Letter Ballot #23 progress, in inverse chronological order:
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #23b: Announcement {CLOSED}
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot Recirc #23a: Announcement {CLOSED}
Call for Comments: Announcement {CLOSED}
IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #23: Initial Round {CLOSED}
| Report Date | Approve | Dis | Sum | Approval Ratio |
Approval Ratio Condition Met (>75%) |
Abstain | Ballots | Members | Return Ratio |
Return Ratio Condition Met (>=50%) |
Return Shortfall |
Approval+ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007/04/30 | 120 | 3 | 123 | .98 | Yes | 5 | 128 | 227 | .56 | Yes | 0 | Yes |
[ Updated
07/04/30, 03:02 PM (MT)
]
Note: This report is infrequently updated while the ballot is open. However, you may check a real-time report of ballot submittals.
| Name\Family | Name\Given | Letter Ballot #23 |
|---|---|---|
| Abrishami | Ray | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Agis | Edward | - |
| Ali | Murtaza | - |
| Andelman | Dov | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Asa | Masahito | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Athalye | Sanjeev | - |
| Austin | Mark | - |
| Barber | Phillip | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Baum | Kevin | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Bhalla | Rajesh | - |
| Bogenfeld | Eckard | - |
| Brandt | Achim | - |
| Cai | Sean | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Carlo | James | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Castelow | David | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (b) |
| Cavalli | Giulio | - |
| Cha | Jaesun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chang | Dean | - |
| Chang | Jae Hwan | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chang | Sungcheol | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chayat | Naftali | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chayer | Rémi | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chen | David | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chen | Yuehua (Lucy) | - |
| Chindapol | Aik | - |
| Cho | Jaehee | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Cho | Jaeweon | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Cho | Kihyoung | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Cho | Seokheon | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Choi | Hyoung-Jin | - |
| Choi | Joonyoung | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Choi | Yang-Seok | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Choi | Yun | - |
| Chou | Joey | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Chun | Jin Young | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Chung | Yun Won | - |
| Cook | Thomas | - |
| Costa | José | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Cudak | Mark | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Cummings | George | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Dang | Shujun | - |
| Draper | Frank | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Dudzinski | Krzysztof | - |
| Eastwood | Lester | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Edler | Tomas | - |
| Eklund | Carl | - |
| Elmdahl | Per | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Fahldieck | Torsten | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Feder | Peretz | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Feng | Dazi | - |
| Fong | Mo-Han | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Freedman | Avraham | - |
| Fu | I-Kang | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Fu | Yan | - |
| Giesberts | Pieter-Paul | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Goldhamer | Mariana | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Golshan | Reza | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Grandblaise | David | - |
| Guo | Qiang | - |
| Han | Jung Ho | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Hanaoka | Seishi | - |
| Harrang | Jeff | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Hart | Mike | - |
| Henderson | Gregory Scott | - |
| Hoghooghi | Michael | - |
| Holmes | David | - |
| Hsiao | Chang-Lung | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Huang | Haiming | - |
| Humbert | John | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Hur | Yerang | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Hwang | InSeok | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Ibbetson | Luke | - |
| Ihm | Bin-Chul | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Jeong | Moo Ryong | - |
| Johnson | Brian | - |
| Johnsson | Kerstin | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a) |
| Johnston | David | - |
| Joo | Panyuh | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kado | Youiti | - |
| Kanai | Takeo | - |
| Kang | Hyunjeong | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kelman | Ofer | - |
| Kiernan | Brian | - |
| Kim | Beomjoon | - |
| Kim | Bong Ho | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kim | Byoung-Jo | - |
| Kim | Dae-Joong | - |
| Kim | Ronny (Yong-Ho) | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kim | Sang Youb | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Kim | Youngho | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kim | YoungKyun | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Kitroser | Itzik | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Koo | Changhoi | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Koorapaty | Havish | - |
| Kuze | Toshiyuki | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Kwon | Dong Seung | - |
| Labs | Jonathan | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Laihonen | Kari | - |
| Lee | Geunho | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lee | Hyunjeong | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lee | Mihyun | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lee | Sang-Ho | - |
| Lee | Sungjin | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lee | Youn-Tai | - |
