IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #9: Voting Report


[Note: Following IEEE Sponsor Ballot, and changes made therein, the revised draft was approved by the IEEE-SA Standards Board on 12 June 2003 as IEEE Standard 802.16/Conformance01-2003.]

Motion: To forward IEEE P1802.16.1/D1-2002 for LMSC Sponsor Ballot.

Document under review: "Draft Standard for Conformance to IEEE Standard 802.16 - Part 1: Protocol Implementation Conformance Statements for 10-66 GHz WirelessMAN-SCTM Air Interface"

Opening date: 21 November 2002
Closing date: 21 December 2002 (anywhere in the world)

IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #9: Announcement

Summary (Final)

Report Date Approve Dis Votes Approval
Ratio
Approval Ratio
Condition Met
(>75%)
Abstain Ballots Members Return
Ratio
Return Ratio
Condition Met
(>=50%)
Return
Shortfall
Motion
Approval
2002/12/24 41 0 41 100.0% Yes 8 49 83 59.0% Yes 0 Approved*
*Non-binding comments were resolved by a Ballot Resolution Committee. A new draft P1802.16.1/D2-2002 was then recirculated, along with the comment resolutions, in Working Group Recirculation Ballot #9a. from 31 December 2002 - 14 January 2003. No responses were received during the recirculation, so Letter Ballot #9 was declared successful and closed.

Ballot Details (Final)

[Note: "-" means "did not return a ballot".]

Name\Family Name\Given Vote
Agrawal Aditya Approve, No Comments
Antonello Gordon Approve, No Comments
Arefi Reza Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Arrakoski Jori Approve, No Comments
Audeh Malik Approve, No Comments
Avivi Eli Approve, No Comments
Banister Brian Approve, No Comments
Benyamin- Seeyar Anader Approve, No Comments
Buskila Baruch Approve, No Comments
Chang Dean Approve, No Comments
Chayat Naftali -
Chayer Rémi Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Edmonston Brian Approve, No Comments
Eidson Brian Approve, No Comments
Eilts Henry -
Eklund Carl Approve, Comments
Fan John -
Freedman Avraham Approve, No Comments
Garrett Andrew -
Garrison G. Jack Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Goldhammer Marianna -
Hadad Zion -
Howell Randy -
Hulse Grant Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Husson David -
Joo Panyuh -
Kaitz Tal -
Kelly Phil -
Kelman Ofer Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Kiernan Brian Approve, No Comments
Kitroser Itzik Approve, No Comments
Klerer Mark Approve, No Comments
Kolze Thomas Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Krinock Jerome Approve, No Comments
Kuo Chun-Ming -
Labs Jonathan Approve, No Comments
Lee Seung-Hwan -
Leiba Yigal Approve, No Comments
Levinson Moshe -
Li Lingjie -
Li Xiaodong (Alex) -
Liebetreu John Approve, No Comments
Lindh Lars Approve, No Comments
Lou Hui-Ling Approve, No Comments
Lycklama Heinz -
Marks Roger Approve, Comments
McKown Russell Approve, No Comments
Middleton Andrew Approve, No Comments
Mody Apurva Approve, No Comments
Mollenauer James Approve, No Comments
Murias Ronald -
Nelson Robert Approve, No Comments
Olszewski Kim -
Patel Manish -
Peirce Kenneth -
Ponnuswamy Subbu Approve, No Comments
Reible Stanley -
Robinson Gene Approve, No Comments
Rogers Shane Approve, No Comments
Roman Vincentzio Approve, No Comments
Sarajedini Amir -
Sarca Octavian -
Schwartz Randall Approve, No Comments
Segal Yossi Approve, No Comments
Selea Radu Approve, No Comments
Simkins James Approve, No Comments
Singh Manoneet -
Son Jung Je -
Sonander Sean Approve, No Comments
Stanwood Kenneth Approve, Comments
Struhsaker Paul -
Taylor Shawn -
Thomson Bill Approve, No Comments
Trinkwon David Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
Ullmann Rainer Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise
van Waes Nico Approve, No Comments
Wang Arthur -
Wang Lei Approve, Comments
Wang Stanley -
Ward Robert -
Whitehead Philip -
Wilson Joanne -
Yanover Vladimir -