| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
G’day Steve I don’t have a presentation ready yet. However, I can tell you that a group of IEEE 802 stakeholders are working behind the scenes on responses to the most recent 3GPP RAN1 LS for discussion in San Diego. The draft is not quite ready for “prime time”
discussion in 802.19, but it is getting close. I can tell you that it in relation to consensus between IEEE 802 and 3GPP RAN1 on the responses in the 3GPP RAN1 LS, there is likely to be: ·
No consensus on about a quarter of the responses
·
Some consensus on about a half of the responses
·
Full consensus on about a quarter of the responses
This is very encouraging, reflecting a relatively productive relationship between the two organisations (IEEE 802 and 3GPP RAN1). As usual with any technical discussion/negotiation, the hard part is to close
off the last few important issues. The proposed response is being structured so that the response to each of the twelve 3GPP RAN1 responses to the IEEE 802 comments can consist of multiple self-contained parts. This is being done so that different
perspectives from a diversity of stakeholders can be expressed on each of the sub-issues related to each comment. This means the question for 802.19 in San Diego will not be “do you agree with every part of the responses?”, but rather “
do you agree that there is value in 3GPP RAN1 considering these responses?”, which should make progress easier. If anyone would like to contribute a response to the 3GPP RAN1 response or a sub-issue within a 3GPP RAN1 response, feel free to send it to me or reply to the 802.19 reflector. Any reasonable response will probably
be included in the draft for consideration by 802.19 in San Diego. Andrew PS I will also have a separate presentation (from me as an individual) related to the request from 3GPP RAN1 that IEEE 802.11 WG consider using ED = -72dBm in the future rather than our current ED/PD mechanism.
I will upload this next week. From: Shellhammer, Steve [mailto:sshellha@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx]
Does anyone have a presentation they would like to make at the Thursday conference call on 3GPP Liaisons? http://ieee802.org/19/pub/calls.htm Steve |