RE: [EFM] [EFM-OAM] OAM Transport Proposal
Brad,
I assume that Hiroshi already prepared part of the list of changes, as the
original promoter of the method.
But, beyond the changes, keep in mind that the new proposal includes the
case of
Preamble as an addition to frames based management.
This means that we will have these changes anyway, proposed as additions to
the MAC.
What can be added to the proposal is a very simple mechanism that will allow
auto-sense of preamble only.
One simple way is to send upon link up a limited number of preamble messages
(maybe ping).
If the other side does not respond that means that does not support the
method - or is
down with the link active. In this case the regular operation is resumed.
This will generate a minimum number of link errors and just upon link up
(anyway an instable
moment).
This is one way. But the main issue is that we should support the link
management
of non MAC based optical termination units.
Sergiu Rotenstein
>>-----Original Message-----
>>From: Booth, Bradley [mailto:bradley.booth@xxxxxxxxx]
>>Sent: Tuesday, April 23, 2002 5:08 PM
>>To: Sergiu Rotenstein; 'stds-802-3-efm@ieee.org'
>>Subject: RE: [EFM] [EFM-OAM] OAM Transport Proposal
>>
>>
>>Sergiu,
>>
>>I assume that an 802.3 repeater would be similar in concept to this
>>converter you mention. For that, I can understand that a MAC
>>level OAM may
>>not be sufficient to provide the link/PHY level OAM that
>>would be required.
>>
>>As much as OAM in preamble may solve the problem, I am still
>>concerned about
>>the changes required to 802.3 to provide this capability. I
>>think that it
>>would be great if an OAM in preamble supporter could compile
>>a list of the
>>changes required to existing clauses to add this feature.
>>
>>I just want the task force and working group to be
>>well-informed about what
>>we're signing up to do.
>>
>>Thanks,
>>Brad
>>
>>______________________
>>Sent from my Blackberry...
>>
The information contained in this electronic mail is privileged and
confidential, intended only for the use of the individual or entity named
above. If the reader of this message is not the intended recipient, you are
hereby notified that any dissemination, distribution, or copying of this
communication is strictly prohibited. If you receive this communication in
error, please immediately notify Disclaimer@xxxxxxxxxx Thank you.