IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #28

Letter Ballot #28: Final Report

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #28e: Confirmation Ballot Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #28d: Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #28c: Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #28b: Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #28a: Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #28: Announcement

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Sum Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval
Conditions met+
2008/08/08 290 3* 293 .99 Yes 20 313 350 .89 Yes 0 Yes
*2 of the 3 Disapprove votes were without comment.
+WG Letter Ballot #28 approved and terminated, 2008-08-08.

Ballot Details

[ Updated 08/08/08, 12:25 PM ]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.

Name\Family Name\Given Letter Ballot #28
Abrishami Ray Approve, No Comments
Agis Edward Approve, No Comments (e)
Ahmadi Sassan Approve, No Comments (a)
Ahn Dong Hyun Approve, No Comments (d)
Ahn JunBae Approve, No Comments (e)
Andelman Dov Approve, No Comments
Arefi Reza Approve, No Comments (a)
Barber Phillip Approve, No Comments (d)
Basgeet Dharma -
Baum Kevin Approve, No Comments
Boariu Adrian Approve, No Comments (d)
Bogenfeld Eckard Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Brandt Achim Approve, No Comments (a)
Branlund Dale Approve, Comments (d)
Brooks Terri Approve, No Comments (a)
Cai Sean Approve, No Comments (d)
Carlo James Approve, No Comments
Cha Jaesun Approve, No Comments (e)
Chae Suchang Approve, No Comments (d)
Chang Jae Hwan Approve, No Comments
Chang Sungcheol Approve, No Comments (a)
Chayat Naftali -
Chayer Rémi Approve, No Comments (a)
Chen David Approve, No Comments
Chen Wei-Peng Approve, No Comments (e)
Cheng Paul Approve, No Comments (a)
Chindapol Aik Approve, No Comments (a)
Chion Hua (Mary) Approve, No Comments (d)
Cho Jaehee Approve, No Comments (d)
Cho Jaeweon Approve, No Comments
Cho Kihyoung Approve, No Comments (a)
Cho Myeon-Gyun Approve, No Comments
Choi Hokyu Approve, No Comments
Choi Hyoung-Jin Approve, No Comments (d)
Choi Hyung-Nam Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Choi In-Kyeong Approve, No Comments (d)
Choi Jinsoo Approve, No Comments (a)
Choi Joonyoung Approve, No Comments
Choi Yang-Seok Approve, No Comments (d)
Choi Yong-Hoon Approve, No Comments
Chou Chie Ming Approve, No Comments (d)
Chou Joey Approve, No Comments
Choukroun David -
Chow Jerry Approve, No Comments (d)
Chui Jimmy Approve, No Comments (a)
Chujo Takafumi Approve, No Comments (b)
Chun Jin Young Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (d)
Chung Young-Uk Approve, No Comments
Colban Erik Approve, No Comments (d)
Comstock David Approve, No Comments (d)
Costa José Approve, No Comments
Crowley Steven Approve, No Comments
Cudak Mark Approve, No Comments
Cummings George Approve, No Comments
Dayal Pranav Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
De Segovia Carlos Approve, No Comments
Demirhan Mustafa -
Dhaliwal Upkar Approve, No Comments (d)
Doi Yoshiharu Approve, No Comments (b)
Doostnejad Roya -
Eastwood Lester Approve, No Comments
Eklund Carl Approve, No Comments (a)
Elmdahl Per Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Erlihson Michael Approve
Etemad Kamran -
Eu Jai -
Eun Yu-Chang Approve, No Comments (d)
Fahldieck Torsten Approve, No Comments (a)
