Re: [BP] SDD21 Concern

[Joe M Abler <abler@xxxxxxxxxx>]

Hi Joel,
Your summary was good.  In my view, the objective at this point in time should be not to move the curve down any more the necessary to address the primary issues you raised at the last meeting.  It's my understanding those main issues were below 3GHz, and it would be my preference to keep the changes to that range only.  I don't think there's anything sacred in having a single equation, and the changes could easily be accomodated by breakpoints for appropriate frequency ranges.

Thanks,        Joe


Joe Abler                                                             abler@us.ibm.com
IBM Microelectronics Division                          919-254-0573
Technical Marketing & HSS Applications    919-254-9616 (fax)
3039 Cornwallis Road                                                                 
Research Triangle Park, NC  27709

Joel Goergen <joel@force10networks.com> Sent by: owner-stds-802-3-blade@listserv.ieee.org 09/08/2004 01:27 PM Please respond to joel

To:        STDS-802-3-BLADE@listserv.ieee.org         cc:                 Subject:        [BP] SDD21 Concern

Hi Everyone.

I'm really concerned that no one has agreed or disagreed with any of my personal observations on the SDD21 mask.  I'm hoping everyone received what was sent.

Further, I was hoping for discussion and I don't see any at all.

????
-joel