Re: [802.3_MAINT] FW: IEEE 802.3 WG Maint - Revision - XLAUI/CAUI and Stat Eye Mask comments - August 8th telecon reminder
Re-sent to the Maintenance
reflector without Qlogic’s restrictive notice. Sorry if you got
this twice.
Mike,
The notes and wording of 52.9.7
was discussed on today’s call. The consensus view was that we would
keep the notes ( but re-word them), that the text of 52.9.7 needs some
modification and that we would also need to modify the PICS of clause 52.
Jonathan is going to draft a
proposal for discussion on next week’s call.
Regards,
Pete Anslow |
Senior Standards Advisor
43-51 Worship Street | London,
EC2A 2DX, UK
Direct +44 2070 125535 |
From: Mike Dudek [mailto:mike.dudek@xxxxxxxxxx]
Sent: 08 August 2011 18:35
To: Mike Dudek; Jonathan King; STDS-802-3-MAINT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx; Ali
Ghiasi; Anslow, Peter; brian misek; Chris Cole; David Lewis; Ganon, Oren;
Jeffery Maki; John Petrilla; Marco Mazzini (mmazzini); Matt Traverso
(mattrave); Piers Dawe; ryan.latchman@xxxxxxxxxxxxx; scott kipp; Wael Diab
Subject: RE: [802.3_MAINT] FW: IEEE 802.3 WG Maint - Revision -
XLAUI/CAUI and Stat Eye Mask comments - August 8th telecon reminder
Sorry. This was
sent before I completed it. See below for the full text.
Mike Dudek
QLogic Corporation
Senior Manager Signal
Integrity
26650 Aliso Viejo
Parkway
Aliso Viejo CA
92656
949 389 6269 -
office.
Mike.Dudek@xxxxxxxxxx
From: Mike Dudek
Sent: Monday, August 08, 2011 10:33 AM
To: 'Jonathan King'; STDS-802-3-MAINT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx; Ali Ghiasi;
Anslow, Peter; brian misek; Chris Cole; David Lewis; Ganon, Oren; Jeffery Maki;
John Petrilla; Marco Mazzini (mmazzini); Matt Traverso (mattrave); Piers Dawe;
ryan.latchman@xxxxxxxxxxxxx; scott kipp; Wael Diab
Subject: RE: [802.3_MAINT] FW: IEEE 802.3 WG Maint - Revision -
XLAUI/CAUI and Stat Eye Mask comments - August 8th telecon reminder
Sorry I
couldn’t make the eye mask call today. I agree with the
general content and am a supporter. I have a suggested change to
the proposed solution.
Change
Add notes to the
transmitter eye mask definition in each of tables 52-7, 52-12, 52-16:
“Either transmitter eye mask test may be used. The alternative hit ratio
transmitter eye-mask test method is described in 86.8.3.2.”
To
Add at the end of
52.9.7. “Two eye masks are defined. The first is
the original eye mask as defined by the 802.3ae project. The alternative
eye mask was added by the 802.3-2012 amendment project. Either
transmitter eye mask test may be used and a pass to either mask test is a pass.
The alternative hit ratio transmitter eye-mask test method is described in
86.8.3.2.
Mike Dudek
QLogic Corporation
Senior Manager Signal
Integrity
26650 Aliso Viejo
Parkway
Aliso Viejo CA
92656
949 389 6269 -
office.
Mike.Dudek@xxxxxxxxxx
From: Jonathan King
[mailto:jonathan.king@xxxxxxxxxxx]
Sent: Sunday, August 07, 2011 11:33 PM
To: STDS-802-3-MAINT@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx; Ali Ghiasi; Anslow, Peter; brian
misek; Chris Cole; David Lewis; Ganon, Oren; Jeffery Maki; John Petrilla; Marco
Mazzini (mmazzini); Matt Traverso (mattrave); Mike Dudek; Piers Dawe;
ryan.latchman@xxxxxxxxxxxxx; scott kipp; Wael Diab
Subject: Re: [802.3_MAINT] FW: IEEE 802.3 WG Maint - Revision -
XLAUI/CAUI and Stat Eye Mask comments - August 8th telecon reminder
A reminder of Monday
morning teleconference 8th August , provisional agenda and call
details below .
Placeholder
supporting slides on both topics are attached
If you are unable to
see the attachments, e-mail me and I’ll send them direct.
Best wishes
jonathan
Agenda:
Alternative statistical eye
mask for clause 52
·
8.00 roll call
- 8.05 IEEE patent
policy
- 8.07 Minutes
of call 1st August
- 8.10
Review of revised placeholder supporting slides
- Review of text for notes
associated with alternative eye mask coordinates to be added to tables
52-7, 52-12, 52-16
- 8.25 questions and
discussion
- 8.50 closing
remarks/actions
- 9.00
end
XLAUI/CAUI minimum VMA spec for
clause 83B
• 9.00
roll call
• 9.05
IEEE patent policy
• 9.10
recap of issue and proposed remedy
– Update on
new simulations – Mike Dudek (if available)
– Review of
placeholder supporting slides – Jonathan King
• 9.25
questions and discussion
• 9.50
closing remarks/actions
• 10.00
end
Note: Mike’s had just 1
week for simulations, so this may be a short meeting
CALL DETAILS:
As
noted during the July plenary maintenance meeting, I intend to submit two
comments on the 802.3 revision draft on these topics:
Alternative
optical Tx eye-mask for 10GBASE-R modules (Clause 52)
and
XLAUI/CAUI
TP4 VMA specification issue (Clause 83B)
Presentations
covering each comment and the proposed remedies were presented at the
July meeting, and are available here:
http://www.ieee802.org/3/maint/public/index.html
YOU
ARE INVITED to comment and contribute on teleconference calls to be held on Monday 8th August,
Monday 16th August, Monday 22nd August
TIMING:
calls will run from 8 am to 10 am, Pacific Coast Time
8
am to 9 am for discussion of Alternative optical Tx eye-mask for 10GBASE-R
modules (Clause 52) and
9
am to 10 am for discussion of XLAUI/CAUI TP4 VMA specification issue (Clause
83B)
CALL DIAL IN NUMBERS, Monday 8th, 15th, 22nd
from USA: 866 654 5792
outside USA: +1 832 445 3154
Conference code: 4085425032
INTENTION:
to review the comments and proposed remedies, and to arrive at a broad
consensus for the specific proposals for text changes to 802.3.
I
plan to submit comments and supporting materials together with a list of
supporters by Aug 25th.
I'll
send out meeting materials the day before each meeting. I also anticipate
that we'll use e-mail and the maintenance reflector to allow off-line review of
drafts texts/slides.
Looking
forward to working with you
If
you have any questions or suggestions ahead of the calls, please feel free to
call or e-mail me Thanks !
Also,
if you know of anyone else who is likely to be interested in the discussion,
and who is not subscribed to the maintenance reflector, feel free to forward
this message and suggest they contact me.
Jonathan
King
Finisar
Corp
1389
Moffet Park Drive
Sunnyvale,
CA 94089
Cell
phone: +1 408 368 3071
E-mail:
jonathan.king@xxxxxxxxxxx