Re: [STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [Handoff]Minutes from 6/24 telecon

["Kiernan, Brian G." <Brian.Kiernan@INTERDIGITAL.COM>]

Title: [STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [Handoff]Minutes from 6/24 telecon

If you haven’t uploaded these contributions yet, please note on the cover page that they are consensus documents.  My congratulations to all for getting so much accomplished.

 

Brian

 

---

From: Iyer, Prakash [mailto:prakash.iyer@INTEL.COM]
Sent: Friday, June 25, 2004 8:36 AM
To: STDS-802-16-MOBILE@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG
Subject: [STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [Handoff]Minutes from 6/24 telecon

 

 

The following harmonized contributions will be submitted as HO adhoc consensus contributions prior to the 5 PM deadline on 6/25. Please submit these using the standard naming conventions (see Brian's earlier email on this subject) to the TGe upload directory (not the temporary file store). Revisions may be needed next week based on more thorough review from the group.

1. HO optimization flags r2
- NOTE to Phil Barber - Ronny Kim has asked that text related to data pending flag + 2 backbone messages be added as informative text per prior emails on this subject.

- Ronny will try to provide some sample text to Phil on above points.
- NOTE to Phil - request to add text to further clarify the definition and purpose of bit #3 (omit network address acquisition management messages) in HO optimization flags

- Unresolved OPEN (Jung-won/Ronny) - currently there are no HO optimization flags to indicate if an MSS has pending data to transmit on the UL during HO and IP address acquisition should be delayed. Needs further analysis but will not gate submission of this contribution today.

- Phil will submit a comment with this contribution

2. NBR-ADV r0
- This is a revision to the MOB-NBR-ADV message as discussed during the handoff adhoc F2F. There was no other feedback during the call.

- Phil will submit a comment with this contribution

3. Method for scanning neighbor BSs periodically
- Again, no specific issues were raised regarding this contribution
- Kihyoung will submit a comment with this contribution

4. Clarification of Paging Announce
- Jungje and BJ Kim discussed Jungje's objection to deleting PAGING CYCLE and PAGING OFFSET in the Paging Announce message. The issue was resolved and these 2 fields will be reincorporated in the Paging Announce message.

- BJ Kim will submit a comment with this contribution

5. 55r5 - resource retain time
- Only suggested correction was to fix the title on the second page.
- Jungje Son will submit a comment with this contribution

The following contributions will be submitted by the respective contribution authors as non-consensus contributions. Discusssions will continue on the reflector next week to determine if one or more of these could be revised as needed and elevated to consensus contributions.

* Define_HO_Rangingcodes rev
- Jungje Son will submit with a comment

* Safety Channel HO
- Jungje Son will submit as a comment

* Soft HO (SHO) and Fast BS Switching (FBSS)
- Harmonization process continued among contribution authors. A preliminary harmonized contribution will be submitted before the Friday deadline.

- Current plan is to combine PHY contributions into one and MAC contributions for SHO and FBSS into one.
- Mo-Han Fong / Mary Chion will submit comments with these contributions

We also discussed the following new contributions, with resolution as under:
* Neighbor scanning and preferred cells - Kamran/Masoud
- The contribution wanted to confirm if NBR-ADV is broadcast or unicast - answer is broadcast
- The contributions also recommends support for 3 logical levels of preferred neighbor BSs. This may be an implementation/operational issue and not a spec issue

- Kamran/Masoud will submit a comment for discussion at the July meeting in Portland

* C802.16e-04_120r1 - Branislav
- Contribution was discussed. Ronny Kim's opinion was that Bit #3 in HO optimization flags serves the same purpose as the NBR-ADV flag proposed in this contribution.

- Ronny Kim to send out a brief response regarding this contribution to the reflector
- Author might want to submit as personal contribution anyway before the Friday deadline and revise later based on HO adhoc group input