[STDS-802-16] results of Voting on P802.16-REVd/D5 Recirculation Comments
The voting process is over. All but two of the comments were
withdrawn. Of the two comments under consideration, the results were:
Comment # Accept Reject Abstain Ratio Result
380 2 38 0 5.0% Rejected
435 2 37 1 5.1% Rejected
Neither of these comments needs to be recirculated. The Sponsor
Ballot and associated recirculations are now closed.
I'll be taking care of some final paperwork to make sure that
everything is in order for P802.16-REVd/D5 to be approved as an IEEE
Standard by the IEEE-SA Standards Board on 24 June.
Roger
>When I posted the P802.16-REVd/D5 Recirculation comments, I said
>that I would announce the on-line comment resolution process in a
>few days and told you to expect the decision-making process to be
>quick. I hope you have had time to read the comments.
>
>The process is described in IEEE 802.16-04/31
><http://ieee802.org/16/docs/04/80216-04_31.pdf>. Members of the IEEE
>802.16 Working Group <http://ieee802.org/16/members.html> are the
>members of the Ballot Resolution Committee and eligible to vote.
>They should read IEEE 802.16-04/31 for details. It explains the need
>to make a quick decision on these comments.
>
>The voting deadline is 5 June AOE.
>
>Regards,
>
>Roger
>
>
>
>>The P802.16-REVd Recirc #2 balloting period has closed.
>>
>>The good news is that we are down to one Disapprove voter (Nico van
>>Waes). He submitted one Technical Binding comment, which was a
>>reiteration of a previous comment.
>>
>>The bad news is that we received a total of 171 comments.
>> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/04/80216-04_30.zip
>>
>>The following show the members of the Sponsor Ballot Group who
>>submitted comments, along with the number of comments:
>>
>>Tal Kaitz 2
>>Itzik Kitroser 11
>>Yigal Leiba 44
>>Cor van de Water 3
>>Nico van Waes 1
>>
>>I received additional comments from other individuals who do not
>>belong to the Sponsor Ballot Group:
>>
>>Raja Banerjea 3
>>Changhoi Koo 68
>>Lalit Kotecha 14
>>Wonil Roh 25
>>
>>
>>We will now move on to an on-line comment resolution process in
>>which the members of the Ballot Resolution Committee will be the
>>Members of the IEEE 802.16 Working Group. I will provide details in
>>a few days. Expect the decision-making process to be quick.
>>
>>For those of you who are wondering where this leaves us: we have
>>met the RevCom conditions for D5 to be approved as an IEEE standard
>>on 24 June. If we reject all of these comments, no further
>>recirculation will be necessary. However, we also have the option
>>to accept comments, produce draft D6, open a third recirculation,
>>and remove D5 from the June RevCom agenda.
>>
>>Roger