Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

[STDS-802-16] Fw: 16e PAR Change text proposal - Further revisions



The attached corespondence have been forwarded to me this (Friday) evening.
I don't understand why such major changes in the PAR are not discussed openly through the reflector. I was not on the list, and so I believe could be the case for other members, observers and  others.
I am totally against  the changes proposed, except for the the editorial change of 802.16a to 802.16-2004.   Backwards compatibilty should not be compromised. IMHO, it is important to keep one foot on the ground, so the speak, namely if one implements the scaleable OFDMA mode it has to be fully compatible with 2k BS.  There was never an intention to  invent a new mode in 802.16e, that won't be fully compatible with at least on of the existing ones. Accepting the changes would make the other modes practically obsolete and  jeopardize the efforts of the current implementors.
 
I move to table the issue till the next meeting (#32)
 
Avi Freedman
 
-----Original Message-----
From: Kiernan, Brian G. [mailto:Brian.Kiernan@InterDigital.com]
Sent: Friday, May 14, 2004 17:10
To: Puthenkulam, Jose P; panyuh@samsung.com; Joonho Park; gengwu@nortelnetworks.com; jhumbe01@sprintspectrum.com; elindskog@beceem.com; jeff_harrang@srtelecom.com; cseagr01@sprintspectrum.com; Adam Kerr; Aditya Agrawal; Aik Chindapol; Arthur Wang; Bob Nelson; Bogdan Franovici; Brian Banister; Brian Carroll ; Brian Eidson; Brian Johnson; Carl.Eklund@nokia.com; Changhoi Koo; Claude Royer; Dale Branlund; Dave Trinkwon; David Castelow; David Maez ; Dean Chang; Don Leimer; Dov Andelman; Eyal Verbin; Frank Draper ; Giulio Cavalli; Gordon Antonello; Greg Phillips ; ikelly03@sprintspectrum.com; Irving Wang; Itzik Kitroser; J Pierre Lamoureux; James Simkins; Jim Dickerman; Jing Wang; John Haskins; Jon Labs; Jun Han; Jun Wu; Keith Doucet; Ken Stanwood ; Kevin Suitor; Lalit Kotecha; Lei Wang; Les Eastwood; Mano Vafai; Marianna Goldhammer; Mark Cudak; Martin Lysejko; Max Riegel; Mihnea Moldoveanu; N. K. Shankar; Naftali Chayat; Nico.Vanwaes@nokia.com; Nir Metzer; Ofer Kelman; Paul Odlyzko; Paul Petrus; Phillip Barber; Pierre Lopez; Radu Selea; Raja Banerjea; Rajesh Bhalla; Rehan Jalil; Reza Golshan; Roland Muenzner; Ron Murias; Russ Reynolds; Russell Mckown; Sai Subramanian; Shawn Taylor; Stevenson, Carl R (Carl); Tal Kaitz; Todd Chauvin; Vladimir Yanover; Weidong Yang; Wen Tong; Yigal Leiba; Yonggang Fang; Yossi Segal; Zion Hadad; Agis, Ed; Al Dabagh, Baraa; Altman, Asher; Bakshi, Sanjay; Bhamidipati, Sriram; Bright, Norman; Brombaugh, Eric M; Chakravarthy, Rohini; Chou, Joey; Davidovici, Sorin; Eliaspur, Yigal; Eline, Roger J; Foerster, Jeffrey R; Gotman, Max; Hahn, Yung; Ho, Minnie; Iyer, Prakash; Jacobsen, Eric A; Johnston, Dj; Kibria, Masud; Koshy, Kamal; Kravstov, Vladimir; LaBrecque, Margaret; Lo, Jonathan; McCallum, Ian; Mclaughlin, Eric A; Mintz, Yaacov; Mitchel, Henry; Nagar, Eyal; Ovadia, Shlomo; Perlman, Shuki; Putzolu, David; Qi, Xiao-Feng; Qian, Xiaoshu; Raichura, Jitendra P; Resnick, Ronald J; Ring, Desmond S; Rogers, Chris B; Rosner, Gedon; Rossi, Marc; Salvekar, Atul A; Schwartz, Randall C; Sheiman, Arthur; Sydir, Jerry; Teckman, Tim; Thakur, Anshuman; Walker, Jesse; Yaghoobi, Hassan; Roger B. Marks
Subject: RE: 16e PAR Change text proposal - Further revisions

Suggested Change 3 to Paragraph #18: Change “needs to” to “shall”.

