[STDS-802-16] update of P802.16e ballot status
Folks,
I wanted to provide an update on the P802.16 Sponsor Ballot status.
The official recirc report from the IEEE-SA Balloting Center came in
a little different from the tentative report that I mentioned earlier
(in my note below). The official results were:
91 Approve
45 Disapprove
136 votes = 67% affirmative
Since then, I received email notification from a number of people
asking to change their votes. I can't make this change; they need to
submit their ballots to the IEEE-SA Balloting Center during the next
recirc. However, it is important for me to track these changes of
vote, for two reasons:
(1) The cover letter attached to the next recirc will list the
Disapprove voters. I need not list those who have informed me that
they are switching to Approve.
(2) We need not recirculate the comments of those people who inform
me that they have switched to Approve.
When I include the notices I have received, the tally is:
102 Approve
36 Disapprove
138 votes = 73.9% affirmative
This is just below the 75% approval minimum. See below for the
current list of Disapprove voters.
The remaining Disapprove voters may review the comment resolutions
and send me this note:
>I am satisfied with the resolution of my comments in the comment
>Resolution databases:
> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/05/80216-05_012r3.zip and
> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/05/80216-05_010.zip
>and thereby wish to change my vote to Approve.
or this one:
>I am satisfied with the resolution of my comments X, Y, and Z... in
>the comment Resolution databases:
> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/05/80216-05_012r3.zip and
> http://ieee802.org/16/docs/05/80216-05_010.zip
>but wish to retain my Disapprove vote.
Regards,
Roger
=====
Current list of Disapprove voters:
John Barr
Rajesh Bhalla
David Castelow
Yong Chang
Mark Cudak
Lester Eastwood
Carl Eklund
Colin Frank
Ronen Greenberg
Qiang Guo
David James
James Gilb
Tal Kaitz
Mika Kasslin
Brian Kiernan
Byoung-Jo Kim
Itzik Kitroser
Jonathan Labs
Yigal Leiba
Aviram Lobel
Scott Migaldi
Ronald Murias
Kadathur Natarajan
Richard Pace
Oded Redlich
Herbert Ruck
N. Shankaranarayanan
Dorothy Stanley
Kenneth Stanwood
Victor Stolpman
Rainer Ullmann
Huaiyuan Wang
Lei Wang
Vladimir Yanover
Yonatan Zvi
Nico van Waes