IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #16: Ballot Report

Letter Ballot #16 progress, in inverse chronological order:

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #16b: Announcement {CLOSED, with responses; ballot complete and terminated}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Recirculation Ballot #16a: Announcement {CLOSED}

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #16: Announcement {CLOSED}

Summary Results

Report Date Approve Dis Sum Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Approval+
2005/03/17 114
02
116
98.3%
Yes
10
126
151
83.4%
Yes
0
Yes
2005/03/05
113
03
116
97.4%
Yes
10
126
151
83.4%
Yes
0
Yes
2005/01/11 106 05 111 95.5% Yes 11 121 151 80% Yes 0 Yes*
2004/11/18 99 07 106 93% Yes 11 117 151 77% Yes 0 Yes*
2004/11/02 71 34 105 68% No 11 116 151 77% Yes 0 No*
*Pending comments resolution and recirculation.
+No comments or votes received. No outstanding unresolved Disapprove comments from remaining Disapprove voters.

Ballot Details

[ Updated 2005-03-17 ] [Note: "-" means "did not yet return a ballot".]

Name\Family Name\Given Letter Ballot #16 Recirc Ballot #16a Recirc Ballot #16b
Agis Edward Approve, No Comments

Agrawal Aditya Approve, No Comments

Al-Dabagh Baraa Approve, No Comments

Aliotta Mario Approve, No Comments

Andelman Dov Approve, No Comments

Antonello Gordon -
Approve, No Comments
Athalye Sanjeev Approve, No Comments

Avivi Eli - Approve, No Comments
Banerjea Raja Approve, No Comments Approve, Comments
Banister Brian -

Barber Phillip Approve, No Comments

Baum Kevin Approve, Comments**

Bentov Izhar - Approve, No Comments
Bhalla Rajesh -
Approve, No Comments
Cai Sean Approve, No Comments

Castelow David Approve, Comments**

Cavalli Giulio Approve, No Comments

Chang Dean Approve, No Comments

Chang Jae Hwan Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Chang Yong Approve, Comments**

Chayat Naftali Approve, No Comments

Chayer Remi Approve, No Comments

Chindapol Aik Approve, No Comments

Cho Jaeweon Approve, Comments**

Cho Seokheon -

Choi Hyoung-Jin Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Approve, No Comments
Chou Joey Approve, Comments** Approve, Comments
Chung Jin Yong Approve, No Comments

Costa Jose Approve, No Comments

Cudak Mark Approve, Comments**

Draper Frank Approve, No Comments

Dring John Approve, No Comments

Eastwood Lester Disapprove
Approve, No Comments
Eidson Brian Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Eklund Carl Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Eliaspur Yigal Approve, No Comments

Eline Roger Approve, No Comments

Elkayam Oren Approve, Comments**

Fong Mo-Han Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Franovici Bogdan Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Freedman Avraham Approve, No Comments

Goldhamer Mariana Approve, No Comments

Golshan Reza Approve, No Comments

Guo Qiang Approve, Comments**

Hadad Zion Approve, No Comments

Hahn Yung Approve, No Comments

Han Jun Approve, No Comments

Hartman David -

Haskin John Approve, No Comments

Hwang Seung Ku -

Iyer Prakash Approve, No Comments

Jeong Moo Ryong Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Johnson Brian Approve, Comments**

Johnston David -

Joo Panyuh Approve, Comments**

Kaitz Tal Approve, No Comments

Kelman Ofer - Approve, No Comments
Kerr Adam Approve, No Comments

Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments

Kim Jeonghwi Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Kim Jung Won Approve, Comments**

Kim Yong Bum Approve, No Comments

Kim YoungKyun Disapprove***

Kitroser Itzik Approve, Comments**

Koo Changhoi Approve, Comments**

Kotecha Lalit Approve, No Comments

Kulick John -

Kwon Dongseung -

LaBrecque Margaret Approve, No Comments

Labs Jonathan Approve, No Comments

Lamoureux Jules Pierre Approve, No Comments

Lee Chang-jae Approve, No Comments

Lee Jae Hak Approve, No Comments

Lee Seong Choon Approve, No Comments

Leiba Yigal Approve, Comments**

Leimer Donald -

Lewis Barry Approve, No Comments

Li Lingjie -

Li Xiaodong Approve, No Comments

Liebetreu John Approve, No Comments

Lim Geunhwi -

Lim Hyoungsoo Approve, No Comments

Lim Yong Je -

Lindskog Erik -

Lo Titus Approve, No Comments

Lou Hui-Ling Approve, No Comments

Lycklama Heinz Approve, No Comments

Lynch Michael Disapprove Approve, No Comments
Lysejko Martin Approve, No Comments

Maeng Seung Joo Approve, Comments**

Maez David - Approve, No Comments
Mandin Jeffrey Approve, Comments**

Mankin Kevin Approve, No Comments

Marks Roger Approve, No Comments

McCallum Ian -

McKown Russell Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Migaldi Scott Approve, Comments**

Mollenauer James Approve, Comments**

Moon Dong-Il (Stephan) Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Murias Ronald - Approve, No Comments
Nelson Robert Disapprove Approve, No Comments*
Nitsche Gunnar Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Odlyzko Paul Approve, Comments**

Olfat Masoud -

Ovadia Shlomo Approve, No Comments

Park Nam Hoon -

Park Pyung-Su -
Approve, No Comments
Park Youn Ok -

Pearman Trevor Approve, No Comments

Petrus Paul -

Phillips Greg Approve, No Comments

Puthenkulam Jose Approve, Comments

Rath Kamlesh Approve, No Comments

Riegel Maximilian Approve, No Comments

Rogers Chris Approve, No Comments

Ryu Byung-Han -

Ryu Kiseon -
Approve, No Comments
Sago Andrew Approve, No Comments

Salvekar Atul Approve, No Comments

Schwartz Randall Approve, No Comments

Segal Yossi Disapprove
Approve, No Comments
Selea Radu Approve, No Comments

Shakouri Mohammad Approve, No Comments

Shankaranarayanan N.K. Approve, Comments**

Shasha Eli Approve, Comments**

Simkins James Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise

Son Jung Je Approve, Comments**

Son Yeong Moon Approve, Comments**

Stanwood Kenneth Approve, No Comments

Stevenson Carl -

Taylor Shawn Approve, No Comments

Tong Wen Approve, Comments**

Trinkwon David -

Ullmann Rainer Approve, Comments**

Vafai Mano -
Approve, No Comments
Verbin Eyal Approve, No Comments

Vook Frederick Approve, Comments**

Wang Arthur Approve, No Comments

Wang Irving Approve, No Comments

Wang Jing -

Wang Lei Approve, Comments**

Wang Stanley Approve, No Comments

Whitehead Philip -

Wieczorek Alfred Disapprove***

Yaghoobi Hassan Approve, No Comments

Yanover Vladimir Approve, No Comments

Yeh Choong-Il -

Yeo Kunmin -

Yoon Chulsik Approve, No Comments

Yu Chang Wahn Approve, No Comments

Zhu Peiying Approve, Comments**

**Converted from Disapprove after deadline or based on comment resolution.
***All binding comments resolved satifactorily.