 

Brian

 


From: Puthenkulam, Jose P [mailto:jose.p.puthenkulam@intel.com]
Sent: Friday, May 14, 2004 2:58 AM
To: Puthenkulam, Jose P; panyuh@samsung.com; Joonho Park; gengwu@nortelnetworks.com; jhumbe01@sprintspectrum.com; elindskog@beceem.com; jeff_harrang@srtelecom.com; cseagr01@sprintspectrum.com; Adam Kerr; Aditya Agrawal; Aik Chindapol; Arthur Wang; Bob Nelson; Bogdan Franovici; Brian Banister; Brian Carroll ; Brian Eidson; Brian Johnson; Kiernan, Brian G.; Carl.Eklund@nokia.com; Changhoi Koo; Claude Royer; Dale Branlund; Dave Trinkwon; David Castelow; David Maez ; Dean Chang; Don Leimer; Dov Andelman; Eyal Verbin; Frank Draper ; Giulio Cavalli; Gordon Antonello; Greg Phillips ; ikelly03@sprintspectrum.com; Irving Wang; Itzik Kitroser; J Pierre Lamoureux; James Simkins; Jim Dickerman; Jing Wang; John Haskins; Jon Labs; Jun Han; Jun Wu; Keith Doucet; Ken Stanwood ; Kevin Suitor; Lalit Kotecha; Lei Wang; Les Eastwood; Mano Vafai; Marianna Goldhammer; Mark Cudak; Martin Lysejko; Max Riegel; Mihnea Moldoveanu; N. K. Shankar; Naftali Chayat; Nico.Vanwaes@nokia.com; Nir Metzer; Ofer Kelman; Paul Odlyzko; Paul Petrus; Phillip Barber; Pierre Lopez; Radu Selea; Raja Banerjea; Rajesh Bhalla; Rehan Jalil; Reza Golshan; Roland Muenzner; Ron Murias; Russ Reynolds; Russell Mckown; Sai Subramanian; Shawn Taylor; Stevenson, Carl R (Carl); Tal Kaitz; Todd Chauvin; Vladimir Yanover; Weidong Yang; Wen Tong; Yigal Leiba; Yonggang Fang; Yossi Segal; Zion Hadad; Agis, Ed; Al Dabagh, Baraa; Altman, Asher; Bakshi, Sanjay; Bhamidipati, Sriram; Bright, Norman; Brombaugh, Eric M; Chakravarthy, Rohini; Chou, Joey; Davidovici, Sorin; Eliaspur, Yigal; Eline, Roger J; Foerster, Jeffrey R; Gotman, Max; Hahn, Yung; Ho, Minnie; Iyer, Prakash; Jacobsen, Eric A; Johnston, Dj; Kibria, Masud; Koshy, Kamal; Kravstov, Vladimir; LaBrecque, Margaret; Lo, Jonathan; McCallum, Ian; Mclaughlin, Eric A; Mintz, Yaacov; Mitchel, Henry; Nagar, Eyal; Ovadia, Shlomo; Perlman, Shuki; Putzolu, David; Qi, Xiao-Feng; Qian, Xiaoshu; Raichura, Jitendra P; Resnick, Ronald J; Ring, Desmond S; Rogers, Chris B; Rosner, Gedon; Rossi, Marc; Salvekar, Atul A; Schwartz, Randall C; Sheiman, Arthur; Sydir, Jerry; Teckman, Tim; Thakur, Anshuman; Walker, Jesse; Yaghoobi, Hassan; Roger B. Marks
Subject: RE: 16e PAR Change text proposal - Further revisions

 

Hi All,

 

After getting feedback from several folks here is yet another revision of the text with more changes in item 18.

 

12. Scope of Proposed Project states

 

This document provides enhancements to IEEE Std 802.16/802.16a to support subscriber stations moving at vehicular speeds and thereby specifies a system for combined fixed and mobile broadband wireless access. Functions to support higher layer handoff between base stations or sectors are specified. Operation is limited to licensed bands suitable for mobility between 2 and 6 GHz. Fixed 802.16a subscriber capabilities shall not be compromised (See Item #18).

