Comments P802.3df

Comments on IEEE P802.3df Drafts



******  IEEE SA Ballot *******


Draft 3.2





Unsatisfied negative comments




Listed by Clause
18 December 2023

Final responses to comments




Listed by Clause
18 December 2023


Listed by ID
18 December 2023

Proposed responses to comments




Listed by Clause
14 December 2023


Listed by ID
14 December 2023

Received comments




Listed by Clause
13 December 2023


Listed by ID
13 December 2023








Draft 3.1





Unsatisfied negative comments



Listed by Clause 15 November 2023

Final responses to comments



Listed by Clause 14 November 2023


Listed by ID 14 November 2023

Proposed responses to comments



Listed by Clause 6 November 2023


Listed by ID 6 November 2023


Bucket1 (Listed by ID)
6 November 2023

Received Comments



Listed by Clause
30 October 2023


Listed by ID
30 October 2023




Draft 3.0





Unsatisfied negative comments



Listed by Clause
9 October 2023

Final responses to comments



Listed by Clause 28 September 2023


Listed by ID 28 September 2023

Proposed responses to comments



Listed by Clause
1 September 2023


Listed by ID
1 September 2023


Bucket1 (Listed by Clause)
1 September 2023

Received Comments



Listed by Clause 18 August 2023


Listed by ID 18 August 2023


comment i-115 attachment
31 August 2023


******  Working Group Ballot *******


Draft 2.1





Final responses to comments



Listed by Clause
11 July 2023


Listed by ID
11 July 2023

Work in progress




Listed by Clause - as of 10 July 2023 (with responses updated reflecting bucket1 motion and offline consensus building)
10 July 2023


Listed by ID - as of 10 July 2023 (with responses updated reflecting bucket1 motion and offline consensus building) 10 July 2023

Proposed responses to comments



Listed by Clause
29 June 2023


Listed by ID
29 June 2023


Bucket1 (Listed by Clause)
29 June 2023

Received Comments



Listed by Clause
26 June 2023


Listed by ID
26 June 2023




Draft 2.0





Unsatisfied negative comments



Listed by Clause
8 June 2023


Listed by ID
8 June 2023

Final responses to comments



Listed by Clause 26 May 2023


Listed by ID 26 May 2023

Proposed responses to comments



Listed by Clause - v2 Updated 22 May 2023
     Listed by Clause (old)
22 May 2023
5 May 2023


Listed by ID - v2 Updated 22 May 2023
    Listed by ID (old)
22 May 2023
5 May 2023


Bucket1 (Listed by Clause)
5 May 2023


Bucket 2 comment report (by ID)
24 May 2023

Received Comments



Listed by Clause 17 April 2023


Listed by ID 17 April 2023





******  Task Force Review *******


Task Force review comments on D1.1

Final responses to comments against Draft 1.1

     All: (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)
     1 February 2023

Proposed responses to comments against Draft 1.1

    All: (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)       29 January 2023 
        --- Old  All: (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)       20 January 2023   
    Bucket1:  (Listed by clause)   20 January 2023

  Received comments against Draft 1.1
    (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)  16 Jan 2023  Updated files containing late comments
    (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID11 Jan 2023  Original files





Task Force review comments on D1.0

Final responses to comments against Draft 1.0

     All: (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)
     08-Dec 2022

Proposed responses to comments against Draft 1.0

      All: (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)
     29-Nov 2022

     All: (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)
     Bucket 1: (Listed by clause)
     28-Nov 2022

  Received comments against Draft 1.0
     (Listed by clause) or (Listed by ID)
     16 Nov 2022


Return to the IEEE P802.3df Task Force Area
Last Update: 18 December 2023

[Search] [e-mail] [Standards Home Page] [Corporate Home Page]