| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Comment 394 will be removed from the EZ bucket. On reconsideration, the editor’s proposed response is changed to from PROPOSED ACCEPT to PROPOSED REJECT, with the explanation that, after further review of the text, the revision draft (802.3bx) and the text of IEEE 802.3-2012, the “2
1 0” header in the base standard is underlined, not to indicate a change, but to make it clear that these are column headers identifying bits in a multi-bit code, consistent with use in the base standard – hence the underlining should be retained. A new response will be posted as below, along with any other changes, prior to the meeting.
Any other changes in proposed responses will similarly be forwarded to the reflector. Cl
45
SC 45.2.3.7
P
43 L
38
394 Comment Type
E Change marking in Table 45-123 indicate that the "2 1 0" at top of description are being added (they are underlined). This is not the case. SuggestedRemedy Remove underlining of the "2 1 0" header. PROPOSED REJECT - after review of the current 802.3 revision draft (802.3bx) and the text of IEEE 802.3-2012, the “2 1
0” header in the base standard is underlined, not to indicate a change, but to make it clear that these are column headers identifying bits in a multi-bit code, consistent with use in the base standard – hence the underlining should be retained. Comment Status
D Thanks to Valerie Maguire for finding this. -george zimmerman Chief Editor, IEEE P802.3bq 40GBASE-T Task Force George Zimmerman Principal, CME Consulting Experts in Advanced PHYsical Communications Technology george@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx 310-920-3860 (PLEASE NOTE NEW EMAIL ADDRESS.
THE OTHER WILL STILL WORK, BUT PLEASE USE THIS FOR CME BUSINESS) |