 

Changes suggested:

  1. Change “802.16a” to “802.16-2004”
  2. Delete the last sentence “Fixed 802.16a subscriber capabilities shall not be compromised (See Item #18)”.

 

18 Additional Explanatory Notes: (Item Number and Explanation)

Item #12 - Subscriber stations specified herein, when stationary, shall interoperate with base stations specified in IEEE Std 802.16a. Base stations specified herein shall interoperate with stationary subscriber stations specified in IEEE Std 802.16a. Because the standard will utilize the 802.16/802.16a medium access control layer, it will support multimedia services requiring differentiated Quality of Service, and it will support adaptive physical link control so that subscriber stations can receive higher-rate service when they move more slowly, include more effective antennas, or are otherwise in better link conditions.

 

Changes suggested:

  1. Modify first sentence to “Subscriber stations specified herein, when stationary shall interoperate with base stations specified in 802.16-2004 that use the same physical layer mode (SC, OFDM, OFDMA)”.
  2. Modify second sentence to “Base stations specified herein shall interoperate with stationary subscriber stations specified in IEEE Std 802.16-2004 that use the same physical layer mode (SC, OFDM or OFDMA)”.
  3. Insert new third sentence “Additional mobility enhancements based on scaled FFT sizes may be specified, but for those sizes specified in IEEE Std 802.16-2004 within the same physical layer mode there needs to be backwards compatibility”.
  4. Replace “802.16a” with “802.16-2004” in fourth sentence.

 

 

Thanks to Roger and Brian for their valuable suggestions. Hope you can review and provide feedback for this.

 

Best regards,

jose

 

______________________________

Jose Puthenkulam

Network Architect (802.16 Stds) 

Mobile Networking Lab,

Communication Technology Lab

Intel Corporation

Tel : (503) 264 6121

Cell: (503) 7016922

 


From: Puthenkulam, Jose P
Sent: Wednesday, May 12, 2004 10:53 PM
To: 'panyuh@samsung.com'; Joonho Park; 'gengwu@nortelnetworks.com'; 'jhumbe01@sprintspectrum.com'; 'elindskog@beceem.com'; 'jeff_harrang@srtelecom.com'; 'cseagr01@sprintspectrum.com'; Adam Kerr; Aditya Agrawal; Aik Chindapol; Arthur Wang; Bob Nelson; Bogdan Franovici; Brian Banister; Brian Carroll ; Brian Eidson; Brian Johnson; Brian Kiernan; 'Carl.Eklund@nokia.com'; Changhoi Koo; Claude Royer; Dale Branlund; Dave Trinkwon; David Castelow; David Maez ; Dean Chang; Don Leimer; Dov Andelman; Eyal Verbin; Frank Draper ; Giulio Cavalli; Gordon Antonello; Greg Phillips ; ikelly03@sprintspectrum.com; Irving Wang; Itzik Kitroser; J Pierre Lamoureux; James Simkins; Jim Dickerman; Jing Wang; John Haskins; Jon Labs; Jun Han; Jun Wu; Keith Doucet; Ken Stanwood ; Kevin Suitor; Lalit Kotecha; Lei Wang; Les Eastwood; Mano Vafai; Marianna Goldhammer; Mark Cudak; Martin Lysejko; Max Riegel; Mihnea Moldoveanu; N. K. Shankar; Naftali Chayat; 'Nico.Vanwaes@nokia.com'; Nir Metzer; Ofer Kelman; Paul Odlyzko; Paul Petrus; Phillip Barber; Pierre Lopez; Radu Selea; Raja Banerjea; Rajesh Bhalla; Rehan Jalil; Reza Golshan; Roland Muenzner; Ron Murias; Russ Reynolds; Russell Mckown; Sai Subramanian; Shawn Taylor; Stevenson, Carl R (Carl); Tal Kaitz; Todd Chauvin; Vladimir Yanover; Weidong Yang; Wen Tong; Yigal Leiba; Yonggang Fang; Yossi Segal; Zion Hadad; Agis, Ed; Al Dabagh, Baraa; Altman, Asher; Bakshi, Sanjay; Bhamidipati, Sriram; Bright, Norman; Brombaugh, Eric M; Chakravarthy, Rohini; Chou, Joey; Davidovici, Sorin; Eliaspur, Yigal; Eline, Roger J; Foerster, Jeffrey R; Gotman, Max; Hahn, Yung; Ho, Minnie; Iyer, Prakash; Jacobsen, Eric A; Johnston, Dj; Kibria, Masud; Koshy, Kamal; Kravstov, Vladimir; LaBrecque, Margaret; Lo, Jonathan; McCallum, Ian; Mclaughlin, Eric A; Mintz, Yaacov; Mitchel, Henry; Nagar, Eyal; Ovadia, Shlomo; Perlman, Shuki; Puthenkulam, Jose P; Putzolu, David; Qi, Xiao-Feng; Qian, Xiaoshu; Raichura, Jitendra P; Resnick, Ronald J; Ring, Desmond S; Rogers, Chris B; Rosner, Gedon; Rossi, Marc; Salvekar, Atul A; Schwartz, Randall C; Sheiman, Arthur; Sydir, Jerry; Teckman, Tim; Thakur, Anshuman; Walker, Jesse; Yaghoobi, Hassan
Subject: 16e PAR Change text proposal

