Re: [802SEC] +++ LMSC P&P Revision Ballot +++ Ballot on WG Membership

[Tony Jeffree <tony@jeffree.co.uk>]

Mat -

I vote Disapprove. While broadly in a greement with the intent, there are
a couple of things which need fixing still. Comments attached.

Regards,
Tony

At 00:13 27/04/2003 -0400, mjsherman@research.att.com wrote:

> Dear
> EC members,
>
>  
>
> Below is the status of the LMSC P&P
> Revision Ballot on WG Membership.  The ballot closes April 28, 2003
> 11:59 PM EDT. This is a couple of days away, and this is your FINAL
> warning to vote on this ballot.  Please get in your votes and
> comments so we can have a successful comment resolution on the
> ballot.  (Remember if you do not vote or abstain it is equivalent to
> a DISAPPROVE vote). But more importantly, to have successful ballot
> resolution we need to know why you disapprove.  So make your opinion
> known.  Please identify any inaccuracies you detect in my status
> report. Also, not everyone has been using the comment form I provided for
> their formal comments.  When I say comments provided, they have
> often been informal comments that I intend to include in ballot
> resolution.  Note that due to the large number of rules issues all
> running at once, I am not now taking the time to summarize all the
> comments to date as I have in the past.  I will generate a summary
> document and distribute it well before comment resolution on this ballot
> occurs. 
>
>  
>
> Best Regards,
>
>  
>
> Mat
>
>                                    
>
>  
>
> Ballot Results and comments as of
> 4/26/03 
>
>  
>
> 00 Paul
> Nikolich                                  
> DNV     
>
> 01 Geoff
> Thompson                 
> DIS                  
> Comments Provided     
>
> 02 Matthew
> Sherman                                
> DNV
>
> 03 Buzz
> Rigsbee                                   
> DNV   Comments Provided  
>
> 04 Bob
> O'Hara                     
> DIS                  
> Comments Provided     
>
> 05 Bill
> Quackenbush                               
> DNV
>
> 06 Tony
> Jeffree                                   
> DNV
>
> 07 Bob
> Grow                       
> DIS                  
> Comments Provided
>
> 08 Stuart
> Kerry                                   
> DNV
>
> 09 Bob
> Heile                                      
> DNV
>
> 10 Roger
> Marks                                    
> DNV     
>
> 11 Mike
> Takefman                  
> DIS                  
> Comments Provided
>
> 12 Carl
> Stevenson                                 
> DNV
>
> 13 Jim
> Lansford                                   
> DNV
>
> XX Mark
> Klerer                                          
> Comments Provided
>
> XX Robert
> Love                                          
> Comments Provided
>
> XX Ken
> Alogne                                           
> Comments Provided
>
> XX Reza
> Arefi                                           
> Comments Provided
>
> XX Joanne
> Wilson                                        
> Comments Provided
>
>  
>
> -------------------------------------------------------
>
>            
> totals:      0 APR   4 DIS  
> 0 ABS  10 DNV
>
>  
>
> 10 APPROVES (2/3 majority) are required
> to PASS. 
>
>  
>
>  
>
>  
>
>  
>
> Matthew Sherman 
> Vice Chair, IEEE 802
> Technology Consultant 
> Communications Technology Research 
> AT&T Labs - Shannon Laboratory 
> Room B255, Building 103 
> 180 Park Avenue 
> P.O. Box 971 
> Florham Park, NJ 07932-0971 
> Phone: +1 (973) 236-6925 
> Fax: +1 (973) 360-5877 
> EMAIL: mjsherman@att.com 
>
>

Regards,
Tony

IEEE-802-LMSC-P&P-Revision-Comment-Form-for-WG-Membership-ballot_r1.xls