remedy	
1033		Accepted		Remedy	
1034		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1033	
1035		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1033	
1045		Accepted		Remedy	
1050		Accepted		Remedy	
1051		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
1052		Accepted		Remedy	
1059		Accepted		Remedy	
1070		Accepted		Remedy	
1071		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1070	
1073		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1070	
1074		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1070	
1075		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1070	
1077		Accepted		Remedy	
1087		Accepted		Remedy	
1090		Accepted		Remedy	
1091		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1090	
1092		Accepted		Remedy	
1093		Accepted-Duplicate	see 1090	
1096		Accepted		Remedy	
1103		Accepted		Remedy	
1109		Accepted		Remedy	
1112		Accepted		Remedy	
1113		Accepted		Remedy	
1115		Accepted		Remedy	
1138		Accepted-duplicate	see 0959	
1147		Accepted		Comment	
1148		Accepted		Remedy	
1149		Accepted		Comment	
1156		Accepted		Remedy	
1161		Accepted		Remedy	
1162		Accepted		Remedy	
1164		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Nico	
1171		Accepted		Remedy	
1172		Accepted		Remedy	
1173		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Anader	
1174		Accepted-duplicate	see 1173,1175,1176	
1175		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Anader	
1176		Accepted-modified	Recommendation Anader	

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Note to TGa members: 

The fact whether or not a comment is in the above list does not implicitly anything regarding its merit. It merely indicates that from the editor's point of view, some comments are more editorial than others.
Members are strongly urged to review the list, and suggested to notify both me and the chair, Brian, of objections to any comment being in this list (motivation not required), so that I can amend the motion and we don't have to debate the listing of individual comments during session #18, which would defeat the purpose of disposing of purely editorial comments in an efficient fashion.

Regards,

/Nico