| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Hi Yair
Some more comments on your
presentation:
- Rather than having PSE Ilim_min = PD Ilim_max + 1mA; I
think it will be a cleaner solution to increase the Tlim_min for PSE from
50ms to 51ms (or 55ms to make it a round figure). My third point will make it
clear why I like this approach (This makes energy based policing
easy).
- I do not like the term Ilim_min for PSE. The whole
reason why we have current limiting at PD is so that we do not have to do
current limiting at the PSE. We need to come up with a better
name.
- In 802.3af we had Ilim_min/Icut_min = 14.28%. There is no
rational reason why we need to keep this ratio the same for 802.3at. We have
much more advanced processes today.
We need to come up with the minimum PD Ilim_max that is
acceptable to everyone. There is also no reason why we need
to specify that there be a maximum duty cycle of 5%. Even if we impose this, it
is highly unlikely that a PSE is going to check for 5% dutycycle over 1s. All we
care is the threshold and average current. If the PD draws more than Iport_dcmax
(720mA) for more than 51ms (or 55ms) then the PSE can shut off the PD.
There is no averaging involved here. This is a hard threshold as in AF -
Icut/Tcut
If the average current drawn by the PD over 1 second
is greater than Iport_dcmax (720mA) then the PSE can shut off the
PD.
Thank
you
Anoop
From: owner-stds-802-3-poep@ieee.org [mailto:owner-stds-802-3-poep@ieee.org] On Behalf Of Yair Darshan Sent: Tuesday, June 26, 2007 4:22 AM To: STDS-802-3-POEP@listserv.ieee.org Subject: Re: [8023-POEP] IEEE 802.3at Vport ad hoc meetings Tuesday June 26; materials Hi
Fred, Some
comments: Slide 4:
Icut_max/Icut_min is 0.4/0.3-1=14.28% and not 7% as
stated. Slide 5: I like the
simplicity of how PD is specified in 802.3af then how it presented in slide 5:
We should allow utilizing the full 29.5W as permited by the average current of
0.72A. We can do it easily by keeping the same concept and margins as in
802.3af. Having 14.28% margin between Icut_max to Icut_min allows
it. It is difficult to
understand slide 5. I disagree with the 1st bullet. We should allow
implementations that uses dc current with ac ripple within the range specified
between Icut_max to Icut_min limited to 50msec max and 5% duty as in
802.3af. Slide 6: The point of
having the current limit at the PD was to solve inrush current due to dv/dt in
PSE and dealing with long TLIM_MIN.
This slide suggests that PD with less then Cpd_max don’t have to implement
current limit. This was exactly the case in 802.3af so what is the purpose of
having all this PD current limit discussion? If Cpd is 179.9UF<180U then Tlim
_min may be still 12.6msec and we are back to square 1 = 3month
ago.. The solution is what I
thought last meeting: PD will limit the current within 1msec to ICUT_MAX so we
will have to charge only 0.12uF for the rest of the 50msec max of TCUT. See my
presentation that explains the whole thing. Slide 6: This slide is
relevant only if PD limits to Icut_min. which doesn’t support a solution to
utilizing max 29.5W. See my presentation for proposal to solve this
issue. In addition, please
allocate time to discuss my presentation that may help to solve some issues that
was supposed to be solved by moving the current limit to the PD and in my
opinion are still requires some discussion. The rest looks
fine. Yair From:
Hello, IEEE
802.3at, Vport ad hoc team meetings are scheduled for Tuesday June 26,
July 3, and July 10 (9 AM, PST) to cover current limits required for PoE. Please
