Thread Links Date Links
Thread Prev Thread Next Thread Index Date Prev Date Next Date Index

Re: [STDS-802-16] Cal for Reply Comments on TGm SDD Comment Database



Re-posting. For some reason did not go through the first time.

 

Thanks,

Phil

 


From: Phillip Barber [mailto:pbarber@broadbandmobiletech.com]
Sent: Wednesday, September 10, 2008 6:44 PM
To: 'STDS-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG'
Cc: 'Roger B. Marks'
Subject: RE: [STDS-802-16] Call for Reply Comments on TGm SDD Comment Database

 

All TGm Participants,

 

To provide a little more detail on instances where different topic identifier tags were assigned than that indicated by the commenter:

 

Twenty-nine comments were judged to actually be ‘SDD Cleanup – PHY’ but were labeled by their commenter as ‘PHY: Text’, which was a tag reserved for the output of the PHY Text Rapporteur Group output, as provided by the PHY Text RG Chair. All such comments have been reassigned to ‘SDD Cleanup – PHY’.

 

Eighteen comments submitted with the tag ‘PHY: MIMO’ were judged to instead be ‘SDD Cleanup – PHY’ as they primarily seemed to deal with modification of existing text in the MIMO section of the SDD, and did not appear to be topics under current review in the MIMO Rapporteur Group.

 

There were some forty-four additional comments submitted inappropriately and against instruction as ‘PHY: HARQ’, ‘PHY: MIMO’, or ‘MAC: Idle Mode’. These topic tags were, again, reserved for the output of the respective Rapporteur Groups, as provided by the RG Chair(s). Participants were instructed that they were to instead submit Reply Comments, not original comments, against the RG outputs on these topics. All of these comments have been tagged as ‘out-of-scope’.

 

Two additional comments were tagged ‘out-of-scope’ because they identified themselves as dealing with material not in the CfC&C.

 

 

Participants are encouraged to review the RG output comments and contributions and avail themselves of the opportunity to file Reply Comments to recommend add/remove/changes to RG text. This encouragement is extended to specifically include those whose original comments on RG topics were tagged ‘out-of-scope’. Note that final RG revision uploads are not due until Sept 12 AOE. Participants may choose to prepare and withhold Reply Comments until after reviewing the final pre-Session revision of the RG consensus output comments and contributions.

  

As Roger indicated in his invitation for Reply Comment email announcement, participants—both the owners of the comments as well as other participants—have the opportunity in the Reply Comment process to recommend changes to the tag assignment for all comments.

 

Thanks,
Phillip Barber
Chief Scientist
Wireless Advanced Research and Standards
Huawei Technologies Co., LTD.

 
Rapporteur Group Chair Coordinator, IEEE 802.16 TGm


From: Roger B. Marks [mailto:r.b.marks@IEEE.ORG]
Sent: Wednesday, September 10, 2008 6:09 PM
To: STDS-802-16@LISTSERV.IEEE.ORG
Subject: [STDS-802-16] Call for Reply Comments on TGm SDD Comment Database

 

The IEEE 802.16 TGm SDD Call for Contributions and Comments (CfC&C) IEEE 802.16m-08/033 <http://ieee802.org/16/tgm/#08_033> closed on 5 Sept. The 613 comments received have been compiled into a Commentary database and posted as IEEE 802.16m-08/034r2 <http://ieee802.org/16/tgm/#08_034>.

 

This note is a Call for Reply Comments, with a deadline of Monday 15 Sept at 8 pm local time in Kobe, Japan <http://tinyurl.com/5jzku5>.

 

Comments were requested to identify a specific topic in the CfC&C. This identification is primarily intended as a tool for process control, agenda planning, and resolution assignment. TGm leadership has reviewed the comments and assigned topic identifiers for all comments, in most cases in alignment with the recommendation of the commenter. The assigned topic has been identified in the Commentary database tool by a new ‘Comment Tag:’ field that you will see just below the Suggested Remedy. The following tags are assigned:

 

SDD Cleanup - MAC
SDD Cleanup - PHY
Text
Link
HARQ
MIMO
HO
Idle Mode
Sleep Mode
Data Plane
Network Entry
Connection
Location Services - MAC
Location Services - PHY
Enhanced MBS - MAC
Enhanced MBS - PHY
Multi - Carrier - MAC
Multi - Carrier - PHY
Security - MAC
Security - PHY
Multi-Radio Coexistence - MAC
Multi-Radio Coexistence - PHY
Editorial
Out of Scope

 

Reply comments may include a request (explained in free-form text) to revise the Comment Tag. 

 

The Commentary file will open to the view in which you can begin entering reply comments. Use the "Submit Reply Comments" tab in the upper right corner to export your replies to a file for uploading, per the embedded instructions. Reply comments, in "cmtr" format, need to be uploaded to the "TGm" folder at <http://upload.wirelessman.org>.

 

Roger