Re: [BP] Signaling spread sheet
Mike, and others who were on the Signaling ad hoc conf call last week,
This is exactly the type of spreadsheet I was referring to. Actually, I
was in the process of making good on my action item to post a starter
spreadsheet, but Mike beat me to it :) Attached is the spreadsheet that
was used by 1000BASE-T, and was used as a starting point in 10GBASE-T.
Mike, here are some additional parameters I'd add to what you have
already:
* Details on the receiver architecture, so that the complexity can be
independently verified.
- Forward equalizer tap spacing (T, T/2, etc)
- Forward equalizer number of taps
- Feedback equalizer number of taps
* Jitter tolerance
* Latency
* Noise immunity (using a impulse or sinusoidal interferer, aka the Ron
Crane Test)
* A/D Converter rate and precision (if applicable)
* D/A Converter rate and precision (if applicable)
Regards,
Vivek
-----Original Message-----
From: owner-stds-802-3-blade@listserv.ieee.org
[mailto:owner-stds-802-3-blade@listserv.ieee.org] On Behalf Of Altmann,
Michael W
Sent: Thursday, October 28, 2004 10:44 PM
To: STDS-802-3-BLADE@listserv.ieee.org
Subject: [BP] Signaling spread sheet
Dear IEEE802.3ap TF Members (Signalig ad hoc),
Further to our discussions regarding comparison metrics for signaling
schemes, I created the first cut of a spreadsheet for coding selection
similar to that used by the 10Gbase-T Task force. Comments/critiques
are all welcome. I am not planning to discuss this in the signaling ad
hoc on 29 October, given it's relative new-ness.
Regards.
.../Mike
<<IEEE Coding Table v3.xls>>
<<1000baset_comparison[1].pdf>>
1000baset_comparison[1].pdf