Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [STDS-802-11-TGBN] TGbn motion request



Hi Alfred,

 

I updated the supporting document list for the various SPs.

 

Thanks

Gaurang

 

From: Gaurang Naik
Sent: Tuesday, November 12, 2024 5:13 PM
To: Alfred Asterjadhi <asterjadhi@xxxxxxxxx>
Cc: STDS-802-11-TGBN@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
Subject: TGbn motion request

 

Hi Alfred,

 

Could you please queue the following motions?

 

  • Motion-1: Do you agree that an NPCA STA shall indicate the following to its peer NPCA STA?
    • NPCA switching delay
      • time it needs to switch from the BSS Primary channel to the NPCA Primary channel
    • NPCA switch back delay
      • time it needs to switch from the NPCA Primary channel to the BSS Primary channel
    • Delay values range between 0 and 256 us with a 4 us resolution

Supporting documents: [11-24/1218r1, 11-24/1155r0, 11-24/1260r1, 11-24/1104r3]

Straw poll result: No objection

 

  • Motion-2: Do you agree with the following:
    • An NPCA STA shall initiate frame exchange on the NPCA Primary channel with an NPCA Initial Control Frame in the non-HT PPDU or non-HT duplicate PPDU format using a rate of 6 Mb/s, 12 Mb/s, or 24 Mb/s
    • Details on NPCA ICF are TBD

Supporting documents: [11-24/1218r1, 11-24/1155r0, 11-24/1093r0, 11-24/1260r1, 11-24/1104r3]

Straw poll result: 148Y/12N/50A

 

  • Motion-3: Do you agree that an NPCA STA shall initiate a TXOP on the NPCA Primary channel following the rules defined in 10.23.2.2 (EDCA backoff procedure) and 10.23.2.4 (Obtaining an EDCA TXOP) with the following exception:
    • Every time the STA switches to the NPCA Primary channel, it shall initialize CW_NPCA[AC] to TBD value and pick a new backoff counter (BO_NPCA) randomly between 0 and CW_NPCA[AC]. QSRC_NPCA[AC] shall be set to 0.
    • NOTE – Baseline EDCA procedure is followed on the BSS Primary channel. The values of CW_NPCA and BO_NPCA are discarded by the NPCA STA when it switches back to the BSS Primary channel.

Supporting documents: [11-24/1218r1, 11-24/1155r0, 11-24/1260r1]

Straw poll result: No objection

 

  • Motion-4: Do you support that after an NPCA STA has gained the right to initiate a TXOP on the NPCA Primary channel, it can transmit on a set of channels that:
    • Includes the NPCA Primary channel, and
    • are within the AP’s BSS bandwidth, and
    • do not include the channels in the bandwidth occupied by the OBSS traffic that caused the NPCA STA to switch from the BSS primary channel to the NPCA primary channel, and
    • do not include the channels that are indicated as punctured in the Disabled Subchannel Bitmap subfield in the EHT Operation element,
    • It is TBD whether a frame that does not solicit TB PPDUs can puncture 20 MHz subchannels not indicated as punctured in the Disabled Subchannel Bitmap subfield of the EHT Operation element

Supporting documents: [11-24/1218r1, 11-24/1155r0, 11-24/1260r1, 11-24/1104r3]

Straw poll result: No objection

 

  • Motion-5: Do you agree to the following:
    • When transmitting a Trigger frame on the NPCA Primary channel, the NPCA AP shall signal the RU index considering the NPCA Primary channel as the reference primary channel
      • The Trigger frame shall explicitly indicate that it is transmitted via the NPCA Primary channel (details TBD)

Supporting documents: [11-24/1218r1, 11-24/1155r0, 11-24/1260r1]

Straw poll result: No objection

 

  • Motion-6: Do you agree to define a mode of operation in NPCA where the NPCA non-AP does not use untriggered UL transmissions on the NPCA primary channel
    • This mode can be enabled/disabled by the AP
    • Whether the mode is for all associated non-APs or per non-AP is TBD
    • TBD whether MU EDCA parameters mechanism is used for this or not

Supporting documents: [11-24/1218r1, 11-24/1155r0, 11-24/1093r0, 11-24/1260r1, 11-24/1104r3]

Straw poll result: No objection

 

Thanks

Gaurang

 


To unsubscribe from the STDS-802-11-TGBN list, click the following link: https://listserv.ieee.org/cgi-bin/wa?SUBED1=STDS-802-11-TGBN&A=1