IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #30

Letter Ballot #30: Status Report

Note: At the Closing Plenary of IEEE 802.16 Session #65, on 14 January 2010, the WG approved a motion "That the WG terminate LB #30 and initiate a new WG LB #31 of new WG draft P802.16m/D4 based on the comment resolutions contained in 802.16-10/0001r2."

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #30b: Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #30a: Announcement

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #30: Announcement

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Sum Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval
Conditions met+
2010/01/04 196 95 291 .67 No 2 293 437 .67 Yes 0 No

Ballot Details

[ Updated 10/01/04, 04:43 PM ]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.

Name\Family Name\Given Letter Ballot #30
Abdallah Mohamed -
Abrishami Ray Disapprove (b)
Agarwal Rajni Disapprove (b)
Agiwal Anil Approve, No Comments (b)
Ahmadi Sassan Approve, Comments (b)
Ahn JunBae -
Aloush Avner -
Ambroise Xavier Approve, No Comments
Andelman Dov Approve, Comments
Annavajjala Ramesh -
Aoki Tsuguhide -
Arefi Reza Approve, No Comments (b)
Bacioccola Andrea -
Bajaj Rashmi -
Barber Phillip Disapprove
Bims Harry -
Boariu Adrian -
Bourlas Yair -
Boyer Adrian Approve, No Comments (a)
Cai Sean Disapprove
Cain Peter -
Chae Suchang Approve, No Comments (b)
Chang Sung-Cheol Approve, No Comments (b)
Chang Xin -
Chang YoungBin Approve, Comments (b)
Chang Yu-Hao Approve, No Comments (b)
Chayat Naftali Disapprove
Chen Cheng-Ming Approve, No Comments (a)
Chen Clark Approve, No Comments (a)
Chen Mei-Dai Approve, No Comments (b)
Chen Ren-Jr Approve, Comments (a)
Chen Wei-Peng Approve, No Comments
Chen Wen Kai Approve, No Comments (a)
Chen Whai-En Disapprove (b)
Chen Yih-Shen Approve, No Comments (b)
Chen Yung-Han Approve, Comments (b)
Chen Yuqin Disapprove (b)
Cheng Paul Approve, No Comments (b)
Cheng Ray-Guang Approve, No Comments (a)
Chindapol Aik Approve, No Comments
Chion Hua (Mary) Approve, No Comments (b)
Chiu Chun-Yuan Approve, No Comments (b)
Cho HanGyu Approve, Comments (b)
Cho Jaehee Approve, Comments (a)
Cho Jaeweon Approve, Comments (b)
Cho Youngbo Approve, No Comments (b)
Choi Hokyu Approve, No Comments (a)
Choi Hyoung-Jin -
Choi Jinsoo Disapprove (b)
Choi Joonyoung Approve, No Comments (a)
Choi Yang-Seok Approve, No Comments (a)
Chou Chao-Chin Disapprove (b)
Chou Chie Ming Approve, Comments (b)
Chou Ching-Chun Disapprove (a)
Chou Joey Disapprove
Chow Jerry Disapprove
Chuang Ming-Hsueh Disapprove (b)
Chun Jin Young Approve, Comments (b)
Chun Joon Hwa -
Clerckx Bruno Approve, No Comments (b)
Colban Erik -
Costa José Disapprove
Crowley Steven Approve, No Comments
Cudak Mark Disapprove
Davydov Alexey Approve, Comments (b)
Dayal Pranav -
Dhaliwal Upkar Approve, No Comments (a)
Digham Fadel -
Doostnejad Roya -
Du Ying -
Du Yinggang -
Eastwood Lester Approve, No Comments (b)
Eklund Carl Disapprove
Erlihson Michael Approve, No Comments
Ernström Per -
Etemad Kamran -
Eun Yu-Chang Approve, No Comments (b)
Ezri Doron -
Fahldieck Torsten -
Fan Linghang Approve, Comments (b)
Fang Huiying Disapprove (b)
Fang Yu-Chuan Approve, No Comments (b)
Feder Peretz -
Feng Chengyan Approve, No Comments (b)
Fong Mo-Han Disapprove
Freedman Avraham Disapprove (a)
