Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [802.19] Straw Poll

Nancy,
  Why do you quote 75% and exceptions to rules?  What rules?
This was a straw vote, not a formal motion.  There is no requirement of 75%
A straw vote is used to "test the water". 
Steve posted the results of the straw, which he based his conclusions on.
Work on item two can be done and not be an exception to the rules.

Use cases and scenarios must be done, but since these are numerous a subset may need to be selected to be workable.
Metrics / measurements must also be done in conjunction or what are your use cases or scenarios good for?
Given these two, the others should fall into place.

David Cypher
==========================================
At 06:29 PM 4/18/2009, Nancy Bravin wrote:
HI Steve,

I would recommend that we concentrate on the use case / scenarios which is the only one that passed over 75%, and that will provide an accurate
roadmap of what needs to be done. That may or may not include the other questions, or may provide
a better way of defining how to do it.  We will in the end have more participation if we can get consensus over 75% in all areas we work on.
Otherwise we are always working with exceptions to the rules.

Just an opinion, Nancy 
 
From: whitespace@xxxxxxxx [ mailto:whitespace@xxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Shellhammer, Steve
Sent: Saturday, April 18, 2009 2:22 PM
To: 802. 19 TAG (stds-802-19@xxxxxxxx); 802TVWS (WHITESPACE@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx)
Subject: RE: Straw Poll
 
All,
 
                I would like to thank everyone for their participation in the Straw Poll.  Here are the results.
 
 []
 
                As you can see the only task that received overwhelming support was Task 1 on Coexistence Scenarios.  The other three tasks received mixed results.
 
                Clearly we should do Task 1.  I would also say that we received 2/3 support for Task 2, so in my personal opinion we should consider doing Task 2 on coexistence metrics.
 
                The support for Tasks 3 and 4 are spit almost down the middle.   We can discuss these on Tuesday?s conference call.  However, given mixed support I am not sure it makes sense to consider these at this point.  It might make sense to plan for Tasks 1 and 2 and after those are complete reconsider whether there is support for Tasks 3 and 4.  Let?s discuss on Tuesday?s call.
 
                Also, and email comments are welcome.
 
Regards,
Steve
 
 
From: whitespace@xxxxxxxx [ mailto:whitespace@xxxxxxxx] On Behalf Of Shellhammer, Steve
Sent: Tuesday, April 14, 2009 5:20 PM
To: 802. 19 TAG (stds-802-19@xxxxxxxx); 802TVWS (WHITESPACE@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx)
Subject: Straw Poll
 
All,
 
                Here are the instructions for the straw poll on TVWS coexistence SG deliverables.
 
Straw Poll Instructions
 

1.        Save the attached spreadsheet and change the file name to your personal name in the form ?First_Last?

2.        In Column B row 1 change the word ?Name? to your personal name

3.        In Column B rows 2-5 enter either ?Yes?, ?No? or ?Abstain? for each of the possible SG deliverables, indicating your support or lack of support for development of each deliverable

4.        Save the revised file and email it back to me by the end of the day on Friday April 17.  There is no need to send the file to the entire email list
 
Regards,
Steve