| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Hi Ludwig, Agenda – Rather than Recap of Geneva Tutorial, let’s call these first slides Use Cases, that seems to be what they mostly are. Or Background. I think we will need to reduce the number of slides in this section somewhat to allow time for
the technical detail slides. Then we need to make this cover the 802.1 and 802.3 combined functionality – it is a bit too tipped toward just 802.3br right now:
·
Architectural overview - i.e. the MAC interface and split of functionality above and below the MAC.
·
Technical overview of Functions added above the MAC Client Interface – transmission selection adjustments for scheduling and preemption, control protocol
·
Technical overview of Functions below the MAC Client interface – MAC Merge sublayer operation and framing. I think once the agenda is fixed this way, the slides are okay to share with the author/reviewer ad hoc – possibly with a note that the terminology (e.g. DMLT) needs to be updated. I don’t see anything inflammatory in it. Some other comments as I come across them, not in order of significance.
Page 2 – white on light blue text (column titles and presenter names) is hard to read – suggest changing to black text. Why are some email addresses in light blue and some in black? On slide 12 (and check for usage elsewhere) any terminology that evolved between study group and PAR should be updated to current – so let’s remove DMLT and replace with IET (spelled out in first usage). Since this is a joint IEEE 802.1
and IEEE 802.3, should replace slide 12 with something covering the components of the solution: Traffic scheduling and preemption from 802.1 and Interspersing Express Traffic from 802.3 Michael, should something about 802.1CB also be said – adding it to the tutorial seems like a lot to load into one 90 minute slot – perhaps mention that it’s related to these use cases but the technical info isn’t covered in this tutorial? Regards, Pat From: Winkel, Ludwig [mailto:ludwig.winkel@xxxxxxxxxxx]
FYI, I updated the San Antonio folder. The San Antonio draft meeting minutes and the closing report are uploaded now. http://www.ieee802.org/3/br/public/2014-11%20San%20Antonio,%20TX/ The IEEE 802 SEC approved our request to held a tutorial in Berlin 2015. We got the 1st slot. Those who announced during the joint .1/.3 meeting their
willingness to contribute will get soon a 1st draft outline (name list see Annex A in the San Antonio minutes). If more people are interested to contribute, please let me know.
Mit freundlichen Gruessen / With best regards,
Chair of the IEEE P802.3br Task Force Vice-chair of IEC SG8 Convenor of IEC SC65B/WG16 Convenor of IEC SC65C/WG17 Convenor of IEC SC65C/MT9 Convenor of CENELEC TC65X/WG1 Mail: Siemens AG , PD TI FC
From: Winkel, Ludwig [mailto:ludwig.winkel@xxxxxxxxxxx]
We will have the joint meeting 802.3IET/802.1TSN by Thursday starting at 10am in the room Lone Star B. Mit freundlichen Gruessen / With best regards,
Chair of the IEEE P802.3br Task Force Vice-chair of IEC SG8 Convenor of IEC SC65B/WG16 Convenor of IEC SC65C/WG17 Convenor of IEC SC65C/MT9 Convenor of CENELEC TC65X/WG1 Mail: Siemens AG , PD TI FC
|