Fu I-Kang Disapprove (b)
Fwu Jong-Kae (JK) Approve, Comments (b)
Gal Dan Disapprove
Geles Mark -
Ghasemi Amir -
Glassford Rob -
Goh Wee Peng -
Goldhamer Mariana Disapprove
Gosteau Jeremy -
Griot Miguel -
Guan Yanfeng Disapprove (b)
Gundlach Michael Disapprove (a)
Hadad Zion Disapprove (b)
Hahn GeneBeck Approve, No Comments (b)
Hamiti Shkumbin -
Han Seung Hee Approve, No Comments (a)
Hanaoka Seishi -
Harel Tom Disapprove (a)
Hart Mike -
Hayase Shigenori -
Himayat Nageen Approve, Comments (b)
Ho Chieh Yuan Approve, No Comments (b)
Ho Chung-Lien Approve, Comments (b)
Ho Minnie Approve, No Comments (a)
Hsiao Chang-Lung Approve, No Comments
Hsiao Ying-Chuan Approve, No Comments (b)
Hsieh Ching-Tarng Approve, No Comments (a)
Hsieh Yu-Tao Approve, Comments (b)
Hsu Chun-Yen Disapprove (b)
Hsu Chung-Hsien Approve, No Comments (b)
Hsu Hsien-Tsung -
Hsu Jen-Yuan Approve, No Comments (a)
Hsuan Yi Approve, Comments (b)
Hu Teck -
Huang Cancan -
Huang Din Hwa Approve, No Comments (b)
Huang Lei Disapprove (b)
Hui Jie Approve, Comments
Hui Junhong -
Humbert John -
Hur Yerang -
Ihm Bin-Chul Approve, No Comments (b)
Ikeda Tetsu Approve, Comments (b)
Imata Satoshi Approve, No Comments (b)
Iyengar Rajagopal -
Jan Yih Guang Disapprove (b)
Jang Jaehyuk Approve, Comments (b)
Jee Junghoon -
Jeon Hyung Joon -
Ji Baowei Approve, No Comments (a)
Jin Lei Disapprove (b)
Jin Sunggeun Approve, No Comments
Johnsson Kerstin Approve, No Comments (a)
Johnston David -
Josiam Kaushik Approve, Comments (b)
Juang Rong-Terng Approve, Comments (b)
Jung Bang Chul -
Jung Inuk Disapprove (b)
Jung Soojung Approve, Comments (b)
Kang Heewon Approve, Comments (a)
Kang Hyunjeong Disapprove (b)
Kang Jianfeng -
Kang Minsuk -
Kang Seunghyun Approve, No Comments (b)
Kao Chien-Yu Approve, No Comments (a)
Kato Tsuguo Approve, No Comments
Khan Farooq Ullah Approve, No Comments (b)
Khojastepour Mohammad Approve, Comments (b)
Khoryaev Alexey Approve, Comments (b)
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments
Kim Bong Ho -
Kim Dongcheol Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Eunkyung Approve, Comments (b)
Kim Jeong Gon Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Jihyung Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Juhee Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Jung-Im -
Kim Namgi Approve, Comments (a)
Kim Ronny (Yong-Ho) Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Sang Gook Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Sangheon Approve, Comments (b)
Kim Sungkyung Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Taeyoung Approve, Comments (b)
Kim Won Ik Approve, No Comments (b)
Kim Young Kyun -
Kim Young-Il -
Kishigami Takaaki Disapprove
Kitroser Itzik -
Klutto Milleth J. Approve, No Comments (a)
Koc Ali Approve, No Comments
Kone Mamadou -
Koo Changhoi -
Korakis Thanasis -
Korkmaz Gokhan Disapprove
Kuchi Kiran Kumar Approve, Comments (a)
Kuo Ping-Heng Disapprove (b)
Kuze Toshiyuki Approve, No Comments (b)
Kwak Byung-Jae -
Kwak Jin-Sam Approve, No Comments (b)
Kwon Dong Seung Approve, No Comments (b)
Kwon Young Hoon Disapprove (b)
Kwon Young-Hyoun Approve, No Comments (b)
Labonte Sylvain -
Labs Jonathan Disapprove (b)
Lee Hyun Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee HyunWoo Approve, Comments (b)
Lee Jeong Julie -
Lee Jin Approve, Comments (b)
