Dear Bob,
PPTs are already uploaded.
Regarding the right timing for the WG ballot, is a difficult
issue. Many people in the TF are working hard to achieve the
original schedule. We do have pressure from the Japanese OEMs,
they do not want to delay their commercial usage of the standard.
In my personal opinion, if we have done the work properly for the
July meeting, we should try to stay in the original schedule.
I understand the concerns, but we also have a lot of pressure.
May be other participants in the TF have other opinion, but as far
as I know people wants to speed up if feasible.
Regards
Carlos
El 29/5/15 a las 19:07, ROBERT GROW
escribió:
Carlos:
Sorry for the slow response, but I’ve been thinking about
your question. We haven’t been doing this previously, but I
received a number of comments about the source of contributions
for the May meeting being all KDPOF. So, it might be good to
add to the May meeting page something like Co-Located PMD Ad Hoc
and put the presentations under that heading. People reviewing
the web site prior to July would then see a broader
participation. Let’s do it.
On another topic.
David Law again expressed his wish that we postpone until
September advancement to WG ballot. That of course is only
possible if the proposed rules change allowing that passes in
July. He is hoping that we could pass a motion allowing
either going ahead in July or in September if the rules change
allowing it passes. We will still presubmit the draft as we
can’t be sure the rules change will pass.
I think David is motivated in this preference by a number
of factors.
1. If I have it right, three projects will be
pre-submitting for WG ballot in July. If all are successful,
that means that all three will need to be balloted between
July and September. That is a very heavy balloting load for
WG members. Especially when considering that two other
projects are in WG ballot recirculation now (br, bq), and one
in Sponsor ballot recalculation (bw).
2. The other projects have undergone many more TF reviews
than we have. (Going into the May meeting, bn = 5, bp = 5, bv
= 1).
3. We will not be pre-submitting a technically complete
draft, but instead will be completing the draft in July. We
will compare unfavorably to the other two projects on this and
the amount of review. P802.3bw suffers from the same
perception of a single company driving the work, but probably
less so than we do. It went through limited TF review and in
my opinion went to WG ballot technically incomplete (no PICS).
—Bob
Dear
Bob,
should these be posted in the web ?
Carlos
El 26/5/15 a las 9:29,
Volker Goetzfried escribió:
Dear all,
attached are the slides I've shown during our
Ad-hoc meeting in Pittsburgh.
Regards,
Volker
--
Best regards,
Volker Götzfried
R&D, Application Engineer
Tel.: +49 (0) 941/2978-4129
Fax: +49 (0) 941/2978-4252
Avago
Technologies Fiber GmbH
Wernerwerkstr. 2
93049 Regensburg
GERMANY
Amtsgericht
Regensburg HRB 10719
Geschäftsführer: Otto
Gruber, Martin Weigert
(English translation:
Geschäftsführer=Managing
Director, Amtsgericht=Local
Court)
--
Carlos Pardo
KDPOF
CEO
--
Carlos Pardo
KDPOF
CEO
|