Re: [STDS-802-16] P802.16e - Comments from P802.20 Working Group
Folks,
Yesterday, NesCom received a protest note from 802.20 Chair Jerry
Upton objecting to the 802.16e PAR modification under consideration
at the meeting of 22 September.
The note included 11 attachments. I've posted the main one (the
letter to NesCom) here:
http://ieee802.org/16/docs/04/80216-04_58.pdf
I will provide a response for NesCom. If you have some supporting
content to contribute, please let me know as soon as possible so that
I may take it into consideration.
Roger
>Dear All:
>
>Below and attached is information that I received from Jerry Upton, the
>Working Group Chair of P802.20, indicating why the modified PAR for
>P802.16e should not be approved. Of particular interest to note is his
>letter to NesCom (RationaleforNescomnotapproving*.*).
>
>If you should have any comments regarding the attached, Jerry can be
>reached via e-mail at jerry1upton@aol.com and Roger Marks, the Working
>Group Chair for P802.16e, can be reached via e-mail at r.b.marks@ieee.org.
>Please copy me on all correspondence.
>
>Best regards,
>
>Jodi Haasz
>Program Manager
>International Stds Programs and Governance
>Standards Activities
>Phone +1 732 562 6367
>FAX +1 732 875 0695
>Email: j.haasz@ieee.org
>
>----- Forwarded by Jodi Haasz/STDS/STAFF/US/IEEE on 09/08/2004 08:46 AM
>
>
>Jodi,
>Attached are 11 documents including a letter to NesCom members. This
>concerns the Modified 802.16e PAR that is on the agenda for the September
>NesCom meeting.
>
>Please distribute the letter and all the documents to the members.
>
>I currently plan to attend the meeting. I would appreciate a short time on
>the agenda to address questions and make statements.
>
>If you have any problems with the documents, please call my mobile anytime
>of the day. I will call you on Tuesday.
>
>Regards,
>Jerry Upton
>Office: +1-847-692-2497
>Mobile: +1-847-772-4800
>Fax: +1-847-692-9473(See attached file: 802.20 Positions on 802.16e.ppt)
>
>Attached files:
> 80216-02_37 (Minutes July 02).pdf
> 80216-02_48r4 Org 820.16e PAR.pdf
> 80216-04_33r3 802.16ePAR rev.pdf
> 80216e-04_11 MAY 04 Minutes.pdf
> C80216e-04_70r3 (FFT size).pdf
> C80216e-04_98r4 (marked as 98r3).pdf
> Post_Amendment_PARS_16_20_Att_Z.ppt
> RationaleforNescomNotapproving802.16ePAR JUpton.doc
> UniquenessofProjects_WO_3G_Att_Y.ppt
> UniquenessofProjects1_sgm-02-16.ppt
>