Re: FW: [802SEC] Comments from 802.16 regarding proposed P802.19 PAR

[Tom Siep <tom.siep@xxxxxxxx>]

802.19 SG,

Proposed modified text for your consideration is in the attached doc

FWIW my take on the comments:

(1) In Section 13 (Scope of Proposed Project), it is not clear how rigorously the methodologies will assess
coexistence of wireless networks. Will assessment involve only physical characteristics of transmissions (and
reception) or go further to examine protocol or network aspects of potential coexistence?

Fair comment.  I thought it was implied by our text, but it seems to need to be specific.

(2) The statement in the Scope “though the methods developed here may be applicable in other places” is
ambiguous.

I think the term meant is "non-specific", rather than "ambiguous".  The phrasing is not ambiguous -- it is quite clear that this is not the only place the resultant document may find use.  I supplied text to make the other uses more specific, but the alternative is to drop the phrase altogether as not being relevant to the IEEE process.

Comments welcome,
Tom


Shellhammer, Steve wrote:

802.19 SG,

	Looks like we got comments on our PAR from 802.16.  Please plan
to attend the SG meeting tomorrow morning at 8AM so we can address these
comments.

Steve

-----Original Message-----
From: Roger B. Marks [mailto:r.b.marks@ieee.org] 
Sent: Tuesday, March 07, 2006 2:01 PM
To: STDS-802-SEC@listserv.ieee.org
Subject: [802SEC] Comments from 802.16 regarding proposed P802.19 PAR

Steve,

IEEE 802.16 is submitting two comments to the 802.19 TAG regarding 
the proposed P802.19 PAR. You can find these on the LAN at:
	http://lan.wirelessman.org/16/le/docs/80216h-06_007.pdf

or on the Internet at:
	http://wirelessman.org/le/docs/80216h-06_007.pdf

Regards,

Roger

Dr. Roger B. Marks  <mailto:r.b.marks@ieee.org> +1 303 497 7837     
Chair, IEEE 802.16 Working Group on Broadband Wireless Access
        <http://WirelessMAN.org>


  

IEEE 802 Executive Committee,

This is a notification of the following PAR and 5C which I
intend to bring up for a vote at the March Plenary session in Denver,
CO.

The documents can be found at,

http://ieee802.org/19/pub/2005/19-05-0053-06-0SG1-PAR-Assessing-Coexist
    

ence.doc
  

----------
This email is sent from the 802 Executive Committee email reflector.
This list is maintained by Listserv.


  

-- 
Tom Siep
Cambridge Silicon Radio
tom.siep@csr.com
Office: +1 972  496-0766 (GMT -6)
Mobile: +1 214  558-4358                

19-05-0053-06-0SG1-PAR-Assessing-Coexistence-tms_01.doc