Lee Ju Seung Approve, No Comments (a)
Lee Jungwon -
Lee Ki-Dong Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee Kyounghwan -
Lee Mi Hyun Disapprove (b)
Lee Sook-Jin Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee Sukwoo Approve, No Comments (b)
Lee Sungjin Approve, Comments (b)
Lee Wookbong Approve, Comments (b)
Lee Yang-Han Disapprove (b)
Lee Youn-Tai Disapprove (a)
Lee Yung-Ting -
Li Guangjie Approve, No Comments (a)
Li Richard Approve, No Comments
Li Shaohua -
Li Ying Approve, Comments (b)
Li Zexian Disapprove (b)
Liao Pei-Kai Disapprove (b)
Liao Wei-Shun -
Lim Junsung -
Lim Kwangjae Approve, No Comments (b)
Lin Chih-Yuan Approve, No Comments (b)
Lin Hsin-Piao Approve, No Comments (b)
Lin Kuhn-Chang Approve, No Comments (b)
Lin Kun-Yi Approve, No Comments (b)
Lin Yi-Ting Disapprove (b)
Liu Chongli Disapprove (b)
Liu Hang Approve, No Comments (b)
Liu Lina Disapprove (b)
Liu Yang Disapprove (b)
Livschitz Michael -
Loa Kanchei Disapprove (b)
Lu Jianmin Disapprove (b)
Lu Zhaohua Disapprove (b)
Lv Kaiying Disapprove (b)
Lynch Michael Approve, No Comments (b)
Madihian Mohammad Approve, No Comments (b)
Maeder Andreas Approve, Comments (b)
Maez David Approve, No Comments (b)
Maggi Giovanni -
Maheshwari Shashikant -
Maiberger Roy -
Maltsev Alexander Approve, No Comments (a)
Mao Ronald Disapprove
Marks Roger Disapprove (b)
Marque-Pucheu Gerard Approve, No Comments
Maskatia Arif -
Masters Jeffery -
Matsumoto Wataru -
Mazzarese David Approve, Comments (b)
McBeath Sean Disapprove
McGinniss David -
Meddour Djamal-Eddine Approve, No Comments (b)
Migaldi Scott Approve, No Comments (b)
Mlinarsky Fanny -
Mohanty Shantidev Approve, Comments (b)
Molisch Andreas -
Mondal Bishwarup Approve, No Comments (b)
Monogioudis Pantelis -
Moon Sungho Approve, No Comments (b)
Muck Markus Disapprove (b)
Murias Ronald Disapprove (b)
Naguib Ayman -
Nakamura Michiharu Disapprove
Nakatsugawa Keiichi Approve, No Comments (b)
Nguyen An -
Niu Huaning Approve, Comments (a)
Nohara Mitsuo Approve, No Comments
Novak Robert -
Oh Changyoon Approve, No Comments (a)
Oh Min-Seok Approve, No Comments (b)
Okuda Masato Disapprove
Olfat Masoud -
Olszewski Kim -
Ono Ryoji -
Orlik Philip -
Ostling Per-Erik -
Otterbach Juergen -
Papathanassiou Apostolos Approve, No Comments (b)
Park Giwon Disapprove (b)
Park Hyungho Approve, No Comments (b)
Park Jeongho Approve, Comments (b)
Park Michael -
Park Sung-Eun Approve, Comments (a)
Park Youn Ok -
Patel Vijay -
Peng Yan Disapprove (b)
Pi Zhouyue Approve, Comments (b)
Pillai Vinod Ramaswamy -
Pirhonen Riku -
Porat Ron -
Power Kevin Disapprove (a)
Probasco Scott Disapprove (b)
Puthenkulam Jose Approve, Comments (b)
Qi Xin -
Qian Nanjian (Jeff) -
Qu Hongyun Approve, No Comments (b)
Rabineau Rodrigue Approve, No Comments (a)
Ramakrishna Sudhir Approve, Comments (b)
Reddy Ranga K Approve, No Comments (a)
Redlich Oded -
Ren Fang-Ching Approve, Comments (b)
Riegel Maximilian Disapprove
Roh Kwanhee Approve, No Comments (a)
Roh Wonil Approve, No Comments (a)
Rong Zhigang Disapprove (b)
Ruck Herbert Disapprove (b)
Ryu Byung-Han -
Ryu Kiseon Disapprove (b)
Saifullah Yousuf -
Sambasivan Sam -
Sarperi Luciano Disapprove (b)
Sayeedi Shahab Disapprove (a)
Schaepperle Joerg Disapprove
Schneider Thomas -
Schumacher Joseph Disapprove (b)
Seagren Chris Abstain for Lack of Time (a)
Seol Ji-Yun Approve, Comments (b)
