| Thread Links | Date Links | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Thread Prev | Thread Next | Thread Index | Date Prev | Date Next | Date Index |
|
Hello Clint,
Since there were a number of comments submitted in the last ballot from disapprove voters, are you saying that these are all old issues? If they are new issues and not resolved to the satisfaction of the commenter, then an unchanged recirc would be required.
I count around 40 technical comments that are in-scope and based on the resolutions. If these are old issues then how they fall into that category should be documented in the resolutions.
There are 28 comments rejected with a resolution "Group failed to reach consensus to make a change to the draft". It is good practice to document the consensus building process in the resolution, for example, summarize the nature of the discussion, the voting
result and when the voting took place.
The resolution to comments 4 and 41 is "Group thinks this is an editorial matter, draft will be professionally edited prior to publication" (reclassifying a technical comment as editorial). It is hard for me to see this as an editorial (the comment identifies
a 75% overlap as being in error and suggests it should be 25%). If it is editorial, how the group arrived at that conclusion deserves some explanation.
The resolution to comment 106 ("PICs are an informative annex") is not responsive to the comment ("PICS is missing a lot of entries"). This would also presumably be one of the old issues (a reference to previous resolution would be useful).
Regards,
-Robert
From: ***** IEEE 802 LAN-MAN Standards Committee ***** <STDS-802-LMSC@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> on behalf of Clint Powell <cpowell@xxxxxxxx>
Sent: Sunday, February 1, 2026 11:08 PM To: STDS-802-LMSC@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx <STDS-802-LMSC@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx> Subject: [802-LMSC] Conditions Met for LMSC Conditional Approval to Start SA Balloting of P802.15.4ab-D04 All, Let this email serve as notice that the Conditions to proceed with moving the P802.15.4ab draft to SA Ballot, approved by the LMSC at the Nov. LMSC Closing Plenary, have been met. · The recirculation was completed prior to the next (March) LMSC Plenary. on Jan. 8, 2026 vs. expected date of Jan. 7, 2026 at time of conditional approval · The Approval rate was 91.89%, and there were no new valid DISAPPROVE votes · No technical changes are being made to the draft · There no new remaining valid DISAPPROVE comments on new issues that are not resolved to the satisfaction of the submitter from existing DISAPPROVE voters · Comments were reviewed and discussed by the TG4ab TG at the Jan. 802 Wireless Interim · At the conclusion of the TG4ab meetings on Jan. 15th, all comments ended up being rejected by the Task Group – comments and their disposition details can be found in the comment resolution database for LB227, which can be found at: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.15/documents?is_dcn=3&is_group=04ab&is_options=5&is_year=2026 · Task Group approved comment resolutions on Thurs., Jan. 15, 2026 · There were 4 new invalid DISAPPROVE comments from existing no voters that were rejected due to being out scope (on unchanged text in the draft) · LB227, the 3rd Letter Ballot Recirculation of the P802.15.4ab draft P802.15.4ab-D04 concluded on Jan. 8, 2026 (expected date of 1/7/26) with the following final audited aggregate results: · VOTERS 133 · VOTED 115 · YES 102 · ABSTAIN 4 · NO 9 · % VOTERS 86.47% · % YES 91.89% · % ABSTAIN 3.48% · Did Not Vote 18 · Did Not Vote % 13.5% · There were 122 total comments received An update to the package prepared for LMSC Conditional Approval to move the draft P802.15.4ab-D04 to RevCom, including the addition of a summary of LB227, has been posted at: https://mentor.ieee.org/802.15/documents?is_dcn=582&is_options=5&is_year=2025
Having met the Conditions of Approval, SA Balloting of the P802.15.4ab draft P802.15.4ab-D04 will now be initiated Best Regards, Clint Powell Managing Director – Wireless IoT Standardization, PWC LLC IEEE 802.15 WG Chair & IEEE 802 LMSC IEEE 802.15 TG4ab (NG-UWB) - Vice Chair CSA IEEE 802.15.4 PHY/MAC Advisory Group - Chair CSA Aliro CSG Certification Policy & Procedure - Tiger Team Lead Mobile/WhatsApp: 480 586-8457 Email: cpowell@xxxxxxxx To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-LMSC list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-LMSC&A=1 To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-LMSC list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-LMSC&A=1 |