| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Hi Clay, My comments to your
proposal: 1. Why to define 15K as a
solution. It may be better to define "invalid signature" which is
R<15k OR R>33K. 2. Your solution request
to be in non valid signature even if the spike was 1 picoseconds. And the PD
saw class even for just very short time. So do we want to show invalid
detection for just very short time? How it affect cost, complexity. 3. Your solution force
specific implementation as was mentioned in July meeting. I thought that we
prefer to let the vendor make the design tricks to overcome this issue. I would like us also to
discuss the following topics: 1. Imark current limit value.
I am suggesting to change it to 100mA. 2. To delete the text
that requires to measure both Icalss_lim and Imark_lim to the requirement of
checking Iclass_lim only (during the measurement of I class). I guess that we will have
support for it and we could also propose a motion to address it as well. 3rd topic that
I would like to discuss is Yair From: Hello All,
The meetings are limited to 1 hour and commence at: |