| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Yes, they do, so there is a record of
their approval. From: Jung Je Son
[mailto:jungje.son@SAMSUNG.COM] Mike, As I remember, several persons on
your list of disapproval voter without comment expressed his flip of vote to
approval. Do you think such persons need to vote
as approval at new recirculation? BR, Jung Je Son From: Mike Hart [mailto:Mike.Hart@UKBROADBAND.COM]
All WG LB 28 pool members, Following session #55 I’ve checked
the status of LB28. According to my records, the list of commenters with one or
more unsatisfied comments is as follows (if you need to know exact comment
numbers, please let me know): LB28 (http://www.ieee802.org/16/docs/07/80216-07_045r5.zip)
– total of 17 comments Choi, In-Kyeong Mao, Ronald Popoli, Robert Song, Young Seog Wang, Lei Colban, Erik Piggin, Paul LB28b (http://www.ieee802.org/16/docs/08/80216-08_013r3.zip)
– total 9 comments Branlund, Dale Senarath, Gamini Xu, Ling LB28c (http://www.ieee802.org/16/docs/08/80216-08_023.zip)
– total 8 comments Hsu, Hsien-Tsung Lee, Youn-Tai Lee, Yung-Ting Loa, Kanchei Yin, Hua-Chiang Comstock, David Taori, Rakesh Kang, Hyunjeong The following people are registered as
disapprove voters at the end of LB28 with no disapprove comments in any
database: Boariu, Adrian Chae, Suchang Chion, Hua (Mary) Feng, Shulan Li, Thomas Lin, Tzu-Ming Lu, Jianmin Wang, Yanhong Wu, Yingzhe Xie, Chengjie Please check the databases and consider
whether you can change your vote to approve (or let me know if I’ve made
a mistake) in LB28d Regards, Mike From: Mike Hart
[mailto:Mike.Hart@UKBROADBAND.COM] All WG LB 28 pool members, A number of people have submitted cmts files to indicate which comments
they are satisfied with in the databases associated with LB28, LB28a and LB28b.
However, there are still a number of people with unsatisfied comments in the
three databases. To assist the Relay TG, we would appreciate it if you could review your
comments in light of the most recent version of the draft (http://www.ieee802.org/16/pubs/80216j.html)
and let us know (if you are voting disapprove in LB28c) if any of your previous
comments are satisfied by submitting a cmts file for the relevant database.
If you are still not satisfied, then please submit a comment as part of LB28c
indicating why you are not satisfied with the resolution so that we can try to
address your concerns. It would be useful if you could reference the
unsatisfied comment so that we can tie everything up. This is
particularly important for those of you that will not attend the next IEEE
meeting, as otherwise we will not know how to satisfy your concerns. According to my records, the list of commenters with one or more
unsatisfied comments is as follows (if you need to know exact comment numbers,
please let me know): LB28 (http://www.ieee802.org/16/docs/07/80216-07_045r5.zip)
– total of 30 comments Choi, In-Kyeong Xie, Chengjie Mao, Ronald Popoli, Robert Song, Young Seog Lee, Seung Joon Lin, Zhibin Wang, Lei Colban, Erik Lu, Jianmin Piggin, Paul Wang, Yanhong LB28a (http://www.ieee802.org/16/docs/08/80216-08_002r3.zip)
– total of 3 comments Lin, Tzu-Ming Senarath, Gamini LB28b (http://www.ieee802.org/16/docs/08/80216-08_013r3.zip
– total 18 comments Branlund, Dale Chow, Jerry Feng, Shulan Huang, Cancan Kang, Hyunjeong Lin, Tzu-Ming Olszewski, Kim Qian, Jeff Senarath, Gamini Xu, Ling If you need any help with making a cmts file, please let me know. Regards, Mike |