Feder Peretz Approve, No Comments
Feng Shulan Approve, No Comments (d)
Fernaine Thierry -
Fong Mo-Han Approve, No Comments
Freedman Avraham Approve, Comments (b)
Fu I-Kang Approve, No Comments (a)
Gal Dan Approve, No Comments
Giesberts Pieter-Paul Approve, No Comments
Glassford Rob Approve, No Comments (e)
Goldhamer Mariana Approve, No Comments
Golshan Reza Approve, No Comments (b)
Grandblaise David Approve, No Comments (a)
Gu Daqing Approve, No Comments
Guvenc Ismail -
Hadad Zion Approve, No Comments (d)
Hahn GeneBeck Approve, No Comments (b)
Hamiti Shkumbin Approve, No Comments (a)
Han Jung Ho Approve, No Comments
Hanaoka Seishi Approve, No Comments (a)
Harrang Jeff -
Hart Mike Approve, No Comments (e)
Henderson Gregory Scott -
Higuchi Keisuke Approve, No Comments (b)
Ho Minnie Approve, No Comments (a)
Hsiao Chang-Lung Approve, No Comments
Hsieh Ching-Tarng Approve, No Comments (a)
Hsieh Yu-Tao Approve, No Comments (e)
Hsu Hsien-Tsung Approve, No Comments (d)
Hsu Yuan-Ying Approve, No Comments (a)
Hu Teck Approve
Hu Wendong -
Huang Cancan Approve, No Comments (d)
Hui Junhong Approve
Humbert John Abstain (d)
Hur Yerang Approve, No Comments
Hwang In Seok Approve, No Comments
Ihm Bin-Chul Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (d)
Ikeda Tetsu Approve, No Comments
Ikegami Tetsushi Approve, No Comments (a)
Jang Jaehyuk Approve, No Comments
Jeniston Deviraj Klutto Milleth Approve, No Comments
Jeon Hyung Joon Approve, No Comments (b)
Jeong Moo Ryong Approve
Jin Sunggeun Approve, No Comments (d)
Johnson Brian Approve, No Comments
Johnsson Kerstin Approve, No Comments (d)
Johnston David Approve, No Comments
Joo Panyuh Approve, No Comments
Jung Young-Ho Approve, No Comments
Kanai Takeo Approve, No Comments
Kang Hyunjeong Approve, No Comments (d)
Kang Seung Hyun Approve, No Comments (b)
Kaplan Ted -
Kelman Ofer Approve, No Comments (e)
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments (e)
Kim Bong Ho Approve, No Comments
Kim Changkyoon Approve, No Comments (a)
Kim Hyung Kee Approve, No Comments
Kim Hyunjae -
Kim Kyeongsoo Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Kim Ronny (Yong-Ho) Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Sang Youb Approve, No Comments
Kim Sungkyung Approve, No Comments (e)
Kim Young Kyun Approve, No Comments
Kim Young-Il Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Young-jae Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Youngho Approve, No Comments
Kishigami Takaaki Approve, No Comments (a)
Kitroser Itzik Approve, No Comments (a)
Koc Ali Approve, No Comments
Kong Peng-Yong -
Koo Changhoi Approve, No Comments (e)
Koorapaty Havish Approve, Comments (a)
Korakis Thanasis Approve, No Comments (e)
Korkmaz Gokhan Approve, No Comments
Kuze Toshiyuki Approve, No Comments (d)
Kwak Byung-Jae Approve, No Comments (a)
Kwak Jin Sam Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (b)
Kwon Dong Seung Approve, No Comments
Kwon Yeong-Hyeon Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Labs Jonathan Approve, No Comments
Lamoureux Pierre Approve, No Comments
Lee Geon Yong -
Lee Heesoo -
Lee Hyojin -
Lee Hyun Approve, No Comments (a)
Lee Hyunjeong Approve, No Comments (a)
Lee Jin Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee Ki-Dong Approve, No Comments (e)
Lee Kyu Ha Approve, No Comments (d)
Lee Mi Hyun Approve, No Comments
Lee Sang-Ho Approve, No Comments
Lee Seung Joon Approve, No Comments (d)
