stds-802-16: 802.16a Recirculation Status
Folks,
Recirculation of the P802.16a Sponsor Ballot resolutions ran from 2-11 October.
The current P802.16a approval ratio is 80% (48 Approve/12 Disapprove).
The 32 recirc comments submitted are available in Commentary:
http://ieee802.org/16/docs/02/80216-02_54.zip
The three supporting contributions are also on-line:
"Stuff, the sequel" {material referenced by comments on P802.16a/D5 recirc} C802.16a-02/90 (Nico van Waes)
http://ieee802.org/16/tga/contrib/C80216a-02_90.pdf
"Resolution of Comments 196 and 197 (Frame Duration Codes)"
C802.16a-02/89 ( David Trinkwon)
http://ieee802.org/16/tga/contrib/C80216a-02_89.pdf
"Rebuttal of Task Group Reasons for Resolution on Comment 318"
C802.16a-02/88 ( David Trinkwon)
http://ieee802.org/16/tga/contrib/C80216a-02_88.pdf
At this point, comment resolutions will be prepared by the Ballot Resolution Committee (BRC) appointed by the unanimous motion carried at Session #21 (see below). Formal Reply Comments are not being requested. However, if you have an opinion on one of the 32 comments, or would like to proposed a resolution to it, you are free to contact one or more of the BRC members. You can also email the whole BRC at <ballot16a@wirelessman.org>.
Roger
Session #21, Motion #9: "To appoint a Ballot Resolution Committee and task them to resolve any comments arising from the recirculation of the P802.16a Sponsor Ballot. The final set of resolutions would be forwarded only if unanimously supported by the Committee. The Committee is tasked to technically justify accepting any comments that would reverse earlier technical decisions. The Working Group and Task Group a Chairs will be observers to the Committee. The members of the Ballot Resolution Committee will be the following, and only the following: Brian Eidson, Marianna Goldhammer, Itzik Kitroser, Bob Nelson, Randall Schwartz, Shawn Taylor, and Nico Van Waes. Each member is entitled to resign and name an alternate."