[802.3BA] WG Ballot Results Update

[John DAmbrosia <jdambrosia@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>]

Dear Task Force Participants,

I have been informed by the WG Chair that the results of the IEEE P802.3ba / D2.0 WG ballot have been updated to reflect the change in status of one individual.  No comments had been received from this individual, resulting in the classification “A Disapprove without Comment.”   This individual has demonstrated that comments had been emailed per the stated deadline in the announcement of the Working Group ballot.  Therefore the WG chair has updated this individual’s status as “Disapprove with Comment” and the comments will be considered by the Task Force.

 

The updated ballot results are:

 

Voters	229
Approve	87
Disapprove with comment	32
Disapprove without comment	3
Abstain	10
Returns	132

 

These returns resulted in the following metrics:

RespRate	57.64%
AppRate	73.11%
AbsRate	7.58%

 

The ballot is still valid as it met the requirements for response rate ( >=50% ) and abstention rate ( < 30% ).

 

The following breakdown by comment type is an update based on the comments received discussed above, late comments received, and review of the comments received.

 

Description	Editor	Clause	TR	T	ER	E	Total
Front matter, MAC, 40G & 100G Intro	Ilango Ganga	99, 00, 01, A, 4, 4A, 31B, 80	29	14	20	27	90
Management	Hugh Barrass	30, 45	22	29	24	45	120
RS/MII and PCS	Mark Gustlin	81, 82	23	15	7	21	66
PMA	Steve Trowbridge	83, 83C	11	3	9	11	34
XLAUI/CAUI	Ryan Latchman	83A, 83B	33	53	17	14	117
Backplane KR4 related	Arthur Marris	69, 69A, 69B, 73, 74, 84	24	15	18	7	64
Copper CR4 & CR10	Chris Di Minico	85	43	53	13	29	138
Optical SR4 & SR10	Piers Dawe	86	30	45	24	17	116
Optical 40G LR4	Jonathan King	87	3	14	6	3	26
Optical 100G LR4 & ER4	Pete Anslow	88	9	8	8	2	27
Total comments			227	249	146	176	798

 

Regards,

 

John D’Ambrosia

Chair, IEEE P802.3ba Task Force