Thanks John.
I will revise accordingly.
Best Regards,
Rajat.
From: Wullert, John R II (PERATON LABS) <jwullert@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>
Sent: Wednesday, 2 March 2022 9:59 pm
To: Rajat PUSHKARNA <rajat.pushkarna@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx>; STDS-802-11-TGBE@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: RE: [STDS-802-11-TGBE] Requesting Feedback for 1681r11
Rajat,
I echo Yongho’s comment – the line “CFEHTMLDnonAP: M” should be removed on FT58.4/FT58.5.
John
Hi Yongho,
Thanks for your feedback. Please see my response inline and if it looks acceptable do let me know.
Best Regards,
Rajat.
Please see comments below.
CFEHTMLD
|
EHT MLD operation
|
Clause 35
|
[YH: Please fill this column.]
|
Yes: No:
N/A:
|
[RP]: Told by members to keep it blank as it is still not agreed.
FT58.4
|
EPCS Priority Access Enable Request frame
|
9.6.35.5
|
EHTM5: M AND CFEHTMLDnonAP: M
[YH: EPCS Priority Access Enable Request frame can be sent from AP MLD. Remove the 2nd sentence.]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
FT58.5
|
EPCS Priority Access Enable Response frame
|
9.6.35.6
|
EHTM5: M AND CFEHTMLDnonAP: M
[YH: Usually, EPCS Priority Access Enable Response frame is sent from AP MLD. Remove the 2nd sentence.]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
[RP]: Agree will change accordingly and send you the revised document.
EHTM2
|
Signaling of EHT operation
|
9.4.2.295a (EHT Operation element)
|
CFEHT AND CFSTAofAP:M
[YH: This is wrong. CFSTAofAP should be CFAP.]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
[RP]: Agree, will revise.
EHTM3.2
|
SRS Control
|
9.2.4.6a.9
9.2.4.7.9 (SRS Control)
|
CFEHT: O
[YH: SRS Control is used only for the MLD.
Change to CFEHTMLD: O]
|
EHTM3.3
|
AAR Control
|
9.2.4.6a.10
9.2.4.7.10 (AAR Control)
|
CFEHT: O
[YH: AAR Control is used only for the MLD.
Change to CFEHTMLD: O]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
EHTM9.7
|
Multi-link power management
|
35.3.12
[YH: In 35.3.13, the following features should not be mandatory.
35.3.12.3 MLD max idle period management
35.3.12.5 WNM sleep mode in multi-link operation
Please add two seperate items.]
|
CFEHTMLD: M
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
[RP]: Agree, will add the items
EHTM9.7.1
|
Dynamic link transitions
|
35.3.7.2
|
EHTM9.7: O
[YH: This should be change to CFEHTMLDAP: M
CFEHTMLDNSTRmobileAP:M
CFEHTMLDnonAP: O
Because this is for the single radio MLD, the AP MLD shall support the single radio ML operation by default.]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
EHTM9.16
|
Multi-link SCS procedure
|
35.3.22
|
CFEHTMLDAP: O
CFEHTNSTRMobileAP: O
CFEHTMLDnonAP: O
[YH: Please combine this into one entry.
CFEHTMLD: O]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
EHTM10
|
EHT sounding protocol
|
|
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
EHT10.3
|
EHT Sounding protocol as MU beamformer
|
35.6
|
EHT8.1 [YH: M or O?]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
EHTM10.4
|
EHT Sounding protocol as MU beamformee
|
35.6
|
EHT8.2 [YH: M or O?]
|
ÿ
Yes
ÿ
No
ÿ
N/A
|
[RP]: Sorry for the type, it’s ‘M’
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBE list, click the following link:
https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBE&A=1
To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBE list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBE&A=1
|