Lee Sukwoo Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee Wookbong Approve, No Comments (d)
Lee Yong Su Approve, No Comments
Lee Youn-Tai Approve, No Comments (d)
Lee Yung-Ting Approve, No Comments (d)
Levanda Matty Approve, No Comments (e)
Li Guangjie Approve, No Comments
Li Jiang Approve, No Comments (b)
Li Jun Approve, No Comments
Li Richard Approve, No Comments (e)
Li Shaohua Approve, No Comments (d)
Li Thomas Disapprove (b) [without comment]
Licitra Gaspare -
Lim Aeri Approve, No Comments
Lim Geunhwi Approve, No Comments (b)
Lim Hyoung Kyu Approve, No Comments (b)
Lim Kwangjae Approve, No Comments (a)
Lin Jiezhen -
Lin Tzu-Ming Approve, No Comments (d)
Lin Zhibin Approve, No Comments (d)
Lindgren Stefan Approve, No Comments (b)
Liu Hang Approve, No Comments (d)
Livschitz Michael Approve, No Comments (d)
Lo Titus Approve, No Comments (d)
Loa Kanchei Approve, No Comments (d)
Lu Jianmin Approve, No Comments (d)
Lu Yanling Approve, Comments (b)
Lynch Michael Approve, No Comments
Madihian Mohammad Approve, No Comments (e)
Maez David Approve, No Comments (e)
Maggi Giovanni Approve
Maheshwari Shashikant Approve, Comments (d)
Mao Ronald Approve, No Comments (d)
Marks Roger Approve, No Comments (e)
Meddour Djamal-Eddine Approve, No Comments (a)
Migaldi Scott Approve, No Comments (e)
Min Chan Ho Approve, No Comments
Mohanty Shantidev Approve, No Comments (a)
Molisch Andreas Approve, No Comments (b)
Mollenauer James Approve, No Comments
Mont-Reynaud Ollivier Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Moon Sungho Approve, No Commentsa
Mulder Willem Approve, No Comments
Na Jee-Hyeon -
Nagai Yukimasa Approve, No Comments (d)
Naguib Ayman Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (d)
Nakamura Kenichi Approve, No Comments
Nakamura Michiharu Approve, No Comments (a)
Njedjou Eric Approve, No Comments
Noh Minseok Approve, No Comments (e)
Nohara Mitsuo Approve, No Comments (a)
Norin John Approve
Odlyzko Paul Approve, No Comments
Oh Changyoon Approve, No Comments (b)
Oh Min-Seok Approve, No Commentsa
Okuda Masato Approve, Comments (d)
Olszewski Kim Approve, No Comments (d)
Orlik Philip Approve, No Comments
Papathanassiou Apostolos -
Paranchych David Approve, No Comments
Park DS Approve, No Comments
Park Jeongho Approve, No Comments
Park Michael -
Patel Vijay Approve, No Comments (d)
Peterson Roger Approve, No Comments
Piggin Paul Approve, No Comments (d)
Popoli Robert Disapprove
Poulin Darcy Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Probasco Scott Approve, No Comments (a)
Puri Anuj -
Puthenkulam Jose Approve, Comments
Qi Xin Approve, No Comments (e)
Qian Nanjian (Jeff) Approve, No Comments (d)
Qin Fei Approve, No Comments (b)
Qu Hongyun Approve, No Comments (d)
Raghavan Arvind Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ramachandran Shyamal Approve, No Comments (a)
Reddy Ranga K Approve, No Comments (d)
Reid Anthony -
Ren Fang-Ching Approve, No Comments (e)
Riegel Maximilian Approve, No Comments (d)
Roh Kwanhee Approve, No Comments
Roh Wonil Approve, No Comments
Rong Zhigang Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Rouz Adel Approve, No Comments (a)
Rubin Philip Approve, No Comments
Ruck Herbert Approve, No Comments (a)
Rush Charles -
Ryu Kiseon Approve, No Comments (b)
Saed Aryan Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (d)
Saifullah Yousuf Approve, No Comments (e)
Saito Kenji Approve, No Comments (b)
Sandhu Sumeet Approve
Sarris Ioannis Approve, No Comments