| Lewis | Barry | - |
| Li | Jia-Ru | - |
| Li | Jiang | - |
| Li | Jun | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Li | Thomas | - |
| Licitra | Gaspare | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Lim | Aeri | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lim | Geunhwi | Disapprove (a) |
| Lim | Hyoung Kyu | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lim | Sun Ju | - |
| Lin | Tzu-Ming | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Lin | Zhibin | - |
| Lycklama | Heinz | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Lynch | Michael | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Ma | Steve | - |
| Maez | David | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Maidment | David | - |
| Makhijani | Mahesh | - |
| Mandin | Jeffrey | - |
| Mao | Ronald | - |
| Marks | Roger | Disapprove (a) |
| Matatyaou | Asaf | - |
| Migaldi | Scott | - |
| Mollenauer | James | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Mont-Reynaud | Ollivier | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Muenzner | Roland | - |
| Mulder | Willem | - |
| Nakamura | Kenichi | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Nakamura | Michiharu | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Natarajan | K.S. | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Nohara | Mitsuo | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Odlyzko | Paul | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Oh | Min Seok | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Oprea | Radu | - |
| Paranchych | David | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Park | DS | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Peterson | Roger | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Piggin | Paul | - |
| Poston | Jeff | - |
| Poulin | Darcy | - |
| Probasco | Scott | - |
| Puthenkulam | Jose | Approve, Comments (a) |
| qian | nanjian (jeff) | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a) |
| Qu | Hongyun | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Raghavan | Arvind | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Ramachandran | Shyamal | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Rayal | Frank | - |
| Reid | Anthony | - |
| Ren | Fang-Ching | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Retnasothie | Francis | - |
| Riegel | Maximilian | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Roh | Wonil | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Ruck | Herbert | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Rush | Charles | - |
| Ryu | Kiseon | - |
| Saifullah | Yousuf | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Saito | Kenji | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Schlanger | Gary | - |
| Schmidt | Jörg | - |
| Schumacher | Joseph | Approve, Comments (b) |
| Sharon | Ariel | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Shasha | Eliyahu | - |
| Sheen | Wern-Ho | - |
| Sherman | Matthew | - |
| Shyy | D. J. | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (a) |
| Simkins | James | - |
| Sivanesan | Kathiravetpillai | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Sjoberg | Sten | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Somerville | Clare | - |
| Son | Jung Je | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Son | Yeong Moon | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Stafford | Robert | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Stanwood | Kenneth | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Suh | Kyungjoo | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Sun | Yong | - |
| Sydir | Jaroslaw | - |
| Sydor | John | - |
| Tang | Xiangguo | - |
| Taori | Rakesh | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Taylor | Shawn | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Teo | Koon Hoo | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Tong | Wen | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Tsai | Shiau-He | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Ullmann | Rainer | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Urban | David | - |
| Vadgama | Sunil | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Valbonesi | Lucia | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Van Leeuwen | Richard | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Verbin | Eyal | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Viorel | Dorin | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Vook | Frederick | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Wallenius | Eero | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Wang | Arthur | - |
| Wang | Guo Qiang | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Wang | Irving | - |
| Wang | Jing | - |
| Wang | Lei | Disapprove (b) |
| Wang | Michael | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Wang | Shu-Shaw | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Wang | Stanley | - |
| Waung | William | - |
| Wennstrom | Mattias | - |
| Wieczorek | Alfred | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Wu | Geng | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Wu | Xuyong | - |
| Wu | Yingzhe | - |
| Xiang | David | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Xu | Ling | - |
| Xu | Shanshan | - |
| Yagi | Akiyoshi | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Yang | Yunsong | - |
| Yaniv | Ran | - |
| Yanover | Vladimir | Approve, Comments (a) |
| Yin | Hujun | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Youn | Aeran | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Yun | Jungnam | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Yun | Mi-Young | Approve, No Comments (b) |
| Yuza | Masaaki | Abstain for Lack of Technical Expertise (b) |
| Zein | Nader | - |
| Zhu | Chenxi | - |
| Zhu | Peiying | Approve, No Comments (a) |
| Zhu | Yongjin | - |
| Zou | Lan | - |
(a) Recirc #23a
(b) Recirc #23b
*Following ballot close and/or comment resolution.