IEEE 802 LAN/MAN Standards Committee

IEEE 802 LAN/MAN Standards Committee Appeals

The IEEE 802 LAN/MAN Standards Committee Policies and Procedures provide a means for members to appeal decisions to the Executive Committee. When this occurs, the Chair of the Executive Committee appoints a three-person appeal panel to hear the appeal and render a decision.

This page provides the material submitted by the member(s) making the appeal (appellant), the material submitted by the member(s) responding to the appeal (appellee), and the decision of the appeal panel. The appeals are listed in reverse chronological order.

Appeal of Charles S. Farlow v. 802 LMSC / 802.15.6 Ballot Resolution Committee (IEEE-SA appeal)
 - on decision to forward draft to RevCom / IEEE 802.15.6 BRC comment resolution
 - Appeal Withdrawn by appellant

Appellant - Appeal Withdrawal
Material from the appellant
Material from the appellee

Appeal of Jerry Upton (Chair, 802.20) v. 802 LMSC (IEEE-SA appeal)
 - on LMSC appeal panel decision on Mollenauer, et al

Material from the appellant
Material from the appellee
Decision of the IEEE-SA Standards Board appeal panel

Appeal of Jerry Upton (Chair, 802.20) v. 802 LMSC (IEEE-SA appeal)
 - on decision not to extend 802.20 PAR

Material from the appellant
 - Request for action by the EC
Material from the appellee
 - Additional material
Decision of the IEEE-SA Standards Board appeal panel

Appeal of Hassan Yaghoobi and Jose Puthenkulam v. Chair of 802.20

Material from the appellant
Material from the appellee
Decision of the appeal panel

Appeal of James F. Mollenauer, Val Oprescu, and Al Wieczorek v. Chair of 802.20

Material from the appellant
Material from the appellee
Decision of the appeal panel
Decision of the appeal panel (revised)
Rehearing request
Decision of the appeal panel after rehearing

Appeal of Dr. David V. James v. Chair and Vice Chair of 802.3

Material from the appellant
 - Supporting material
Material from the appellee
 - Supporting material
Decision of the appeal panel

Last Update: January 26, 2017

This page is maintained by
It has been designed to be compliant with HTML 3.2 and above and should work with all compliant browsers.

Privacy & Opting Out of Cookies