Schaepperle Joerg Approve, No Comments
Schlanger Gary Approve, No Comments
Schumacher Joseph -
Seagren Chris -
Senarath Gamini Approve, No Comments (d)
Shah Jigar Approve, No Comments
Shang Zheng Approve, No Comments
Sharon Ariel Approve, No Comments
Sheen Wern-Ho Approve, No Comments (b)
Shekalim Peretz Approve, No Comments (d)
Shen Gang Approve, Comments (a)
Sherman Matthew Approve, Comments
Shibayama Hitoshi -
Shim Jaejeong (Brian) Approve, No Comments
Shyy D. J. Approve, No Comments (e)
Simkins James Approve, No Comments
Sivanesan Kathiravetpillai Approve, No Comments
Sjoberg Sten Approve, No Comments (a)
Son Jung Je Approve, No Comments
Son Yeongmoon Approve, No Comments
Song Ting-Chen (Tom) Approve, No Comments (d)
Song Young Seog Approve, No Comments (d)
Srinivasan Roshni Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Stafford Robert -
Stanwood Kenneth Approve
Steer David Approve, No Comments (a)
Sukiasyan Aram Approve, No Comments (a)
sun sheng Approve, No Comments (d)
Sun Yong Approve, No Comments
Sung Sulyun -
Sydir Jaroslaw J Approve, Comments (a)
Sydor John Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (b)
Takai Mineo Approve, No Comments (e)
Takatani Yukihiro Approve, No Comments (d)
Tan Pek Yew Approve, Comments
Tao Jeffrey Approve, Comments (d)
Taori Rakesh Approve, No Comments (d)
Taylor Shawn Approve, No Comments (d)
Teo Koon Hoo Approve, No Comments
Thome Timothy Approve, No Comments (e)
Tong Wen Approve, No Comments
Tonnerre Arnaud Approve, No Comments (d)
Tsai Shiau-He Approve, No Comments (a)
Ullmann Rainer Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Urban David Approve, No Comments (e)
Vadgama Sunil Approve, No Comments (a)
Valbonesi Lucia Approve, No Comments
van Leeuwen Richard Approve, No Comments
Vannithamby Rath Approve, No Comments
Venkatachalam Muthaiah Approve, No Comments (a)
Viorel Dorin Approve, No Comments (e)
Visotsky Eugene Approve, No Comments (d)
Vook Frederick Approve, No Comments
Wallenius Eero -
Wang Arthur Approve, No Comments
Wang Guo Qiang Approve, No Comments (e)
Wang Lei Approve, No Comments (d)
Wang Michael Approve, No Comments
Wang Shu-Shaw Approve, No Comments (d)
Wang Stanley Approve, No Comments
Wang Yanhong Approve, No Comments (d)
Watanabe Fujio Approve, No Comments (d)
Webb Michael -
Wieczorek Alfred Approve, No Comments (d)
Wu Geng Approve, No Comments
Wu Xuyong Approve
Wu Yingzhe Disapprove (a) [without comment]
Xiang David Approve, No Comments (e)
Xie Chengjie Approve, No Comments (d)
Xu Hua Approve, No Comments
Xu Kaixin -
Xu Ling Approve, No Comments (d)
Yagi Akiyoshi Approve, No Comments (a)
Yang Hongwei -
Yang Jen-Shun Approve, No Comments
Yang Liuyang -
Yang Rongzhen Approve
Yang Xiangying Approve, No Comments
Yang Yunsong Approve
Yanover Vladimir Approve, No Comments
Yin Hua-Chiang Approve, No Comments (d)
Yin Hujun Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a)
Yoon Chulsik Approve, No Comments (a)
Youn Aeran Approve, No Comments (b)
Yun Jungnam Approve, No Comments
Yun Sangboh Approve, No Comments
Yuza Masaaki Approve, No Comments (d)
Zhang Jinyun Approve, No Comments (d)
Zhang Kaibin Approve, Comments (a)
Zheng Hongming Approve, No Comments
Zhou Fei Frank -
Zhou Hua Approve, No Comments (d)
Zhou Yuefeng Approve, No Comments (e)
Zhu Chenxi Approve, Comments (d)
Zhu Peiying Approve, No Comments (b)
(a) Recirc #28a
(b) Recirc #28b
(c) Recirc #28c
(d) Recirc #28d
(e) Recirc #28e