RE : Requirements doc posted
Hello again,
Michael,
I am of those not really in favour of having the Rquirement Document divided as proposed. The requirements could end up loosing their overall clarity and understanding. Further, the suggested division does not partition the document perfectly. What I mean is the document does not only discuss
Triggers, information database and layer 2.5 but quite a lot more!
Finally, I think having general reference models (to be detailed in subsequent documents) make no harm but rather illustrates the Req document in a interesting way and can therefore be kept.
Eric Njedjou
France Telecom
-----Message d'origine-----
De : owner-stds-802-21@listserv.ieee.org [mailto:owner-stds-802-21@listserv.ieee.org] De la part de Michael.G.Williams@nokia.com
Envoyé : jeudi 22 juillet 2004 01:44
À : STDS-802-21@listserv.ieee.org
Objet : Requirements doc posted
For those of you interested in the requirements document development, here is an event notification ;^)
There have been no comments for or against the ideas of dividing the requirements doc into three parts, or the idea of removing the reference model from the requirements and adding them to the proposals. Please comment if either of these proposals would affect our ability to move forward. If no comments occur by July 27th, we will continue with the document as structured.
Our Editor has the revised document up on the website under the July folder as revision 5. All members of the requirements ad hoc please read through this and comment on the new version before the July 27th conference call.
In particular, some sections are awaiting input. We shouldn't wait until the 26th to incorporate those sections into the agenda for the call. Please submit text for :
* 3.8 Cost
* 3.9 Link Utilization
* 3.10 User experience
* 6 (all) Reference models
Please review the other sections you were concerned about at the end of our last meeting. If we are able to get the remaining submissions in, and all concerns addressed, we will still reach consensus in time for call for proposals in August.
Best Regards,
Michael Williams
IEEE 802.21 Vice Chair