Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

[STDS-802-16] corrected IEEE 802.16 Letter Ballot #20 results



Folks,

My previous Letter Ballot #20 was incomplete. The last update missed 
the latest voters. My apologies.

I have updated the report. The approval ratio is 55%.

Roger

>Working Group Letter Ballot #20 closed on March. The results are here:
>	http://ieee802.org/16/netman/ballot20/report20.html
>
>The approval ratio is 69%, below the minimum of 75% required for 
>approval. However, if comment resolution is successful, the ballot 
>can still pass.
>
>The database has been very difficult to compile. People have become 
>very casual about following the correct format, remembering to enter 
>their name, getting their names in the right order, etc. Also, a 
>huge number of duplicate comments were submitted. Of 749 comments, 
>only 257 are unique; the rest are exact duplicates. It was a lot of 
>work for me to separate these. However, I've done so because it 
>would be a lot harder for everyone else to have to review 749 
>comments and figure out which ones they'd already done.
>
>Here is the comment report:
>	<http://ieee802.org/16/docs/06/80216-06_014.zip>
>
>The unique comments are numbered 1-257 and are marked in the 
>check-box. Those are the only ones you will see when you open the 
>file. The duplicates comments are separate records, all currently 
>hidden and all with the comment number "D". We may give them unique 
>numbers later. This is a different method than I've used in the past 
>for duplicates; I think it will make it easier to track which 
>resolutions have been accepted by which people. You should just 
>ignore the duplicates.
>
>I'll check with Phil to see what he wants to do about Reply Comments.
>
>Roger
>
>
>>To:  IEEE 802.16 Reflector
>>bcc: IEEE 802.16 Working Group Members <http://ieee802.org/16/members.html>
>>
>>IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #20 is now open, through 1 
>>March 2006 AOE. The ballot is on the following question:
>>
>>*"To forward to the IEEE 802 LMSC Executive Committee, for IEEE-SA 
>>Sponsor Ballot, IEEE P802.16g-06/D1."
>>
>>The announcement document:
>>  Title: "IEEE 802.16 Working Group Letter Ballot #20: Announcement"
>>  Document Number: IEEE 802.16-06/007r1
>>  URL: <http://ieee802.org/16/docs/06/80216-06_007r1.pdf>
>>
>>details the procedures. It also tells you how to participate and 
>>explains the Members' obligation to do so. "Membership shall be 
>>lost if two consecutive, or two of any three consecutive, Working 
>>Group letter ballots for which the member was eligible are not 
>>returned or are returned with an abstention other than for 'lack of 
>>technical expertise'." You can check your recent balloting history:
>>	<http://ieee802.org/16/tgc/C4/ballot18/report18ini.html>
>>	<http://ieee802.org/16/netman/ballot19/report19.html>.
>>
>>Don't forget the deadline of 1 March 2006.
>>
>>The ballot submission form is available at:
>>	http://dot16.org/ballot20/ballotform20.html
>>
>>Results will be posted, as they are received, at:
>>	http://ieee802.org/16/netman/ballot20/report20.html
>>
>>Roger
>>
>