David,
Thanks for you comment. I
will start to put together a spreadsheet which will include all the comments I
receive.
Also, I would recommend that
all liaisons with other working groups review this document or consider
recruiting some help reviewing the document.
Steve
From: David Cypher
[mailto:david.cypher@nist.gov]
Sent: Monday, December 12, 2005
11:35 AM
To: Shellhammer, Steve;
stds-802-19@ieee.org; aik.chindapol@siemens.com; carl.stevenson@ieee.org;
guenter.kleindl@siemens.com; giffordi@ieee.org; jerry.upton@ieee.org;
Joseph.Levy@interdigital.com; mjlynch@nortelnetworks.com; nada.golmie@nist.gov;
bheile@ieee.org; Roger B. Marks; Shellhammer, Steve; sli@sibeam.com;
swhitesell@vtech.ca; stuart.kerry@philips.com; tom.siep@ieee.org
Subject: Re: IEEE 802.19 TAG
Conference Call
My high level comment about the 802.15.4a CA Annex E, is that it is
incomplete and that trying to find answers within the draft text is impossible
due to it being incomplete too. This letter ballot is like many other previous
ballots, they are placed in letter ballot well in advance of being complete for
even 802.15 WG procedures.
I have a list of over 70 comments that support this observation/position.
Therefore the comment that I propose for the 802.19 TAG to consider is.
The entire document is not sufficiently complete to consider the contents of
the letter ballot any further.
=====================================================
At 01:39 PM 12/12/2005, Shellhammer, Steve wrote:
IEEE 802.19 TAG,
We will be
having a TAG (not a study group) conference call on Wednesday December 14 at 12
Noon Eastern Time (9 AM Pacific Time).
The agenda
is as follows,
AGENDA
- Discuss 802.15.4a CA document (Appendix E of the
802.15.4a draft)
- Discuss document 19-05-0045 Coexistence Parameter
by Joseph Levy
To prepare for the meeting I would request that people review the documents
prior to the call and come prepared to make comments and ask questions.
The bridge
information is,
TO ATTEND THE AUDIO CONFERENCE:
1. Call 858-845-5000
2. After the greeting press 1 to attend meeting.
3. Enter Meeting ID 80219 followed by the # sign.
4. Enter Meeting Password 80219 followed by the # sign.
5. Follow the remaining prompts for recording the callers name and joining the
meeting.
For assistance, dial #0 at any time.
Regards,
Steve