 

Hi All,

 

At the Seattle Face-to-Face 802.16 Pre-meeting we discussed the need to modify the 16e PAR to remove the need for interoperability for the Scalable OFDMA FFT profiles from 128-1k with the REVd physical layer profiles. This is because some MSS may only implement some of the FFT sizes based on the channel widths and currently the 2k mode is mandated in 16e for compatibility reasons and it is a difficult requirement to meet for all solutions.

 

Hence the following changes to the 16e PAR text were prepared at the Seattle meeting. Hope you can all review and provide feedback on whether this text is acceptable. (Current PAR is here http://ieee802.org/16/docs/02/80216-02_48r4.pdf )

 

12. Scope of Proposed Project states

 

This document provides enhancements to IEEE Std 802.16/802.16a to support subscriber stations moving at vehicular speeds and thereby specifies a system for combined fixed and mobile broadband wireless access. Functions to support higher layer handoff between base stations or sectors are specified. Operation is limited to licensed bands suitable for mobility between 2 and 6 GHz. Fixed 802.16a subscriber capabilities shall not be compromised (See Item #18).

 

Changes suggested:

  1. Change “802.16a” to “802.16REVd”
  2. Delete the last sentence “Fixed 802.16a subscriber capabilities shall not be compromised (See Item #18)”.

 

Reason for deleting the last sentence was that one could not properly interpret what would essentially compromise a 802.16a subscriber. Also as the standard upfront states that it is an amendment there seemed to be no need for this sentence.

 

18 Additional Explanatory Notes: (Item Number and Explanation)

Item #12 - Subscriber stations specified herein, when stationary, shall interoperate with base stations specified in IEEE Std 802.16a. Base stations specified herein shall interoperate with stationary subscriber stations specified in IEEE Std 802.16a. Because the standard will utilize the 802.16/802.16a medium access control layer, it will support multimedia services requiring differentiated Quality of Service, and it will support adaptive physical link control so that subscriber stations can receive higher-rate service when they move more slowly, include more effective antennas, or are otherwise in better link conditions.

 

Changes suggested:

  1. Modify first sentence to “Subscriber stations specified herein shall interoperate with base stations when using the same physical layer profiles specified in IEEE Std 802.16REVd. ”.
  2. Modify second sentence to “Base stations specified herein shall interoperate with stationary subscriber stations when using the same physical layer profiles specified in 802.16REVd.” 
  3. Replace “802.16a” with “802.16REVd” in third sentence.

 

So this text essentially made the scope of interoperability more explicit.

 

Please try your best to give feedback by at least by Friday 5/14 morning.

 

Thanks & best regards,

jose

 

______________________________

Jose Puthenkulam

Network Architect (802.16 Stds) 

Mobile Networking Lab,

Communication Technology Lab

Intel Corporation

Tel : (503) 264 6121

Cell: (503) 7016922