Shalash Ahmed Abstain for Lack of Time (a)
Shang Zheng -
Shekalim Peretz Disapprove (b)
Shen Gang -
Sherman Matthew -
Shilo Shimi -
Shim Jaejeong (Brian) Approve, Comments (a)
Shin Wooram Approve, No Comments (b)
Shono Takashi Approve, No Comments (b)
Shyy D. J. Approve, No Comments (b)
Si Hongjie -
Sivanesan Kathiravetpillai -
Sjoberg Sten Approve, No Comments
So Tricci Disapprove
Son Jung Je Approve, Comments (a)
Son Yeongmoon Approve, Comments (b)
Song Ting-Chen (Tom) Approve, No Comments (a)
Song Young Seog -
Soong Anthony Disapprove (b)
Srinivasan Roshni Approve, Comments (b)
Stanwood Kenneth Approve, No Comments
Su Hsuan-Jung -
Su Huan-Yu -
Su Xin -
Sun Bo Disapprove (b)
Sun Hongmei -
Sun Li-Hsiang Approve, No Comments (b)
Sun Yakun -
Sun Yong -
Sung Doo-hyun Approve, No Comments (b)
Sydir Jaroslaw J Approve, Comments
Sydor John -
Takai Mineo Approve, No Comments (b)
Talukdar Anup Approve, No Comments (b)
Tang Yang Disapprove (b)
Tao Jeffrey -
Tao Ming-Hung Approve, Comments (b)
Taori Rakesh Approve, Comments (a)
Taylor Shawn Approve, No Comments (b)
Thakare Kiran -
Thome Timothy -
Ting Pangan Approve, No Comments (a)
Tonnerre Arnaud Approve, No Comments
Trigui Hafedh -
Tsai Chang-Lan Approve, No Comments (b)
Tsai Shiau-He -
Tsai Tsung-Yu Disapprove (a)
Tsai Yi-Hsueh Approve, No Comments (b)
Tseng Fan Shuo Approve, No Comments (a)
Tseng Hsien-Wei Disapprove (b)
Tzavidas Stavros Disapprove (b)
Ullmann Rainer Disapprove
Urban David -
Vadgama Sunil Disapprove
Vannithamby Rath Approve, Comments (b)
Venkatachalam Muthaiah Approve, Comments (b)
Viorel Dorin -
Vook Frederick Disapprove (b)
Vrzic Sophie -
Walker Kenneth -
Wang Arthur -
Wang Chun-Yen Approve, No Comments (b)
Wang Fan Approve, No Comments (b)
Wang Jiacheng Approve, No Comments (b)
Wang Lai-Huei -
Wang Lei Disapprove (b)
Wang Li -
Wang Michael -
Wang Ping Approve, No Comments (b)
Wang Shu-Shaw -
Wang Xiaoyi -
Wang Yanhong Disapprove (b)
Ward Matthew -
Watanabe Fujio Approve, No Comments
Watanabe Yoshikazu Approve, Comments (a)
Wei Hung-Yu Disapprove (a)
Willey Dan -
Wu Ciouping Approve, No Comments (b)
Wu Jia-Hao Approve, No Comments (b)
Wu Qi Approve, No Comments (b)
Wu Shih-Lin -
Wu Xuyong Disapprove (b)
Xia Xin -
Xie Chengjie -
Xu Changlong Approve, No Comments
Xu Hongliang -
Xu Hua -
Xu Jin Disapprove (b)
Xu Ling Disapprove
Yaghoobi Hassan Approve, Comments (b)
Yang Chang Feng -
Yang Chih-Cheng Disapprove (a)
Yang Feng-Ming Approve, No Comments (a)
Yang Hongwei Approve, No Comments (a)
Yang Rongzhen Approve, Comments (b)
Yang Xiangying Approve, Comments (b)
Yang Yunsong Disapprove (b)
Yanover Vladimir Disapprove (b)
Yeh Choong Il -
Yin Hua-Chiang Approve, No Comments (b)
Yin Hujun Approve, Comments (b)
Yoo Hwasun Approve, Comments (a)
Yoshii Isamu Disapprove (b)
Yu Hyunkyu Approve, Comments (a)
Yu Kai Approve, No Comments (b)
Yuk Young Soo Disapprove (b)
Yun Jungnam -
Zein Nader Approve, No Comments (b)
Zeira Eldad Disapprove (b)
Zeng Yunbao -
Zhang Jie -
Zhang Jinyun -
Zhang Kaibin Disapprove
Zhang Yuantao -
Zhao Zheng Approve, No Comments (b)
Zheng Haihong -
Zheng Xufeng Approve, No Comments (b)
Zheng Yan-Xiu Approve, No Comments (a)
Zheng Zhongbin -
Zhou Hua Disapprove (a)
Zhou Lei Approve, Comments (b)
Zhu Chenxi -
Zhu Jing Approve, Comments (b)
Zhu Peiying Disapprove
Zhu Yuan Approve, Comments (b)