RE: [802SEC] +++ LMSC P&P Revision Ballot +++ Ballot on WG Membership
Hi
Mat,
I also vote disapprove; my main
concern is the either/or of attendance or letter of intent in 5.1.3.1. I
think many people today understand the 75% rule for two plenaries...I think it's
reasonable to ask them to confirm their interest after they have met an
attendance criteria, but not simply to get voting rights on the basis of a
LOI. Similarly, there could be a somewhat relaxed attendance requirement
for transition from a Study Group, but still confirmed with an (electronic) LOI
confirmation. This would avoid the automatic voting rights issue that I
think a lot of us are uncomfortable with.
Best,
Jim
P.S.
And my apologies for not using the comment form, but I only have the single
comment.....
Mat
-
I vote Disapprove. While broadly in a greement with the intent, there
are a couple of things which need fixing still. Comments
attached.
Regards,
Tony
At 00:13 27/04/2003 -0400,
mjsherman@research.att.com wrote:
Dear EC members,
Below is the status of the LMSC P&P Revision
Ballot on WG Membership. The ballot closes April 28, 2003 11:59 PM
EDT. This is a couple of days away, and this is your FINAL warning to vote
on this ballot. Please get in your votes and comments so we can have a
successful comment resolution on the ballot. (Remember if you do not
vote or abstain it is equivalent to a DISAPPROVE vote). But more
importantly, to have successful ballot resolution we need to know why you
disapprove. So make your opinion known. Please identify any
inaccuracies you detect in my status report. Also, not everyone has been
using the comment form I provided for their formal comments. When I
say comments provided, they have often been informal comments that I intend
to include in ballot resolution. Note that due to the large number of
rules issues all running at once, I am not now taking the time to summarize
all the comments to date as I have in the past. I will generate a
summary document and distribute it well before comment resolution on this
ballot occurs.
Best Regards,
Mat
Ballot Results and comments as of 4/26/03
00 Paul
Nikolich
DNV
01 Geoff
Thompson
DIS
Comments Provided
02 Matthew
Sherman
DNV
03 Buzz
Rigsbee
DNV Comments Provided
04 Bob
O'Hara
DIS
Comments Provided
05 Bill
Quackenbush
DNV
06 Tony
Jeffree
DNV
07 Bob
Grow
DIS
Comments Provided
08 Stuart
Kerry
DNV
09 Bob
Heile
DNV
10 Roger
Marks
DNV
11 Mike
Takefman
DIS
Comments Provided
12 Carl
Stevenson
DNV
13 Jim
Lansford
DNV
XX Mark
Klerer
Comments Provided
XX Robert
Love
Comments Provided
XX Ken
Alogne
Comments Provided
XX Reza
Arefi
Comments Provided
XX Joanne
Wilson
Comments Provided
-------------------------------------------------------
totals: 0 APR 4 DIS 0
ABS 10 DNV
10 APPROVES (2/3 majority) are required to PASS.
Matthew Sherman
Vice Chair, IEEE 802
Technology Consultant
Communications Technology Research
AT&T Labs - Shannon Laboratory
Room B255, Building 103
180 Park Avenue
P.O. Box 971
Florham Park, NJ
07932-0971
Phone: +1
(973) 236-6925
Fax: +1
(973) 360-5877
EMAIL:
mjsherman@att.com
Regards,
Tony