review the direction we are heading at: http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/3/at/public/may07/schindler_5_28_07.pdf Please also
review: http://grouper.ieee.org/groups/802/3/at/public/may07/avetteth_0507.pdf Please
ensure that you review the IEEE-SA PatCom slides [ http://standards.ieee.org/board/pat/pat-slideset.pdf
] prior to the start of the conference call. At the start of call I will ask
that everybody confirms that they have read this material - if anybody hasn't we
will pause the call until they confirm that they have done
so. Thanks, Fred ______________________________________________________________________________ Frederick
Schindler has invited you to a Cisco Unified MeetingPlace
Conference Date/Time:
JUN 26, 2007 at 9:00AM Length:
60 Frequency:
3 Meeting
ID:
131128329 Meeting
Password:
Global
Access Numbers: http://cisco.com/en/US/about/doing_business/conferencing/index.html US/Canada:
+1.866.432.9903 United
Kingdom: +44.20.8824.0117
TO ATTEND
A WEB AND VOICE CONFERENCE: CISCO
INTRANET ATTENDEES Join the
Web & Voice Conference* 1. Go to
http://meetingplaceinternal.cisco.com/join.asp?131128329 2. Enter your CEC User ID & Password then click
OK - Accept any security
warnings you receive and wait for the Meeting Room to
initialize 3. Click on CONNECT from the Meeting Room to join the
Voice Conference portion of the meeting EXTERNAL
ATTENDEES - Outside the Cisco Intranet** Join the
Web & Voice Conference* 1. Go to
http://meetingplace.cisco.com/join.asp?131128329 2. Fill in the My Name is field then click Attend Meeting - If you have a CEC User ID,
click on the Cisco icon - Accept any security
warnings you receive and wait for the Meeting Room to
initialize 3. Click on CONNECT from the Meeting Room to join the
Voice Conference portion of the meeting *If this is your first time
attending a Web Conference, disable any pop-up blockers and visit http://meetingplace.cisco.com/mpweb/scripts/browsertestupper.asp
to test your web browser for compatibility with the Web
Conference. **Not all meetings are
scheduled to allow external attendees into the Web Conference portion of the
meeting, if the URL does not work, please follow the Voice only Conference
instructions below to attend. TO ATTEND
A VOICE ONLY CONFERENCE 1. Dial into Cisco Unified
MeetingPlace (view the Access Numbers and link
above) 2. Press 1 to attend the
meeting 3. Follow the prompts to
enter the Meeting ID 131128329 and
join the meeting SUPPORT Information
about this Conference: Contact Frederick
Schindler, 14085259859 Cisco IT
GLOBAL
ACCESS NUMBERS COUNTRY
LOCATION
LOCAL
NUMBER
TOLL
FREE-FREEFONE
West
+1.408.525.6800
1.866.432.9903 Argentina
Buenos Aires
+54.11.4341.0101 Brazil
Brasilia
+55.613.424.0220
Regina
+1.306.566.6410
Toronto
+1.416.306.7230
Vancouver
+1.604.647.2350
Winnipeg
+1.204.336.6610 Chile
Santiago
+56.2.431.4936 Colombia
Bogota
+57.1.325.6065 Mexico
Mexico City
+52.55.5267.1800 Peru
Lima
+51.1.215.5101 Puerto
Rico
San Juan
+1.787.620.1865 Venezuela
Caracas
+58.212.902.0210 EMEA
Austria
Vienna
+43.12.4030.6022 Belgium
Diegem
+32.2.704.5072 Bulgaria
Sofia
+359.2.937.5938 Croatia
Zagreb
+385.1.462.8908 Denmark
Aabyhoj
+45.8.939.7131
Copenhagen
+45.3.958.5010
Hallbergmoos
+49.811.554.3016 Norway
Oslo
+47.23.27.3647 Poland
Warsaw
+48.22.572.2615 Portugal
Lisbon
+351.21.446.8756 Slovakia
Bratislava
+421.2.5825.5309 South
Africa
Johannesburg
+27.11.267.1011
Pretoria
+27.12.844.7401
United
Arab Emirates
(UAE)
HongKong
HongKong
+852.3414.1802
Wellington
+64.4.496.5554 Phillipines
Makati (Manila) +63.2.750.5886 Singapore
Singapore Capital +65.6317.7088
Ho Chi Minh City
+84.8.823.3418
(Saigon)
Technical
Leader CISCO
Systems M/S
SJ-19-3 Tel. (408)
525-9859 |