Re: [STDS-802-16] [STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [HARMONIZATION] Minutes from 8/23

Thread Links	Date Links
Thread Prev	Thread Next	Thread Index	Date Prev	Date Next	Date Index

Hi all,

I know that it's a bit late but since there is no deadline for revision on harmonized contributions, I'll make a suggestion

for change of text in "Enhancement of Association using SCAN-REQ/RSP - Harmonization Ad Hoc Consensus Contribution"

In the contribution when performing association with Multiple BSs, MSS should perform association by the ascending order of BS ID.

I feel that it would be better to perform association with the BS with better channel condition, because performing association with

BSs with comparatively poor channel condition could take longer time creating unnecessary delay.

[Change Text as below]

Association Test BS ID
Recommended Association Test BS list for Association. ~~If multiple Association Test BS IDs are included in the message, the MSS may perform Association in ascending order of the sequence of Association Test BS ID presented in the message.~~ If multiple Association Test BS IDs are included in the message, the MSS may perform Association in ascending order of the sequence of Association Test BS ID presented in the message. Serving BS may request, over the backbone, Association Test BS allocation of non-contention based initial ranging opportunity for MSS Association activity. When conducting initial ranging to Association Test BS, MSS shall use allocated non-contention based initial ranging opportunity, if available.

-----Original Message-----
From: owner-stds-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG [mailto:owner-stds-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG]On Behalf Of Iyer, Prakash
Sent: Tuesday, August 24, 2004 12:36 AM
To: STDS-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG
Subject: [STDS-802-16] [STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [HARMONIZATION] Minutes from 8/23 telecon

Consensus Contributions:  All of the contributions in this section will progress as consensus contributions

C80216e-04_304.pdf Enhancement of Association using SCAN-REQ/RSP - Harmonization Ad Hoc Consensus Contribution

>> No comments.

C80216e-04_271 Enhancement to Normal Mode to Sleep Mode Transition – Harmonization Ad-hoc Consensus Contribution

>> No comments.

C80216e-04_330 Sleep mode supporting the periodic ranging w compress format of SLP ID fields in MOB_TRF-IND message - Harmonization Ad-Hoc Consensus Contrib

>> No comments.

C80216e-04_280 Enhancements on Neighbor Advertisement Message - Harmonization Ad hoc Consensus Version

>> Masoud (Nextel) to make editorial changes to indicate specific sections in D4 draft under Proposed Changes section

C80216e-04_245 Idle Mode Harmonization - Harmonization Ad-Hoc Consensus Contribution

>> No comments.

C80216e-04_297 Enhanced Paging with Assigned Ranging Code – Harmonization Ad-hoc Consensus Contribution

>> No comments.

Potential Consensus Candidates:

C80216e-04_299.pdf Short Data Burst Support for MSSs in Sleep Mode

>> Itzik to send comments to reflector (and reply comments).

>> Will not be consensus. Contribution will be revised based on reply comments.

C80216e-04_305.pdf Fast DCD/UCD synchronization for sleep mode MSS

>> Updates to be based on reply comments.

>> Will not be consensus.

PHY Mode/Profile:

C80216e-04_320r1 PHY Profile ID

C80216e-04_343 PHY Mode ID

>> Samsung and Intel attempting to harmonize contributions. Neither to be marked as consensus.

C80216e-04_281 Fast Paging and Broadcast Configuration Update Indication

>> Itzik and John Humbert asked about gain from this contribution.

>> May be revised based on reply comments. Masoud commented that there isn't enough time to complete simulations to demonstrate performance

>> Will not be consensus.

C80216e-04_300.pdf Enhanced initial ranging and BW request ranging

>> Jungje Son and Mo-Han to continue discussion on reflector.

>> Will not be consensus

MBS:

C80216e-04_259 The discovery of MBS information using portal server

>> Beyond the scope of .16e

C80216e-04_260 The delivery of MBS contents using tunnel

>> Beyond the scope of .16e

C80216e-04_275 MBS (Multicast and Broadcast Service) enhanced for macro-diversity reception

>> Working to harmonize with 359r1

C80216e-04_282 Enhancement Feature for Robust Multimedia Broadcasting

>> PHY layer, skipped on this call

C80216e-04_359r1 MBS Harmonization

>> MBS map IE - open issue with Alvarion (pending Alvarion f/b)

>> One issue with Intel to be resolved today

>> Being harmonized with 04_275

Will be harmonized following reply comments period. Contribution will not be marked as consensus.

SHO/FBSS:

C80216e-04_332 Fast Anchor BS Switching Feedback Report Mechanism and Sleep Mode Support for SHO and FBSS

Nextel's contribution ?? (previously Nextel.Cont.HybridHandoffwithFastCellSection.v1.pdf )

>> Most of Nextel's concepts are in the contribution except the optional ranging procedure.

>> Will be tagged as consensus; some edits possible based on reply comments and discussions with Nextel

>> Masoud/Kamran send out email with concerns to SHO/FBSS authors' list

Other Contributions: The contribution on the list below were not discussed

C80216e-04_250r1 A method of shortening the duration of scanning neighbor BSs

C80216e-04_353r1 Compression of Neighbor BS ID using MOB-NBR-ADV message

C80216e-04_306.pdf Load Balancing in Initial Entries and Handovers in Multi FA systems

Re: [STDS-802-16] [STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [HARMONIZATION] Minutes from 8/23 telecon