Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

RE: [RPRWG] More comments on preemption



The preemption issue is directly linked with the data rates that RPR will support, but not exclusively. It is also linked with the services that RPR will provide at lower rates. My opinion is that delay and jitter bounded committed services will be implemented over high rate RPR rings (1G and up). Some users may choose to apply RPR for lower rates to provide these services, but those will be limited to LAN applications that are more tolerant.
Since for high rates, even with jumbo frames, preemption does not provide a substantial (compared with the implementation complication) jitter and delay gain, we should avoid it.
Note that this does not preclude using RPR at lower rates for applications that do not require committed delay and jitter guarantees.
 
Leon