----- Original Message -----
Sent: Tuesday, July 27, 2004 12:15
AM
Subject: [STDS-802-16]
[STDS-802-16-MOBILE] [HARMONIZATION] 7/26 Telecon agenda; inventory of
comments/contribs
Telecon Reminder:
Monday, July 26th, 8 PM U.S. Pacific Time
- 916-356-2663, Bridge: 2, Passcode: 9856750
Proposed Agenda:
* Review inventory of comments / contributions
as starting point for harmonization adhoc (see list below)
* Review plans / proposals for new
contributions within scope of letter ballot recirc.
* Start reviewing categories listed
below.
Comments / Contributions
Inventory:
As a first step
to the harmonization effort, we need to inventory comments/contributions
that were withdrawn or rejected in Portland but which may be candidates to
work from. I have summarized below what I believe are all of these comments
and contributions based on the final USR file. Also, after the D4 draft
becomes available, gaps / inconsistencies might emerge which we will have to
address in this adhoc.
Category: MBS
Support:
* Comment 341
(Contrib. 04/201r1) - Enhanced broadcast / multicast capabilities - was
rejected
Yong Chang's brief email on
this:
This is the
harmonized contribution with the following:
-
Comment 538/Contribution 191: Multicast CID assignment for Multicast and
Broadcast Service in IEEE 80216e
- Contribution 193: Channel
Request messages for Multicast and Broadcast Service in IEEE
80216e
- Comment 342/Contribution 195: A New MAP IE for Group
Messaging Service in IEEE 80216e
The proposal in this
contribution is that:
1. Multicast transport CID is defined and is
used for differentiating the multicast and broadcast content.
2.
MBS_MAP IE is used for support the power saving in idle mode.
3. MBS_ZONE IE is used for support
the mechani sm to let the MSS know whether or not MBS related session and
security information are changed
The Zone_Switch IE is used for the
MSS to change the DL-MAP information after detection of MBS_Zone
change.
4. MBS Security is out of scope of this contribution
because it has already accepted
In addition to these
contributions, there were another contributions for MBS:
-
Comment 338/Contribution 196: Live Poll messages for Multicast and Broadcast
Service in IEEE 80216e
- Contribution 194: Multicast Group
Membership Query message for Multicast and Broadcast Service in IEEE
80216e
Related
PHY(MBS) contribution (which this adhoc will not
discuss)
- Comment 417/Contribution
169r1: Enhanced feature for multimedia broadcasting
The contribution proposed the time-diversity
effect in addition to macro-diversity effect.
Category: Handover Support:
* Comment 353 (Contrib. 04/156r1) - Safety
Channel HO - was rejected
* Complete
Soft HO and Fast BS switching contribution - especially Fast feedback
channel and SDLs
* Comment 483
(backbone signaling) - this is ruled out of scope, so do we want to come up
with requirements / assumptions for another TG to work on or perhaps propose
informative text on assumptions for handover support?
* Comment 530 - was withdrawn. Related comment
is 532 which was rejected.
* Does the
spec cover all frequency reuse scenarios such as 1x3 (question posed by
carriers)
* Preferred base stations
for handoffs - contribution 04/142
Category: Idle mode and Paging
Support:
* Comment 527
(Contrib. 04/222) - Enhanced paging in MOB-PAG-ADV - was rejected
Category: Scanning and Association
related Optimizations:
* Comment 315 (Contrib. 04/167r2) - Enhancement of
scanning and association
Category: Fixes to SDLs and informative text in
Annexes:
* No
contributions on this to date
Category: Miscellaneous:
* Comment 309 (Periodic ranging while in
Sleep mode) - was rejected
* Comment
310 (Contrib. 04/194r1) - was rejected
* Comment 324 (Service Level Prediction) - was
rejected
* Comment 370 (Contrib.
04/48r4) - was rejected
* Comment 537
(Contrib. 04/213r2) - was rejected
Plus - Following comments were withdrawn, do
we need to revisit them -
#293
#294