[STDS-802-16] +++Voting Process on Approval of P802.16-REVd/D5 Recirculation Comments Now Open; Deadline of 5 June
When I posted the P802.16-REVd/D5 Recirculation comments, I said that
I would announce the on-line comment resolution process in a few days
and told you to expect the decision-making process to be quick. I
hope you have had time to read the comments.
The process is described in IEEE 802.16-04/31
<http://ieee802.org/16/docs/04/80216-04_31.pdf>. Members of the IEEE
802.16 Working Group <http://ieee802.org/16/members.html> are the
members of the Ballot Resolution Committee and eligible to vote. They
should read IEEE 802.16-04/31 for details. It explains the need to
make a quick decision on these comments.
The voting deadline is 5 June AOE.
Regards,
Roger
>The P802.16-REVd Recirc #2 balloting period has closed.
>
>The good news is that we are down to one Disapprove voter (Nico van
>Waes). He submitted one Technical Binding comment, which was a
>reiteration of a previous comment.
>
>The bad news is that we received a total of 171 comments.
> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/04/80216-04_30.zip
>
>The following show the members of the Sponsor Ballot Group who
>submitted comments, along with the number of comments:
>
>Tal Kaitz 2
>Itzik Kitroser 11
>Yigal Leiba 44
>Cor van de Water 3
>Nico van Waes 1
>
>I received additional comments from other individuals who do not
>belong to the Sponsor Ballot Group:
>
>Raja Banerjea 3
>Changhoi Koo 68
>Lalit Kotecha 14
>Wonil Roh 25
>
>
>We will now move on to an on-line comment resolution process in
>which the members of the Ballot Resolution Committee will be the
>Members of the IEEE 802.16 Working Group. I will provide details in
>a few days. Expect the decision-making process to be quick.
>
>For those of you who are wondering where this leaves us: we have met
>the RevCom conditions for D5 to be approved as an IEEE standard on
>24 June. If we reject all of these comments, no further
>recirculation will be necessary. However, we also have the option to
>accept comments, produce draft D6, open a third recirculation, and
>remove D5 from the June RevCom agenda.
>
>Roger